随机测量误差对肺癌筛查决策的影响:基于回顾性队列的微观模拟研究
该研究基于8个学术退伍军人事务站点10449例患者的重复吸烟包年记录,评估包年信息随机测量误差对肺癌筛查决策的影响。模拟显示,使用≥30包年阈值导致48.1%至60.7%的筛查资格误分类,而采用肺癌风险阈值误分类率降至47.3%至49.7%,且能更好维持筛查效果。
要点
- 常规实践中包年信息可靠性因站点而异,重复测量可评估其可靠性。
- ≥30包年阈值下,包年信息不可靠导致高比例筛查资格误分类。
- 基于肺癌风险阈值可减少误分类并更好维持筛查效果。
核心结论
- 真实世界包年评估的随机误差在使用≥30包年标准时导致大量筛查资格误分类。
- 采用肺癌风险阈值可减轻不可靠包年信息的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2013年10月至2017年7月期间在8个学术退伍军人事务站点至少两次记录包年史的10449例患者。
- 基于多层线性随机效应模型的最佳线性无偏预测估计每个个体的统计「真实」包年信息。
- 模拟包年观察值,比较基于不可靠包年信息与真实信息的筛查决策及效果。
主要发现
- 常规实践中包年信息评估的可靠性因站点而异,组内相关系数存在范围。
- 使用≥30包年阈值时,较高可靠性包年信息下48.1%误分类,较低可靠性下60.7%误分类。
- 使用肺癌风险阈值时,较低可靠性包年信息下误分类率为47.3%至49.7%。
关键数值与推荐
- 筛查资格误分类率:较高可靠性包年信息下48.1%,较低可靠性下60.7%(≥30包年阈值)。
- 使用肺癌风险阈值时,较低可靠性包年信息下误分类率为47.3%至49.7%。
临床怎么用
- 决策者应关注包年信息不可靠对CT筛查的影响,考虑采用基于风险的方法进行肺癌筛查。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Self-reported tobacco pack-year history plays a large role in decisions about low-dose CT screening for lung cancer, yet is challenging to measure accurately. RESEARCH QUESTION: To what extent does random measurement error in pack-year information impact screening decisions and screening effectiveness? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Retrospective cohort study of 10,449 patients with pack-year history documented at least twice between October 2013 and July 2017 across 8 academic Veterans Affairs sites. Outcome measures included (1) observed reliability of pack-year information based on all repeat measures for the study population and (2) each person's statistically "true" pack-year information based on best linear unbiased predictor from a multilevel linear random effects model. To examine how unreliability leads to misclassification of screening eligibility and inaccuracy in estimating lung cancer risk, we simulated pack-year observations for each person, first comparing simulated pack-year and lung cancer risk values with true values, then comparing outcomes when basing screening decisions on unreliable pack-year information vs true information. RESULTS: Reliability of assessing pack-year information in routine practice varied across sites. Thus, we examined the clinical impact of two different levels of reliability, based on the range of intraclass correlation coefficients observed. Using a ≥ 30-pack-year threshold led to a high rate of eligibility misclassifications (48.1% misclassified with higher reliability pack-year information and 60.7% misclassified with lower reliability information). However, using a lung cancer risk threshold leads to fewer misclassifications (47.3%-49.7% misclassified when using lower reliability pack-year information) and maintains screening effectiveness better when using unreliable pack-year information. INTERPRETATION: Random error in real-world pack-year assessments leads to a substantial rate of misclassifying who should be offered CT screening if a ≥ 30-pack-year criterion is used. However, using a lung cancer risk threshold mitigates the impact of unreliable pack-year information. Decision-makers concerned about the impact of unreliable pack-year information should consider using risk-based approaches to CT screening.
引用
- Caverly TJ, Zhang X, Hayward RA, et al. Effects of Random Measurement Error on Lung Cancer Screening Decisions: A Retrospective Cohort-Based Microsimulation Study. Chest. 2020. PMID: 32941860. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2020.08.2112
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。