文献速递慢阻肺

COPD亚型是否真实存在?10个独立队列的异质性与聚类分析

Do COPD subtypes really exist? COPD heterogeneity and clustering in 10 independent cohorts.
PubMed 文献 · Thorax · 2017-06-21

结果显示聚类亚型跨研究可重复性有限(中位NMI范围0.17-0.43),排除归属不明确者后仍不理想(0.32-0.60),而主成分分析得到的连续特征表现更一致。提示COPD异质性更适合用共存于同一个体的连续疾病特征描述,而非互斥亚型。

要点

  • 相同聚类方法在10个COPD队列中的亚型可重复性仅为中等。
  • 排除聚类归属不明确个体后一致性改善但仍不理想。
  • COPD异质性宜用连续疾病特征刻画,而非互斥亚型。

核心结论

  • 相同聚类分析在多个COPD队列中可重复性有限,COPD异质性更适合用同一患者共存程度不同的连续疾病特征来刻画,而非互斥的COPD亚型。

研究设计与样本

  • 纳入特征包括FEV1、FEV1/FVC、FVC、体重指数、改良医学研究委员会评分、哮喘和心血管合并疾病。
  • 用主成分分析评估临床特征间相关模式,用k-medoids和层次聚类进行聚类分析,以标准化互信息(NMI,0至1,越高一致性越好)量化聚类解的一致性。

主要发现

  • COPD聚类亚型跨研究可重复性中等,中位NMI范围0.17-0.43。
  • 对排除不属于任何聚类明确个体的方法,一致性更好但仍不理想,中位NMI范围0.32-0.60。
  • 由主成分分析得到的COPD临床特征连续表示在各研究间一致性更高。

临床怎么用

  • 解读COPD聚类亚型研究时需考虑其跨队列可重复性有限,不宜将单一聚类亚型直接当作稳定表型用于临床决策。
  • 临床评估COPD异质性时可关注连续疾病特征在同一患者中的共存与程度,而非仅按互斥亚型分类。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: COPD is a heterogeneous disease, but there is little consensus on specific definitions for COPD subtypes. Unsupervised clustering offers the promise of 'unbiased' data-driven assessment of COPD heterogeneity. Multiple groups have identified COPD subtypes using cluster analysis, but there has been no systematic assessment of the reproducibility of these subtypes. OBJECTIVE: We performed clustering analyses across 10 cohorts in North America and Europe in order to assess the reproducibility of (1) correlation patterns of key COPD-related clinical characteristics and (2) clustering results. METHODS: We studied 17 146 individuals with COPD using identical methods and common COPD-related characteristics across cohorts (FEV1, FEV1/FVC, FVC, body mass index, Modified Medical Research Council score, asthma and cardiovascular comorbid disease). Correlation patterns between these clinical characteristics were assessed by principal components analysis (PCA). Cluster analysis was performed using k-medoids and hierarchical clustering, and concordance of clustering solutions was quantified with normalised mutual information (NMI), a metric that ranges from 0 to 1 with higher values indicating greater concordance. RESULTS: The reproducibility of COPD clustering subtypes across studies was modest (median NMI range 0.17-0.43). For methods that excluded individuals that did not clearly belong to any cluster, agreement was better but still suboptimal (median NMI range 0.32-0.60). Continuous representations of COPD clinical characteristics derived from PCA were much more consistent across studies. CONCLUSIONS: Identical clustering analyses across multiple COPD cohorts showed modest reproducibility. COPD heterogeneity is better characterised by continuous disease traits coexisting in varying degrees within the same individual, rather than by mutually exclusive COPD subtypes.

来源:Thorax,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Castaldi PJ, Benet M, Petersen H, et al. Do COPD subtypes really exist? COPD heterogeneity and clustering in 10 independent cohorts. Thorax. 2017. PMID: 28637835. doi:10.1136/thoraxjnl-2016-209846

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。