动态多学科讨论在间质性肺疾病中的诊断能力:938例回顾性观察研究
该回顾性观察研究比较了2005至2015年间在鲁汶大学医院多学科讨论(MDD)中讨论的938例间质性肺疾病(ILD)患者的MDD前诊断与MDD诊断。结果显示,80.5%的患者经MDD获得明确诊断,41.9%有MDD前诊断的患者诊断被改变,79.5%无MDD前诊断的患者经MDD获得诊断。MDD诊断在区分特发性肺纤维化与其他ILD方面显示出优于MDD前诊断的预后判别趋势。
要点
- MDD为80.5%的ILD患者提供明确诊断,并对几乎所有未分类患者建议进一步检查。
- 41.9%有MDD前诊断的患者诊断被MDD改变,提示MDD对诊断修正有重要价值。
- MDD诊断对IPF与其他ILD的预后判别优于MDD前诊断,尤其在诊断不一致患者中。
核心结论
- MDD在80.5%的病例中提供明确诊断,并对几乎所有其他病例建议进一步检查。
- MDD改变了41.9%有MDD前诊断患者的诊断,且可能被低估。
- MDD诊断在区分IPF与其他ILD方面显示出更好的预后判别能力,提示其附加价值。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性观察研究,比较2005年1月至2015年12月在鲁汶大学医院MDD讨论的938例连续ILD患者的MDD前诊断与MDD诊断。
主要发现
- 938例患者中,755例(80.5%)获得特定诊断。
- 183例未分类ILD患者中,150例(16.0%)获得进一步检查建议以确立明确诊断。
- 191例(有MDD前诊断患者的41.9%)MDD改变了诊断。
- 384例(无MDD前诊断患者的79.5%)在转诊医生未诊断时由MDD提供了诊断。
- MDD诊断与MDD前诊断相比,在IPF与其他ILD间的预后判别趋势更好(Harrell C-index,0.666 vs 0.631;P = .08),在诊断不一致患者中尤为明显(风险比,2.68 vs 0.84;P = .012 vs .768)。
临床怎么用
- 对于ILD患者,尤其是诊断不明确者,建议通过动态MDD讨论以明确诊断或指导进一步检查。
- MDD诊断可能改善IPF与其他ILD的预后判别,支持其在临床决策中的应用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The advice of a dynamic multidisciplinary discussion (MDD) is believed to be important in the diagnosis of interstitial lung diseases (ILDs). However, to what extent MDD diagnoses differ from the preliminary diagnoses before formal workup and MDD (preMDD diagnoses) is still insufficiently studied. METHODS: We compared preMDD and MDD diagnoses in patients discussed at the Leuven University Hospitals MDDs between January 2005 and December 2015. RESULTS: Of 938 consecutive patients discussed in an MDD, 755 (80.5%) received a specific diagnosis. From the 183 patients with unclassifiable ILD, 150 patients (16.0%) received suggestions concerning further investigations to establish a definite diagnosis. In 191 patients (41.9% of patients with a preMDD diagnosis), the MDD changed the diagnosis. In 384 patients (79.5% of patients without preMDD diagnosis), MDD provided a diagnosis when the referring physician did not. MDD diagnosis showed a trend toward better prognostic discrimination between idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis and other ILDs compared with preMDD diagnosis (Harrell C-index, 0.666 vs 0.631; P = .08), which was particularly clear in patients with discordant MDD and preMDD diagnoses (hazard ratio, 2.68 vs 0.84; P = .012 vs .768). CONCLUSIONS: The MDD provided a definite diagnosis in 80.5% of presented cases, suggesting further investigations in almost all others. Given the high number of patients without preMDD diagnosis, the rate of change in preMDD diagnoses (41.9% of patients with a preMDD diagnosis) probably is an underestimation. The better prognostic discrimination among ILDs by using MDD indicates the added value of MDD in ILD.
引用
- De Sadeleer LJ, Meert C, Yserbyt J, et al. Diagnostic Ability of a Dynamic Multidisciplinary Discussion in Interstitial Lung Diseases: A Retrospective Observational Study of 938 Cases. Chest. 2018. PMID: 29608882. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2018.03.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。