成人持续性脑震荡后症状的非药物治疗:系统评价与Meta分析及指南推荐
该系统评价与Meta分析检索Embase、MEDLINE等数据库至2020年3月3日,纳入19项随机临床试验共2007例参与者(女性1064例,53.0%),评估成人(>18岁)持续性(>4周)脑震荡后症状的7种非药物干预。证据水平从无符合纳入标准的证据到极低和低水平不等;对早期信息与建议、分级体育锻炼、前庭康复、颈背部手法治疗、心理治疗及跨学科协调康复治疗均给出弱推荐;眼动视觉治疗无相关证据,指南小组基于共识给出良好临床实践推荐。作者认为需加强对持续性脑震荡后症状各类干预的研究。
要点
- 证据确定性为极低至低水平,指南小组对早期信息与建议、分级体育锻炼、前庭康复、颈背部手法治疗、心理治疗及跨学科协调康复治疗均给出弱推荐。
- 眼动视觉治疗未检索到相关证据,指南小组基于共识给出良好临床实践推荐。
- 纳入19项随机临床试验共2007例参与者(女性1064例,53.0%),针对成人(>18岁)持续性(>4周)脑震荡后症状。
- 7种干预的证据水平从无符合纳入标准的证据到极低和低水平不等。
适用人群与场景
- 成人(年龄>18岁)持续性脑震荡后症状(>4周)患者。
- 纳入标准:干预性研究且设有对照组,聚焦脑震荡或轻度创伤性脑损伤后症状。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 持续性脑震荡后症状定义为症状持续>4周。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 早期信息与建议:弱推荐。
- 分级体育锻炼:弱推荐。
- 前庭康复:弱推荐。
- 颈背部手法治疗:弱推荐。
- 心理治疗:弱推荐。
- 跨学科协调康复治疗:弱推荐。
- 眼动视觉治疗:无相关证据,指南小组基于共识给出良好临床实践推荐。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统评价与Meta分析:检索Embase、MEDLINE、PsycINFO、CINAHL、PEDro、OTseeker及Cochrane Reviews(通过MEDLINE和Embase),从最早可出版年份至2020年3月3日,采用PRISMA指南提取数据和质量评价,使用AMSTAR工具和Cochrane偏倚风险工具(随机临床试验)评估纳入研究,采用随机效应模型计算合并效应估计,按GRADE框架评级证据并形成推荐。
- 共识别11篇系统评价但未贡献任何原始研究;另行识别并纳入19项随机临床试验,共2007例参与者(女性1064例,53.0%)。
- 7种干预的证据水平从无符合纳入标准的证据到极低和低水平不等。
- 对早期信息与建议、分级体育锻炼、前庭康复、颈背部手法治疗、心理治疗及跨学科协调康复治疗均给出弱推荐;眼动视觉治疗无相关证据,基于共识给出良好临床实践推荐。
- 主要结局为持续性脑震荡后症状的总体负担及反映特定干预重点的另一结局(如分级体育锻炼干预后的躯体功能)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价与Meta分析及指南推荐。
- 证据等级:采用GRADE框架评级,证据确定性为极低至低水平;推荐强度为弱推荐(早期信息与建议、分级体育锻炼、前庭康复、颈背部手法治疗、心理治疗、跨学科协调康复治疗);眼动视觉治疗基于共识给出良好临床实践推荐。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 基于极低至低确定性证据或基于共识,指南小组认为常用非药物干预治疗持续性脑震荡后症状的科学支持较弱,结果与国际指南推荐一致。
- 作者认为需要加强对持续性脑震荡后症状各类干预的研究。
指南或共识出处
- 指南名称:成人持续性脑震荡后症状的非药物治疗:系统评价与Meta分析及指南推荐(JAMA Netw Open)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Persistent (>4 weeks) postconcussion symptoms (PPCS) are challenging for both patients and clinicians. There is uncertainty about the effect of commonly applied nonpharmacological treatments for the management of PPCS.
OBJECTIVE: To systematically assess and summarize evidence for outcomes related to 7 nonpharmacological interventions for PPCS in adults (aged >18 years) and provide recommendations for clinical practice.
DATA SOURCES: Systematic literature searches were performed via Embase, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, CINAHL, PEDro, OTseeker, and Cochrane Reviews (via MEDLINE and Embase) from earliest possible publication year to March 3, 2020. The literature was searched for prior systematic reviews and primary studies. To be included, studies had to be intervention studies with a control group and focus on PPCS.
STUDY SELECTION: A multidisciplinary guideline panel selected interventions based on frequency of use and need for decision support among clinicians, including early information and advice, graded physical exercise, vestibular rehabilitation, manual treatment of neck and back, oculomotor vision treatment, psychological treatment, and interdisciplinary coordinated rehabilitative treatment. To be included, studies had to be intervention studies within the areas of the predefined clinical questions, include a control group, and focus on symptoms after concussion or mild traumatic brain injury.
DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Extraction was performed independently by multiple observers. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines were used for data abstraction and data quality assessment. Included studies were assessed using the Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR) tool and the Cochrane Risk of Bias (randomized clinical trials) tool. Meta-analysis was performed for all interventions where possible. Random-effects models were used to calculate pooled estimates of effects. The level and certainty of evidence was rated and recommendations formulated according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations (GRADE) framework.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: All outcomes were planned before data collection began according to a specified protocol. The primary outcomes were the collective burden of PPCS and another outcome reflecting the focus of a particular intervention (eg, physical functioning after graded exercise intervention).
RESULTS: Eleven systematic reviews were identified but did not contribute any primary studies; 19 randomized clinical trials comprising 2007 participants (1064 women [53.0%]) were separately identified and included. Evidence for the 7 interventions ranged from no evidence meeting the inclusion criteria to very low and low levels of evidence. Recommendations were weak for early information and advice, graded physical exercise, vestibular rehabilitation, manual treatment of the neck and back, psychological treatment, and interdisciplinary coordinated rehabilitative treatment. No relevant evidence was identified for oculomotor vision treatment, so the panel provided a good clinical practice recommendation based on consensus.
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Based on very low to low certainty of evidence or based on consensus, the guideline panel found weak scientific support for commonly applied nonpharmacological interventions to treat PPCS. Results align with recommendations in international guidelines. Intensified research into all types of intervention for PPCS is needed.
参考来源
- Rytter HM, Graff HJ, Henriksen HK, et al. Nonpharmacological Treatment of Persistent Postconcussion Symptoms in Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis and Guideline Recommendation. JAMA Netw Open. 2021. PMID: 34751759. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.32221
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。