尼日利亚重症监护室物理治疗师最低临床实践标准专家共识:一项改良德尔菲研究
该改良德尔菲研究旨在就尼日利亚重症监护室(ICU)物理治疗师的最低临床实践标准达成专家共识,以期为未来制定指南奠定基础。研究纳入26名有尼日利亚ICU工作经验的物理治疗师,采用包含222个条目的问卷进行三轮在线德尔菲调查,条目须达到≥70%的共识同意率方可判定为「必要」或「不必要」。第一轮后178项被评为「必要」,第二轮和第三轮修改后分别新增15项和3项为「必要」,共196项达成共识;24项未达成共识;所有轮次后无任何条目被评为「不必要」。第三轮后仍有24名物理治疗师参与。
要点
- 三轮德尔菲后,222个条目中196项被判定为「必要」(第一轮178项,第二轮修改后新增15项,第三轮新增3项)。
- 24项条目未达成共识(共识标准为≥70%同意率)。
- 所有轮次结束后,无任何条目被判定为「不必要」。
- 26名专家物理治疗师完成第一轮,第三轮后仍有24名参与。
- 该共识为尼日利亚ICU物理治疗最低临床实践标准,是未来制定指南的第一步。
适用人群与场景
- 在尼日利亚重症监护室(ICU)工作的物理治疗师。
- 参与本研究的专家为有尼日利亚ICU工作经验的物理治疗师,经目的性抽样招募。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识判定标准:每个条目须达到≥70%的共识同意率,方可被判定为「必要」或「不必要」;参与者对每个条目选择「必要」、「不必要」或「不确定」。
- 未达成共识的条目在后续轮次中通过提供定义或澄清进行修改后再次呈现。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:改良德尔菲技术(在线三轮德尔菲程序);样本量:26名专家物理治疗师完成第一轮,第三轮后仍有24名参与。
- 问卷包含222个关于物理治疗在重症监护中作用的条目;第一轮后178项被评为「必要」,第二轮修改后新增15项,第三轮新增3项,共196项达成「必要」共识。
- 24项条目未达成共识;所有轮次后无任何条目被评为「不必要」。
- 数据分析采用描述性分析。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:专家共识(改良德尔菲研究)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该共识可为尼日利亚ICU物理治疗师的最低临床实践标准提供参考,并作为未来制定指南的第一步。
指南或共识出处
- 本文为尼日利亚ICU物理治疗师最低临床实践标准的专家共识,发表于Afr J Thorac Crit Care Med;原文未提及具体的指南或共识名称。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Management of patients in intensive care units (ICUs) needs staff with a recommended level of expertise and experience owing to the life-threatening nature of illnesses, injuries and complications that these patients present with. There are no specific guidelines governing physiotherapy practice in ICUs in Nigeria. Hence, there is a need to have expert consensus on the minimum clinical standard of practice for physiotherapists working in ICUs as a first step to proposing/developing guidelines in the future.
OBJECTIVES: To assess the expert consensus on the minimum clinical standard of practice for physiotherapists working in ICUs in Nigeria.
METHODS: Physiotherapists with working experience in Nigerian ICUs were purposively recruited into the present study using a modified Delphi technique. A questionnaire comprising 222 question items on the role of physiotherapy in critical care was adopted and administered to the participants over three rounds of Delphi procedure (online). Participants checked either 'essential', 'not essential' or 'unsure' for each question item. For each question item to be considered 'essential' or 'not essential', a consensus agreement ≥70% had to be met. Questions without consensus were further modified by providing definition or clarification and presented in subsequent rounds. Data were analysed descriptively.
RESULTS: We recruited 26 expert physiotherapists who consented to the study and completed the first round of the study. The majority of the physiotherapists (n=24) remained in the study after the third round. A total of 178 question items were adjudged to be 'essential' after the first round, and a further 15 and three additional items were subsequently adjudged to be as 'essential' after modifying the outstanding question items during the second and third rounds, respectively. No consensus was reached for 24 items. None of the question items were ranked as 'not essential' after all the rounds.
CONCLUSION: Expert consensus was achieved for a substantial number of question items regarding knowledge and skills for assessment, condition and treatment items of the questionnaire by experienced critical care physiotherapists in Nigeria.
参考来源
- Idris I, Awotidebe AW, Mukhtar NB, et al. Expert consensus on the minimum clinical standards of practice for Nigerian physiotherapists working in intensive care units: A modified Delphi study. Afr J Thorac Crit Care Med. 2021. PMID: 34761211. doi:10.7196/AJTCCM.2021.v27i3.137
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。