经口呼吸与侧卧位对经口鼻面罩CPAP疗效的影响
BACKGROUND: Oronasal masks are used widely for treating OSA with CPAP. However, oronasal CPAP is associated with lower effectiveness and lower adherence than nasal CPAP.…
要点
- 经口鼻面罩CPAP适应者中,仅口腔呼吸会显著降低CPAP疗效并需更高压力。
- 侧卧位可显著降低经口鼻及仅口腔CPAP的残余AHI。
- 多数患者可成功转换为鼻面罩CPAP,并获得更低压力与更好OSA控制。
核心结论
- 经口鼻面罩CPAP在患者仅经口呼吸时消除OSA的有效性显著下降。
- 经口鼻CPAP在侧卧位时疗效显著优于仰卧位。
- 转换为鼻面罩可提高CPAP治疗OSA的有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 患者随机顺序接受两次CPAP多导睡眠图滴定:一次鼻口双腔开放,一次仅口腔开放,均在仰卧位与侧卧位进行。
- 随后提供鼻面罩并进行第三次鼻CPAP多导睡眠图测试。
主要发现
- 75%患者在使用经口鼻面罩时仍为经口鼻呼吸。
- 仅口腔CPAP的残余AHI中位数12.5(IQR 1.8-28.3)显著高于经口鼻CPAP的2(IQR 1-6.0),P = .003。
- 仅口腔CPAP所需压力中位数11 cm H2O(IQR 10-12)显著高于经口鼻CPAP的10 cm H2O(IQR 9-10),P = .003。
- 经口鼻和仅口腔CPAP在侧卧位时残余AHI均显著低于仰卧位。
- 75%患者同意并偏好继续使用鼻面罩,鼻CPAP压力更低且OSA控制更好。
临床怎么用
- 对经口鼻面罩CPAP适应但疗效不佳者,应评估是否存在经口呼吸并考虑侧卧位或转换为鼻面罩。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Oronasal masks are used widely for treating OSA with CPAP. However, oronasal CPAP is associated with lower effectiveness and lower adherence than nasal CPAP. RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the impact of oral route and lateral position in patients well adapted to oronasal CPAP? Can these patients be switched to nasal CPAP? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Patients with OSA receiving oronasal CPAP underwent two CPAP polysomnography titrations in random order using an oronasal mask with two independent sealed compartments connected to two separate pneumotachographs. One study was performed with the nasal and oral compartments opened and the other study was performed with only the oral compartment opened. CPAP titration was carried out in the supine and lateral positions. Finally, the patients were offered a nasal mask. A third polysomnography test was performed using nasal CPAP. RESULTS: Twenty patients with OSA (baseline apnea-hypopnea index [AHI], 52 ± 21 events/h) adapted to oronasal CPAP were studied. Most patients (75%) were oronasal breathers with optimal CPAP. Oral CPAP was less effective to treat OSA than oronasal CPAP, evidenced by a higher residual AHI (median, 2 [interquartile range (IQR), 1-6.0] vs 12.5 [IQR, 1.8-28.3); P = .003), despite a significantly higher CPAP level (median, 10 cm H2O [IQR, 9-10 cm H2O] vs 11 cm H2O [IQR, 10-12 cm H2O]; P = .003). The residual AHI was significantly lower in the lateral position for both oronasal and oral CPAP. Finally, patients (75%) agreed to change and preferred to continue using a nasal mask, which resulted in lower CPAP and better OSA control. INTERPRETATION: Our results indicate that the effectiveness of oronasal CPAP to abolish OSA is decreased significantly when patients are required to breathe exclusively through the mouth. Oronasal CPAP efficacy is significantly better in the lateral position. The transition to nasal mask results in higher CPAP effectiveness to treat OSA. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRY: ClinicalTrials.gov; No.: NCT05272761; URL: www. CLINICALTRIALS: gov.
引用
- Xavier JLA, Fernandes MD, Andrade RGS, et al. Impact of Exclusive Mouth Route and Lateral Position on the Efficacy of Oronasal CPAP to Treat OSA in Patients With OSA Adapted to Oronasal Mask. Chest. 2024. PMID: 39454998. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2024.10.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。