重症患者的临终:照护者临终体验评估(EOLE研究)
该研究纳入2018年4月至6月52个ICU中连续死亡的510例成年患者,其中403例经历放弃/撤除治疗决策,362例实际撤除治疗。主要终点为CAESAR问卷评估的临终体验,护士平均得分为55/75(±6),医生为62/75(±5)(P < 0.001)。次要终点Numeric Analogic Scale护士为8(±2),医生为8(±2)(P = 0.06)。多因素分析显示,照护者间对生命支持强度意见不一致、死亡当天使用无创通气及监测和血液检查与护士评分较低相关;死亡当天进行心肺复苏与医生评分较低相关。作者认为,改善护士在临终过程中的参与、减少侵入性治疗可能改善护士和医生的临终体验。
要点
- 510例ICU死亡患者中,403例经历放弃/撤除治疗决策,362例实际撤除治疗。
- CAESAR评分护士平均55/75(±6)低于医生62/75(±5),差异有统计学意义(P < 0.001)。
- Numeric Analogic Scale护士8(±2)与医生8(±2)无显著差异(P = 0.06)。
- 有放弃/撤除治疗决策的患者,护士和医生的CAESAR评分及Numeric Analogic Scale均显著更高。
- 实际撤除治疗的362例中,照护者间对生命支持强度意见不一致、死亡当天无创通气及监测和血液检查与护士评分较低相关;死亡当天心肺复苏与医生评分较低相关。
适用人群与场景
- 2018年4月至6月在52个ICU中连续死亡的成年患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- CAESAR问卷共15个条目,每条目评分从1(创伤性体验)到5(安慰性体验),总分15至75分,分数越高体验越好。
- Numeric Analogic Scale评分从0(最差临终)到10(最佳临终)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为多中心评估性研究,纳入52个ICU中连续死亡的510例成年患者,其中403例经历放弃/撤除治疗决策,362例实际撤除治疗。
- 主要终点CAESAR评分:护士平均55/75(±6)vs 医生平均62/75(±5),P < 0.001。
- 次要终点Numeric Analogic Scale:护士平均8(±2)vs 医生平均8(±2),P = 0.06。
- CAESAR评分与Numeric Analogic Scale显著但弱相关;有放弃/撤除治疗决策的患者,护士和医生的CAESAR评分及Numeric Analogic Scale均显著更高。
- 多因素分析(362例实际撤除治疗患者):照护者间对生命支持强度意见不一致、死亡当天使用无创通气及监测和血液检查与护士评分较低相关;死亡当天进行心肺复苏与医生评分较低相关。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:多中心评估性研究(EOLE研究),注册号ClinicalTrial.gov: NCT03392857。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,改善护士在临终过程中的参与、减少侵入性治疗可能改善护士和医生的临终体验。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The death rate in intensive care units (ICUs) can reach 20%. More than half occurs after a decision of care withholding/withdrawal. We aimed at describing and evaluating the experience of ICU physicians and nurses involved in the end-of-life (EOL) procedure. Primary objective was the evaluation of the experience of EOL assessed by the CAESAR questionnaire. Secondary objectives were to describe factors associated with a low or high score and to examine the association between Numeric Analogic Scale and quality of EOL.
METHODS: Consecutive adult patients deceased in 52 ICUs were included between April and June 2018. Characteristics of patients and caregivers, therapeutics and care involved after withdrawal were recorded. CAESAR score included 15 items, rated from 1 (traumatic experience) to 5 (comforting experience). The sum was rated from 15 to 75 (the highest, the best experience). Numeric Analogic Scale was rated from 0 (worst EOL) to 10 (optimal EOL).
RESULTS: Five hundred and ten patients were included, 403 underwent decision of care withholding/withdrawal, and among them 362 underwent effective care withdrawal. Among the 510 patients, mean CAESAR score was 55/75 (± 6) for nurses and 62/75 (± 5) for physicians (P < 0.001). Mean Numeric Analogic Scale was 8 (± 2) for nurses and 8 (± 2) for physicians (P = 0.06). CAESAR score and Numeric Analogic Scale were significantly but weakly correlated. They were significantly higher for both nurses and physicians if the patient died after a decision of withholding/withdrawal. In multivariable analysis, among the 362 patients with effective care withdrawal, disagreement on the intensity of life support between caregivers, non-invasive ventilation and monitoring and blood tests the day of death were associated with lower score for nurses. For physicians, cardiopulmonary resuscitation the day of death was associated with lower score in multivariable analysis.
CONCLUSION: Experience of EOL was better in patients with withholding/withdrawal decision as compared to those without. Our results suggest that improvement of nurses' participation in the end-of-life process, as well as less invasive care, would probably improve the experience of EOL for both nurses and physicians. Registration: ClinicalTrial.gov: NCT03392857.
参考来源
- End of life in the critically ill patient: evaluation of experience of end of life by caregivers (EOLE study). Ann Intensive Care. 2021. PMID: 34825996. doi:10.1186/s13613-021-00944-z
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。