平衡多数与少数需求:成人哮喘指南的下一步方向
本文指出哮喘诊疗多在非专科场所进行,基于症状和简单肺功能的阶梯式管理因症状特异性不足和可变气流受限敏感性低而存在缺陷,且炎症、气流受限与症状分离使通用管理对相当比例患者无效。作者建议采用结合人群与个体化的新策略,以关键可治疗机制特征的客观评估驱动治疗决策。
要点
- 多数哮喘管理决策发生在非专科场所,诊断常难以自信排除。
- 症状特异性不足和可变气流受限敏感性低,通用阶梯管理对部分患者无效。
- 建议以可治疗机制特征的客观评估驱动治疗决策。
核心结论
- 基于症状和简单肺功能的通用阶梯式哮喘管理在相当比例患者中难以成功,建议采用以客观评估可治疗机制特征驱动治疗决策的联合策略。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为Lancet Respir Med发表的指南述评,讨论成人哮喘指南的下一步方向,未报告系统检索或样本量。
主要发现
- 哮喘诊断依赖症状模式识别和哮喘发作,有时辅以基础肺功能检查。
- 症状特异性不足及可变气流受限敏感性低,使哮喘诊断常难以自信排除。
- 炎症、气流受限与症状之间的分离,使基于症状的通用阶梯管理对相当比例患者不太可能成功。
- 有效治疗使用效率低,结局常比可能达到的更差。
临床怎么用
- 在非专科场所应重视客观评估可治疗机制特征,而非仅凭症状阶梯调整治疗。
- 对诊断不确定者,需考虑症状特异性和可变气流受限敏感性的局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Asthma differs from many other chronic conditions in that most key management decisions are made in non-specialist settings, such as general practitioner surgeries and accident and emergency departments. Diagnosis in primary care relies on recognition of a characteristic pattern of symptoms and the occurrence of asthma attacks, sometimes supplemented by basic lung function tests. Ongoing management is guided by the assessment of symptoms and simple lung function measures of airflow obstruction, with little attempt made to personalise management. This approach is flawed because the inadequate specificity of symptoms, as well as the low sensitivity of variable airflow obstruction, means that a diagnosis of asthma is often difficult to exclude with confidence. Moreover, even if diagnosed correctly, dissociation between inflammation, airflow obstruction, and symptoms means that a generalised stepwise approach to managing asthma on the basis of symptoms is unlikely to be successful in a substantial proportion of patients. As a result, effective treatments are used inefficiently, and outcomes are often worse than they could be. Rather than use of either a population-based or personalised approach for the diagnosis and management of asthma, we recommend a new combined approach, in which treatment decisions are driven by objective assessment of key treatable mechanistic traits.
引用
- Shaw DE, Heaney LG, Thomas M, et al. Balancing the needs of the many and the few: where next for adult asthma guidelines? Lancet Respir Med. 2021. PMID: 33639099. doi:10.1016/S2213-2600(21)00021-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。