间质性肺疾病相关肺动脉高压:超声心动图与右心导管检查的局限性比较
结果显示TR速度>3.4 m/s时RHC确认PH的阳性预测值为86%,但TR速度<2.8 m/s时40%患者经RHC仍确诊PH,被误判为低概率。结论认为现行ESC/ERS TR速度筛查阈值确认PH价值高但排除PH价值有限。
要点
- TR速度>3.4 m/s时RHC确认PH的阳性预测值为86%。
- TR速度<2.8 m/s时40%患者经RHC仍确诊PH,被误判为低概率。
- 调整TR速度低概率阈值未能显著改善排除PH的能力。
核心结论
- 在ILD疑似PH患者中,ESC/ERS推荐的TR速度筛查阈值确认PH的阳性预测值高(86%),但排除PH价值有限,40%经RHC确诊PH者被误判为低概率。
- 评估替代TR速度低概率阈值未显著改善TR速度排除PH诊断的能力。
研究设计与样本
- 以RHC测压为参照,评估ESC/ERS推荐的TR速度阈值(高>3.4 m/s、中2.9-3.4 m/s、低<2.8 m/s)对PH概率分层的预测效用。
主要发现
- TR速度>3.4 m/s的受试者中86%经RHC确认PH。
- TR速度<2.8 m/s的ILD受试者中60%经RHC排除PH,即40%经RHC确诊PH被误判为低概率。
- 评估替代TR速度低概率阈值未显著改善TR速度排除PH诊断的能力。
关键数值与推荐
- ESC/ERS推荐的高概率TR速度阈值为>3.4 m/s。
- ESC/ERS推荐的中概率TR速度阈值为2.9-3.4 m/s。
- ESC/ERS推荐的低概率TR速度阈值为<2.8 m/s。
- TR速度>3.4 m/s时RHC确认PH的阳性预测值为86%。
- TR速度<2.8 m/s时40%患者经RHC确诊PH而被误判为低概率。
临床怎么用
- 在ILD疑似PH患者中,TR速度>3.4 m/s可较高概率确认PH,但TR速度<2.8 m/s不能可靠排除PH。
- 对ILD疑似PH患者,不应仅依据TR速度低概率结果排除PH,需结合RHC进一步评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: In interstitial lung disease (ILD), pulmonary hypertension (PH) is a major adverse prognostic determinant. Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) is the most widely used tool when screening for PH, although discordance between TTE and right heart catheter (RHC) measured pulmonary haemodynamics is increasingly recognized. We evaluated the predictive utility of the updated European Society of Cardiology/European Respiratory Society (ESC/ERS) TTE screening recommendations against RHC testing in a large, well-characterized ILD cohort. METHODS: Two hundred and sixty-five consecutive patients with ILD and suspected PH underwent comprehensive assessment, including RHC, between 2006 and 2012. ESC/ERS recommended tricuspid regurgitation (TR) velocity thresholds for assigning high (>3.4 m/s), intermediate (2.9-3.4 m/s) and low (<2.8 m/s) probabilities of PH were evaluated against RHC testing. RESULTS: RHC testing confirmed PH in 86% of subjects with a peak TR velocity >3.4 m/s, and excluded PH in 60% of ILD subjects with a TR velocity <2.8 m/s. Thus, the ESC/ERS guidelines misclassified 40% of subjects as 'low probability' of PH, when PH was confirmed on subsequent RHC. Evaluating alternative TR velocity thresholds for assigning a low probability of PH did not significantly improve the ability of TR velocity to exclude a diagnosis of PH. CONCLUSION: In patients with ILD and suspected PH, currently recommended ESC/ERS TR velocity screening thresholds were associated with a high positive predictive value (86%) for confirming PH, but were of limited value in excluding PH, with 40% of patients misclassified as low probability when PH was confirmed at subsequent RHC.
引用
- Keir GJ, Wort SJ, Kokosi M, et al. Pulmonary hypertension in interstitial lung disease: Limitations of echocardiography compared to cardiac catheterization. Respirology. 2018. PMID: 29327393. doi:10.1111/resp.13250
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。