危机中公平分配资源:死亡预测模型的种族差异
该研究在27家医院纳入因脓毒症或急性呼吸衰竭住院的黑人和白人患者,比较SOFA与LAPS2对院内死亡率的预测准确性。LAPS2的区分度(AUC 0.76)高于SOFA(AUC 0.68),但两者均低估白人、高估黑人死亡率;模拟显示81.6%黑人被归入低优先级,9.4%被错误排除最高优先。去除肌酐的SOFA可减少种族校准偏差。
要点
- SOFA在危机资源分配中可能加剧种族差异。
- LAPS2区分度优于SOFA,但校准仍存在种族偏差。
- 去除肌酐的SOFA可减少种族校准偏差。
核心结论
- 在危机护理标准中使用SOFA可能导致资源分配的种族差异。
- 需要更公平的死亡预测评分。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入27家医院因脓毒症或急性呼吸衰竭住院的黑人和白人患者,共113,158例,其中黑人27,644例(24.4%)。
- 计算SOFA、LAPS2及其修改版本对院内死亡率的区分度和校准度。
主要发现
- LAPS2的AUC为0.76(95%CI 0.76-0.77),高于SOFA的AUC 0.68(95%CI 0.68-0.69)。
- LAPS2校准优于SOFA,但两者均低估白人患者院内死亡率、高估黑人患者院内死亡率。
- 模拟显示81.6%黑人患者被归入较低优先级类别,9.4%黑人患者被错误排除最高优先。
- 去除肌酐的SOFA减少了种族校准偏差。
关键数值与推荐
- SOFA AUC 0.68(95%CI 0.68-0.69),LAPS2 AUC 0.76(95%CI 0.76-0.77)。
- 黑人患者占24.4%(27,644/113,158)。
- 81.6%黑人患者被归入较低优先级,9.4%被错误排除最高优先。
临床怎么用
- 临床在危机资源分配中应警惕SOFA可能带来的种族差异。
- 可考虑使用LAPS2或去除肌酐的SOFA以减少种族偏差。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Rationale: Crisis standards of care (CSCs) guide critical care resource allocation during crises. Most recommend ranking patients on the basis of their expected in-hospital mortality using the Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) score, but it is unknown how SOFA or other acuity scores perform among patients of different races. Objectives: To test the prognostic accuracy of the SOFA score and version 2 of the Laboratory-based Acute Physiology Score (LAPS2) among Black and white patients. Methods: We included Black and white patients admitted for sepsis or acute respiratory failure at 27 hospitals. We calculated the discrimination and calibration for in-hospital mortality of SOFA, LAPS2, and modified versions of each, including categorical SOFA groups recommended in a popular CSC and a SOFA score without creatinine to reduce the influence of race. Measurements and Main Results: Of 113,158 patients, 27,644 (24.4%) identified as Black. The LAPS2 demonstrated higher discrimination (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve [AUC], 0.76; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.76-0.77) than the SOFA score (AUC, 0.68; 95% CI, 0.68-0.69). The LAPS2 was also better calibrated than the SOFA score, but both underestimated in-hospital mortality for white patients and overestimated in-hospital mortality for Black patients. Thus, in a simulation using observed mortality, 81.6% of Black patients were included in lower-priority CSC categories, and 9.4% of all Black patients were erroneously excluded from receiving the highest prioritization. The SOFA score without creatinine reduced racial miscalibration. Conclusions: Using SOFA in CSCs may lead to racial disparities in resource allocation. More equitable mortality prediction scores are needed.
引用
- Ashana DC, Anesi GL, Liu VX, et al. Equitably Allocating Resources during Crises: Racial Differences in Mortality Prediction Models. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2021. PMID: 33751910. doi:10.1164/rccm.202012-4383OC
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。