基于远程视频的COPD自我管理干预:在多元患者群体中的评估与公平有效性范围综述
该范围综述系统检索了基于远程视频的COPD自我管理干预研究,共纳入20项研究,其中仅1项在COVID-19大流行后发表。多数研究未报告种族或收入数据,难以评估干预效果在不同患者群体间的公平性;多数研究显示至少一项医疗使用指标显著下降,有效干预常采用多模式(如面对面联合远程视频)。
要点
- 多数研究未报告种族或收入数据,干预公平性证据不足。
- 12/20研究显示至少一项医疗使用指标显著降低,9项显示住院相关减少。
- 有效干预多采用多模式(如面对面联合远程视频)或视频方式。
核心结论
- 多数研究未报告参与者种族或收入,缺乏干预效果在不同患者群体间公平性的数据。
- 多模式远程视频干预(尤其含面对面成分)最常见有效,未发现与研究质量或样本量相关。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,系统检索基于远程视频的COPD自我管理干预研究,共纳入20项研究。
- 20项研究中19项发表于COVID-19大流行前,11项被评为高质量研究。
主要发现
- 19/20研究报告年龄和性别,仅3/20报告种族数据,1/20报告收入数据。
- 最常用的远程视频方式为面对面联合电话(6/20)、仅视频(6/20)、仅电话(4/20)。
- 12/20研究显示至少一项医疗使用指标显著降低,9项研究显示住院相关减少。
关键数值与推荐
- 有效干预通常采用两种方法(如面对面联合远程视频)、视频方法或两者兼有。
- 未发现干预效果与研究质量或样本量存在关联。
临床怎么用
- 临床可优先考虑多模式远程视频干预(含面对面成分)以减少COPD患者急性医疗使用。
- 需在真实世界中有意识地收集种族、收入等数据以评估干预公平性。
局限性
- 多数研究未报告种族或收入数据,限制了对干预公平有效性的评估。
- 仅1项研究在COVID-19大流行后发表,缺乏大流行后多元人群数据,限制结果外推。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
TOPIC IMPORTANCE: With telemedicine's expansion during the COVID-19 pandemic, it has become critical to evaluate whether patients have equitable access to and capabilities to use televisits optimally for improved COPD outcomes such as reduced hospitalizations. This scoping review evaluated whether televisit-based interventions are evaluated among and equitably effective in improving health care use outcomes among diverse patient populations with COPD. REVIEW FINDINGS: Using a systematic search for televisit-based COPD self-management interventions, we found 20 studies for inclusion, all but one of which were published before the COVID-19 pandemic. Most (11 of 20) were considered good-quality studies. Most studies (19 of 20) reported age and sex; few provided race (3 of 20) or income (1 of 20) data. The most frequently used televisit-based methods were in-person plus phone (6 of 20), video only (6 of 20), and phone only (4 of 20). Most studies (12 of 20) showed a significant reduction in at least one health care use metric; nine studies found hospitalization-related reductions. Effective interventions typically used two methods (eg, in-person plus televisits), video methods, or both. SUMMARY: Most studies failed to report on participants' race or income, leading to a lack of data on the equity of interventions' effectiveness across diverse patient populations. Multimethod televisit-based interventions, particularly with an in-person component, most commonly were effective; no associations were seen with study quality or size. With the increasing reliance on telemedicine to provide chronic disease care, the lack of data among diverse populations since the COVID-19 pandemic began limits generalizability of these findings for real-world clinical settings. More comprehensive evaluations of televisit-based interventions are needed in the era after the pandemic within and across diverse patient populations.
引用
- Akula M, Nguyen M, Abraham J, et al. Determining If COPD Self-Management Televisit-Based Interventions Are Evaluated Among and Equitably Effective Across Diverse Patient Populations to Reduce Acute Care Use: A Scoping Review. Chest. 2024. PMID: 39002815. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2024.06.3799
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。