呼吸科医生对慢性血栓栓塞性肺动脉高压认知与管理问卷分析
结果显示V/Q扫描和右心导管开展不足,肺动脉内膜剥脱术和球囊肺动脉成形术不普及,医生对影像学解读和治疗指征的掌握与指南存在差距。
要点
- 仅31.3%医院可开展V/Q扫描,38.5%可做右心导管检查。
- 88.5%医生选择CTPA筛查CTEPH,但指南符合率仅3.9%。
- 79%医生支持终生抗凝,70.8%认为应首先评估手术适合性。
核心结论
- CTEPH诊治中V/Q及右心导管开展不足,手术和介入治疗不普及,医生对影像解读和治疗指征不熟悉,与指南存在差距。
主要发现
- 74.1%医生来自三级及以上医院,88.5%为中级及以上职称。
- 99.3%医院常规开展超声心动图,94%开展CTPA,31.3%可进行V/Q扫描,38.5%可做右心导管检查。
- 仅8.0%医院开展肺动脉血栓内膜剥脱手术,10.4%开展球囊肺动脉成形术,不同级别医院间差异有统计学意义(P<0.01)。
- 9.6%医生自我评价熟悉CTPA影像阅读,19.9%熟悉V/Q扫描阅读。
- 88.5%医生赞同CTPA为首选筛查方法,指南符合率仅3.9%;53.9%医生认为CTPA阴性可除外CTEPH;79%支持终生抗凝;70.8%认为应首先评估手术适合性。
关键数值与推荐
- V/Q扫描开展率31.3%,右心导管开展率38.5%。
- 肺动脉血栓内膜剥脱手术开展率8.0%,球囊肺动脉成形术开展率10.4%,不同级别医院间P<0.01。
- CTPA作为首选筛查方法的指南符合率3.9%。
- 79%医生支持终生抗凝治疗,70.8%医生认为应首先评估手术适合性。
临床怎么用
- 呼吸科医生应提高对CTEPH指南的掌握,规范筛查路径和治疗指征评估。
- 需加强V/Q扫描和右心导管检查的开展与影像解读培训。
- 应推广肺动脉血栓内膜剥脱手术和球囊肺动脉成形术的适宜开展。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To evaluate the awareness and management status of chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH) among respiratory physicians and therefore to provide for establishing clinical guidelines on CTEPH. Methods: A questionnaire was designed to address the common questions in CTEPH management. The responses were collected online and the data were analyzed. Totally, 1 038 valid questionnaires were collected. Results: 74.1% of the responders were from tertiary hospitals and 88.5% were attending physicians. Only a few hospitals could carry out ventilation-perfusion scintigraphy (31.3%) and right heart catheterization (38.5%). For the treatment of CTEPH, pulmonary endarterectomy and balloon pulmonary angioplasty (BPA) were only performed in 8.0% and 10.4% of the hospitals respectively, and mostly in tertiary hospitals, P<0.01. 49.6% of the physicians were familiar with the interpretation of CTPA, while only 19.9% of V/Q scan. 88.5% of the physicians choose CTPA as the screening tool for CTEPH, but only 3.9% were consistent with the guidelines. 79% of the physicians agreed with lifelong anticoagulation for CTEPH, and 70.8% supported operability should be evaluated in all CTEPH patients. Conclusions: This questionnaire study showed that there was a gap between the guidelines and the real world practice in CTEPH management. Efforts should be made to improve the awareness and standardization of the management of CTEPH. 目的: 了解呼吸科医生对慢性血栓栓塞性肺动脉高压(CTEPH)的认知情况与诊治现状。 方法: 根据CTEPH诊治中的相关问题设计问卷,针对774家全国肺栓塞与肺血管病防治协作组、中日友好医院呼吸专科医联体单位的负责医生和联络医生进行问卷调查,收回有效问卷1 038份(1 038/1 211,85.7%),并对结果进行汇总分析。 结果: 多数(769/1 038,74.1%)参与调查医生就职于三级及以上医院,中级及以上职称占88.5%(919/1 038)。绝大多数医院常规开展超声心动图(99.3%)和CTPA检查(94%),部分医院可进行肺通气灌注(V/Q)扫描(31.3%)和右心导管检查(38.5%),仅少数医院开展CTEPH肺动脉血栓内膜剥脱手术(8.0%)与球囊肺动脉成形术(10.4%),不同级别医院之间差异有统计学意义(P<0.01)。9.6%的医生自我评价熟悉CTPA的影像学阅读方法,19.9%医生熟悉V/Q扫描的阅读。88.5%的医生赞同CTPA是CTEPH患者的首选筛查方法,指南符合率仅3.9%。53.9%医生的观点符合指南,认为CTPA阴性可以除外CTEPH。79%的医生支持CTEPH患者终生抗凝治疗,70.8%的医生认为CTEPH应首先评估是否适合手术治疗。 结论: 目前在CTEPH诊治中存在以下问题:V/Q及右心导管开展不足,肺动脉血栓内膜剥脱手术及球囊肺动脉成形治疗尚不普及,呼吸科医生不熟悉CTEPH相关影像学解读方法与治疗指征等,有必要针对以上问题进一步推广CTEPH的规范化诊治方法。.
引用
- Xie WM, Zhen KY, Zhang M, et al. [Awareness and management of chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension among respiratory physicians revealed by a questionnaire analysis]. Zhonghua Jie He He Hu Xi Za Zhi. 2020. PMID: 32727180. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112147-20190912-00626
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。