严重气流阻塞者FVC支气管舒张反应大于FEV1且更具临床相关性
该研究基于荷兰、新西兰、美国临床患者(n=15,278)及加拿大、挪威和五个拉美国家调查(n=16,250)的支气管舒张试验数据,分析支气管舒张反应(BDR)判读标准与性别、年龄、身高、种族及呼吸损害严重程度的关系。结果显示,FEV1变化以占基线百分比表达时,会虚假提示反应性随损害严重程度增加;而以占预计值百分比或z评分表达可消除此偏差,并使200 mL最低增量标准变得冗余。在严重气流阻塞中,ΔFVC应作为评价肺过度充气临床重要缓解的指标。
要点
- FEV1变化以占基线百分比表达会虚假显示反应性随气流阻塞加重而增加。
- 以占预计值百分比或z评分表达BDR可消除偏差,并使200 mL标准冗余。
- 严重气流阻塞时,ΔFVC应作为评价肺过度充气缓解的临床重要指标。
核心结论
- FEV1反应性以占基线百分比表达会虚假提示反应性随呼吸损害严重程度增加。
- 以占预计值百分比或z评分表达FEV1或FVC变化可消除此伪影,并使200 mL最低增量标准冗余。
- 严重气流阻塞时,ΔFVC应作为临床重要缓解肺过度充气的指标进行严格评价。
研究设计与样本
- 研究数据来自荷兰、新西兰和美国的临床患者(n=15,278;女性51.7%)以及加拿大、挪威和五个拉丁美洲国家的调查(n=16,250;女性54.7%)。
- BDR根据FEV1、FVC和FEV1/FVC计算,表达为绝对变化、占基线百分比、占预计值百分比和z评分。
主要发现
- FEV1和FVC变化(mL)与基线值无关,但偏向年龄、身高、性别和气道阻塞水平;ΔFEV1在非裔美国人中显著较低。
- 在1,106例低FEV1(200-1,621 mL)受试者中,FEV1相对基线增加12%至44.7%,但<200 mL。
- 以占预计值百分比或z评分表达BDR减弱了偏差并使200 mL标准冗余,但阳性反应减少一半。
- ΔFEV1占基线百分比随气流阻塞水平增加,而以z评分或占预计值百分比表达时随严重阻塞而降低;ΔFVC无论何种表达均随气流阻塞水平增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 在1,106例低FEV1(200-1,621 mL)受试者中,FEV1相对基线增加12%至44.7%但<200 mL。
- 以占预计值百分比或z评分表达BDR使阳性反应减少一半。
临床怎么用
- 临床解读支气管舒张反应时应考虑以占预计值百分比或z评分表达FEV1和FVC变化,以避免因表达方式导致的偏差。
- 在严重气流阻塞患者中,应关注FVC变化以评价肺过度充气的临床重要缓解。
局限性
- 研究数据来自特定国家临床患者和调查,可能影响结果的普遍性。
- BDR表达方式对阳性反应判读的影响需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recommendations on interpreting tests of bronchodilator responsiveness (BDR) are conflicting. We investigated the dependence of BDR criteria on sex, age, height, ethnicity, and severity of respiratory impairment. METHODS: BDR test data were available from clinical patients in the Netherlands, New Zealand, and the United States (n = 15,278; female subjects, 51.7%) and from surveys in Canada, Norway, and five Latin-American countries (n = 16,250; female subjects, 54.7%). BDR calculated according to FEV1, FVC, and FEV1/FVC was expressed as absolute change, a percentage of the baseline level (% baseline), a percentage of the predicted value (% predicted), and z score. RESULTS: Change (Δ) in FEV1 and FVC, in milliliters, was unrelated to the baseline value but was biased toward age, height, sex, and level of airways obstruction; ΔFEV1 was significantly lower in African Americans. In 1,106 subjects with low FEV1 (200-1,621 mL) the FEV1 increased by 12% to 44.7% relative to baseline but < 200 mL. Expressing BDR as a percentage of the predicted value or as a z score attenuated the bias and made the 200-mL criterion redundant, but reduced positive responses by half. ΔFEV1 % baseline increased with the level of airflow obstruction but decreased with severe obstruction when expressed as z scores or % predicted; ΔFVC, however expressed, increased with the level of airflow obstruction. CONCLUSIONS: Expressing FEV1 responsiveness as % baseline spuriously suggests that responsiveness increases with the severity of respiratory impairment. Expressing change in FEV1 or FVC as % predicted or as z scores eliminates this artifact and renders the required 200-mL minimum increase redundant. In severe airways obstruction ΔFVC should be critically evaluated as an index of clinically important relief of hyperinflation, with implications for bronchodilator drug trials.
引用
- Quanjer PH, Ruppel GL, Langhammer A, et al. Bronchodilator Response in FVC Is Larger and More Relevant Than in FEV1 in Severe Airflow Obstruction. Chest. 2016. PMID: 28040521. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2016.12.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。