文献速递肺结节与肺癌

医疗机构在报销要求下实施肺癌筛查共享决策的模式与挑战

How Health-Care Organizations Implement Shared Decision-making When It Is Required for Reimbursement: The Case of Lung Cancer Screening.
PubMed 文献 · Chest · 2020-08-13

本研究通过深度访谈30名来自23家医疗机构的关键知情人,探讨肺癌筛查共享决策的实施模式。结果显示存在集中式与分散式两种模式,受访者认为集中式提升决策质量但限制可及性,反之亦然,并面临资源有限、决策定义模糊及缺乏质量评估基准等持续挑战。

要点

  • 肺癌筛查共享决策存在集中式与分散式两种实施模式,部分机构同时使用。
  • 集中式模式被认为提升决策质量但限制患者可及性,分散式模式则相反。
  • 实施中面临资源有限、共享决策定义模糊及缺乏质量评估基准的挑战。

核心结论

  • 无论组织背景或实施模式如何,负责肺癌筛查共享决策项目的人员均对患者可及性和决策质量表示担忧。

研究设计与样本

  • 定性研究,采用深入半结构式访谈,通过滚雪球抽样确定受访者,使用模板分析进行主题分析。
  • 共访谈30名关键知情人,代表位于12个州和4个人口普查区域的23家医疗机构。

主要发现

  • 受访者描述了两种肺癌筛查共享决策项目类型:集中式模式(n=7)由前端从业者转诊至筛查诊所,由培训人员实施共享决策;分散式模式(n=10)由前端从业者在转诊前实施共享决策。
  • 部分机构同时使用两种模式(n=6)。
  • 受访者讨论了共享决策质量与可及性之间的权衡,认为集中式模式提升决策质量但限制可及性,反之亦然。

临床怎么用

  • 医疗机构需在共享决策质量与患者可及性之间权衡,选择适合的集中式或分散式模式。
  • 需超越勾选框式的文档要求,建立使所有高危患者能获得筛查、但仅由知情且认为筛查符合其价值观的患者使用的流程。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services stipulate shared decision-making (SDM) counseling as a prerequisite to lung cancer screening (LCS) reimbursement, despite well-known challenges implementing SDM in practice. RESEARCH QUESTION: How have health-care organizations implemented SDM for LCS? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: For this qualitative study, we used data from in-depth, semistructured interviews with key informants directly involved in implementing SDM for LCS, managing SDM for LCS, or both. We identified respondents using a snowball sampling technique and used template analysis to identify and analyze responses thematically. RESULTS: We interviewed 30 informants representing 23 health-care organizations located in 12 states and 4 Census regions. Respondents described two types of SDM for LCS programs: centralized models (n = 7), in which front-end practitioners (eg, primary care providers) referred patients to an LCS clinic where trained staff (eg, advanced practice nurses) delivered SDM at the time of screening, or decentralized models (n = 10), in which front-end practitioners delivered SDM before referring patients for screening. Some organizations used both models simultaneously (n = 6). Respondents discussed tradeoffs between SDM quality and access. They perceived centralized models as enhancing SDM quality, but limiting patient access to care, and vice versa. Respondents reported ongoing challenges with limited resources and budgetary constraints, ambiguity regarding what constitutes SDM, and an absence of benchmarks for evaluating SDM for LCS quality. INTERPRETATION: Those responsible for developing and managing SDM for LCS programs voiced concerns regarding both patient access and SDM quality, regardless of organizational context, or the SDM for LCS model implemented. The challenge facing these organizations, and those wanting to help patients and clinicians balance the tradeoffs inherent with LCS, is how to move beyond a check-box documentation requirement to a process that enables LCS to be offered to all high-risk patients, but used only by those who are informed and for whom screening represents a value-concordant service.

来源:Chest,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Alishahi Tabriz A, Neslund-Dudas C, Turner K, et al. How Health-Care Organizations Implement Shared Decision-making When It Is Required for Reimbursement: The Case of Lung Cancer Screening. Chest. 2020. PMID: 32798520. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2020.07.078

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。