骨科创伤专科培训匹配中虚拟面试使用的建议:申请人及专科培训主任视角的调查
该研究在2019和2020年骨科创伤专科培训匹配后,向所有匹配申请人和骨科创伤专科培训主任(FD)发放网络调查,分别有31名申请人和23名FD完成,回复率为34%和38%。68%的申请人和17%的FD完成了虚拟面试;29%的申请人认为能熟悉项目文化,38%对展示自我能力满意;62%能舒适地基于虚拟面试对项目排名,但38%报告该形式使其将某项目排名降低;77%的申请人偏好现场面试。75%的FD报告虚拟面试限制其熟悉申请人,仅50%能舒适地对申请人排名;78%的FD认为虚拟面试在专科培训匹配中有作用。97%的申请人担心选择虚拟面试传递较少兴趣,43%的FD会将其解读为较少兴趣。作者基于双方视角提出建议以指导实施。
要点
- 77%的申请人偏好现场面试;62%能舒适地基于虚拟面试对项目排名,但38%报告虚拟面试使其将某项目排名降低。
- 75%的FD报告虚拟面试限制其熟悉申请人,仅50%能舒适地对申请人排名;78%的FD认为虚拟面试在匹配中有作用。
- 97%的申请人担心选择虚拟面试传递较少兴趣,43%的FD会将其解读为较少兴趣。
- 68%的申请人和17%的FD完成了虚拟面试;29%的申请人认为能熟悉项目文化,38%对展示自我能力满意。
适用人群与场景
- 2019至2020年骨科创伤专科培训匹配的匹配申请人(31名完成调查)和骨科创伤专科培训主任(23名完成调查)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为基于2019至2020年骨科创伤专科培训面试经验的网络调查;31名申请人和23名FD完成调查,回复率分别为34%和38%。
- 68%的申请人和17%的FD完成了虚拟面试;29%的申请人认为能熟悉项目文化,38%对展示自我能力满意。
- 62%的申请人能舒适地基于虚拟面试对项目排名,但38%报告该形式使其将某项目排名降低;77%的申请人偏好现场面试。
- 75%的FD报告虚拟面试限制其熟悉申请人,仅50%能舒适地对申请人排名;78%的FD认为虚拟面试在专科培训匹配中有作用。
- 97%的申请人担心选择虚拟面试传递较少兴趣,43%的FD会将其解读为较少兴趣。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:基于网络调查的横断面研究;作者结论认为虚拟面试有多种不足,但技术可行,并为申请人和FD提供合理信息以完成匹配过程。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,基于申请人和FD视角的建议可指导虚拟面试的实施;虚拟面试技术可行,但有多项不足,包括申请人展示自我和熟悉项目文化受限、FD熟悉申请人受限,以及选择虚拟面试可能被解读为兴趣较低。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to assess applicant and fellowship director (FD) perspectives on virtual interviewing based on the 2019 to 2020 orthopaedic trauma fellowship interview experience and to develop recommendations for future application cycles.
METHODS: Web-based surveys were distributed to all matched applicants and orthopaedic trauma FDs after the 2019 and 2020 orthopaedic trauma fellowship match. Thirty-one applicants and 23 FDs completed the survey-response rates of 34% and 38%, respectively.
RESULTS: Virtual interviews were completed by 68% of applicants and 17% of FDs. Twenty-nine percent of applicants felt they were able to familiarize themselves with the culture of programs, and 38% of applicants were satisfied with their ability to present themselves. Most (62%) were comfortable ranking programs based on the virtual interview, but 38% reported the format influenced them to rank a program lower. Among all applicants, 77% preferred the in-person interview. Most FDs (75%) reported virtual interviews limited their ability to familiarize themselves with an applicant, and only 50% were comfortable ranking an applicant afterward. Still, 78% of FDs believe there is a role for virtual interviews in the fellowship match. Choosing a virtual interview may negatively affect applicants as 97% of applicants worry the choice conveys less interest to programs, while 43% of FDs would interpret it as less interest.
CONCLUSIONS: Virtual interviews have multiple shortcomings but are technically feasible and provide reasonable information to applicants and FDs to complete the match process. Our recommendations, based on the perspectives of applicants and FDs, can guide their implementation.
参考来源
- Yong TM, Davis ME, Coe MP, et al. Recommendations on the use of virtual interviews in the orthopaedic trauma fellowship match: A survey of applicant and fellowship director perspectives. OTA Int. 2021. PMID: 34746662. doi:10.1097/OI9.0000000000000130
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。