超细支气管镜与细支气管镜诊断外周肺病变的随机对照试验
本研究纳入直径≤30 mm的外周肺病变患者360例,随机分为超细支气管镜组(3.0 mm,工作通道1.7 mm)与细支气管镜组(4.0 mm,工作通道2.0 mm),均联合支气管内超声、虚拟支气管镜与透视引导。356例纳入分析,超细支气管镜组总体诊断率显著更高(70.1% vs 58.7%,P = .027),操作时间更短(中位24.8 vs 26.8 min,P = .008),并发症率两组差异无统计学意义(2.8% vs 4.5%,P = .574)。
要点
- 超细支气管镜诊断外周肺病变的诊断率高于细支气管镜。
- 超细支气管镜操作时间更短,并发症率与细支气管镜相近。
- 研究纳入病变直径≤30 mm,中位最大径19 mm。
核心结论
- 在诊断小型外周肺病变时,使用3.0 mm超细支气管镜的多模态支气管镜诊断率高于使用4.0 mm细支气管镜。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,纳入外周肺病变直径≤30 mm的患者360例,356例纳入分析,中位最大病变直径19 mm。
- 两组均行支气管内超声、虚拟支气管镜与透视引导的支气管镜检查;超细支气管镜组使用3.0 mm超细支气管镜(工作通道1.7 mm)。
- 细支气管镜组使用4.0 mm细支气管镜(工作通道2.0 mm),允许使用带引导鞘的小活检钳或不带引导鞘的标准活检钳。
- 对无法插入超声探头的病变行针吸活检。
主要发现
- 总体诊断率超细支气管镜组为70.1%,细支气管镜组为58.7%,差异有统计学意义(P = .027)。
- 操作时间超细支气管镜组中位24.8 min,细支气管镜组中位26.8 min,差异有统计学意义(P = .008)。
- 并发症率超细支气管镜组2.8%,细支气管镜组4.5%(P = .574)。
临床怎么用
- 对直径≤30 mm的外周肺病变,可优先考虑使用3.0 mm超细支气管镜进行多模态支气管镜诊断,以提高诊断率并缩短操作时间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: When evaluating peripheral pulmonary lesions, a 3.0-mm ultrathin bronchoscope (UTB) with a 1.7-mm working channel is advantageous regarding good access to the peripheral airway, whereas a 4.0-mm thin bronchoscope provides a larger 2.0-mm working channel, which allows the use of various instruments including a guide sheath (GS), larger forceps, and an aspiration needle. This study compared multimodal bronchoscopy using a UTB and a thin bronchoscope with multiple sampling methods for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions. METHODS: Patients with peripheral pulmonary lesions ≤ 30 mm in diameter were recruited and randomized to undergo endobronchial ultrasonography, virtual bronchoscopy, and fluoroscopy-guided bronchoscopy using a 3.0-mm UTB (UTB group) or a 4.0-mm thin bronchoscope (thin bronchoscope group). In the thin bronchoscope group, the use of small forceps with a GS or standard forceps without the GS was permitted. In addition, needle aspiration was performed for lesions into which an ultrasound probe could not be inserted. RESULTS: A total of 360 patients were enrolled, and 356 were included in the analyses (median largest lesional diameter, 19 mm). The overall diagnostic yield was significantly higher in the UTB group than in the thin bronchoscope group (70.1% vs 58.7%, respectively; P = .027). The procedure duration was significantly shorter in the UTB group (median, 24.8 vs 26.8 min, respectively; P = .008). The complication rates were 2.8% and 4.5%, respectively (P = .574). CONCLUSIONS: Multimodal bronchoscopy using a UTB afforded a higher diagnostic yield than that using a thin bronchoscope in the diagnosis of small peripheral pulmonary lesions. TRIAL REGISTRY: UMIN Clinical Trials Registry; No.: UMIN000010133; URL: https://www.umin.ac.jp/ctr/.
引用
- Oki M, Saka H, Asano F, et al. Use of an Ultrathin vs Thin Bronchoscope for Peripheral Pulmonary Lesions: A Randomized Trial. Chest. 2019. PMID: 31356810. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2019.06.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。