COPD患者临终前30天更早接受姑息性家庭护理与以患者为中心的医疗资源利用及更低费用相关:一项人群水平死者队列研究
该研究基于比利时2010-2015年58 527例COPD死者,分析姑息性家庭护理(PHC)的使用及时机对临终前30天医疗资源利用和费用的影响。使用PHC(vs未使用)降低住院、ICU入住、专科接触、有创通气、影像检查、镇静剂及院内死亡的优势比,增加家庭护理、全科医生接触、姑息病房入住、无创通气、胃管、氧疗及阿片类药物的优势比,平均总医疗费用降低€1569。各PHC时机类别均显示获益,以死亡前90-31天启动PHC获益最大。
要点
- 使用PHC降低临终前30天住院(OR 0.35)、ICU入住(OR 0.16)及院内死亡(OR 0.14)的优势比。
- 使用PHC增加家庭护理(OR 3.27)、全科医生接触(OR 4.65)及阿片类药物(OR 4.04)的优势比。
- 使用PHC者平均总医疗费用降低€1569,死亡前90-31天启动PHC获益最大。
核心结论
- COPD患者临终前30天使用PHC与更低的医院资源利用、更高的家庭及姑息服务利用和更低的医疗费用相关,以死亡前90-31天启动PHC获益最大。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性人群水平死者队列研究,纳入比利时2010-2015年58 527例COPD死者,主要死因为COPD或心血管疾病。
- 比较使用与未使用PHC及四个PHC时机类别(>360、360-181、180-91和90-31 DBD)的医疗资源利用优势比,校正社会人口学、护理强度和疾病严重程度变量。
主要发现
- 58 527例COPD死者中644例(1.1%)在死亡前30天以上接受PHC。
- 使用PHC(vs未使用)降低住院(OR 0.35)、ICU入住(OR 0.16)、专科接触(OR 0.58)、有创通气(OR 0.13)、医学影像包括胸部X线(OR 0.34)、镇静剂(OR 0.48)和院内死亡(OR 0.14)的优势比(p<0.001)。
- 使用PHC增加家庭护理(OR 3.27)、全科医生接触(OR 4.65)、姑息病房入住(OR 2.61)、无创通气(OR 2.65)、胃管(OR 2.15)、氧疗(OR 2.22)和阿片类药物(OR 4.04)的优势比(p<0.001)。
- 使用PHC者平均总医疗费用降低€1569,所有PHC时机类别均显示医疗资源利用和费用获益,以死亡前90-31天启动PHC获益最大。
临床怎么用
- COPD临终患者可考虑尽早启动姑息性家庭护理,以减少住院、ICU入住和有创通气等急性医疗资源使用。
- 死亡前90-31天启动PHC可能获益最大,卫生政策和服务应关注提高PHC可及性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
COPD patients often use many medical resources, such as hospital admissions and medical imaging, inappropriately close to death. Palliative home care (PHC) could beneficially affect this. The aim was to study the effect of use and timing of PHC on medical resource use and costs in the last 30 days before death (DBD) for COPD.We performed a retrospective study of all Belgian decedents in 2010-2015 with COPD and a primary cause of death being COPD or cardiovascular diseases. Odds ratios for medical resources were calculated between using and four PHC timing categories (>360, 360-181, 180-91 and 90-31 DBD) versus not using. Confounders were socio-demographic, care intensity and disease severity variables.Of the 58 527 decedents with COPD, 644 (1.1%) patients received PHC earlier than 30 DBD. Using PHC (versus not using) decreased the odds ratio for hospitalisation (0.35), intensive care unit admission (0.16), specialist contacts (0.58), invasive ventilation (0.13), medical imaging including chest radiograph (0.34), sedatives (0.48) and hospital death (0.14). It increased the odds ratio for home care (3.27), general practitioner contact (4.65), palliative care unit admission (2.61), noninvasive ventilation (2.65), gastric tube (2.15), oxygen (2.22) and opioids (4.04) (p<0.001). Mean total healthcare costs were €1569 lower for using PHC. All PHC timing categories showed a benefit in medical resource use and costs. However, we observed the largest benefit in the category PHC 90-31 DBD.Health policy and services should focus on increasing PHC access, while research should further explore early PHC initiation for COPD.
引用
- Scheerens C, Faes K, Pype P, et al. Earlier palliative home care is associated with patient-centred medical resource utilisation and lower costs in the last 30 days before death in COPD: a population-level decedent cohort study. Eur Respir J. 2020. PMID: 32108048. doi:10.1183/13993003.01139-2019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。