非动脉线心输出量计算误分类运动性肺动脉高压并增加数据丢失风险
该回顾性研究分析296例有创心肺运动试验,比较动脉与非动脉法计算的Fick心输出量。非动脉法使用指脉氧饱和度和混合静脉血红蛋白,与动脉法相关性低,导致前毛细血管和后毛细血管运动性肺动脉高压误分类,且在黑人、硬皮病和雷诺患者中数据丢失更高。
要点
- 非动脉法Fick心输出量与动脉法相关性低,可误分类运动性肺动脉高压。
- 指脉氧饱和度数据丢失率18%,显著高于动脉血氧饱和度0.88%。
- 黑人和硬皮病/雷诺患者指脉氧数据丢失更高,影响无动脉线时运动试验准确性。
核心结论
- 依赖指脉氧饱和度进行有创运动试验会导致前毛细血管和后毛细血管运动性肺动脉高压误分类。
- 黑人和硬皮病/雷诺患者指脉氧饱和度不可测可妨碍准确运动计算,限制无动脉线时有创运动试验的诊断和预后价值。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析296例连续有创心肺运动试验研究。
- 比较指脉氧饱和度与桡动脉血氧饱和度、动脉血红蛋白与混合静脉血红蛋白,以及动脉法与非动脉法计算的Fick心输出量。
- 评估前毛细血管和后毛细血管运动性肺动脉高压误分类风险及指脉氧饱和度不准确导致的数据丢失。
主要发现
- 从静息到峰值运动所有阶段,动脉血红蛋白与混合静脉血红蛋白高度相关,而指脉氧饱和度与动脉血氧饱和度、动脉法与非动脉法心输出量相关性低。
- 指脉氧饱和度数据丢失为346/1926(18%),动脉血氧饱和度数据丢失为17/1923(0.88%),所有运动阶段指脉氧数据丢失显著更高。
- 前毛细血管运动性肺动脉高压误分类为7/41(17.1%),后毛细血管运动性肺动脉高压误分类为2/23(8.7%)。
- 硬皮病和/或雷诺患者指脉氧数据丢失为11/33(33.3%),黑人患者为6/19(31.6%)。
临床怎么用
- 有创运动试验中依赖指脉氧饱和度而非动脉线可能误分类运动性肺动脉高压。
- 对黑人、硬皮病和雷诺患者,无动脉线时指脉氧数据丢失风险高,可能限制试验准确性。
局限性
- 回顾性分析设计。
- 样本来自单中心连续病例。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The direct Fick principle is the standard for calculating cardiac output (CO) to detect CO-dependent conditions like exercise pulmonary hypertension (ePH). Fick COarterial incorporates arterial haemoglobin (Hba) and oxygen saturation (S aO2 ) with oxygen consumption from exercise testing, while Fick COnon-arterial substitutes mixed venous haemoglobin (Hbmv) and peripheral oxygen saturation (S pO2 ) in the absence of an arterial line. The decision to employ an arterial catheter for exercise testing varies, and discrepancies in oxygen saturation and haemoglobin between arterial and non-arterial methods may lead to differences in Fick CO, potentially affecting ePH classification. METHODS: We performed a retrospective analysis of 296 consecutive invasive cardiopulmonary exercise testing (iCPET) studies comparing oxygen saturation from pulse oximetry (S pO2 ) and radial arterial (S aO2 ), Hba and Hbmv, and CO calculated with arterial (COarterial) and non-arterial (COnon-arterial) values. We assessed the risk of misclassification of pre- and post-capillary ePH and data loss due to inaccurate S pO2 . RESULTS: When considering all stages from rest to peak exercise, Hba and Hbmv demonstrated high correlation, while S pO2 and S aO2 as well as COarterial and COnon-arterial demonstrated low correlation. Data loss was significantly higher across all stages of exercise for S pO2 (n=346/1926 (18%)) compared to S aO2 (n=17/1923 (0.88%)). We found that pre- and post-capillary ePH were misclassified as COnon-arterial data (n=7/41 (17.1%) and n=2/23 (8.7%), respectively). Patients with scleroderma and/or Raynaud's (n=11/33 (33.3%)) and black patients (n=6/19 (31.6%)) had more S pO2 data loss. CONCLUSION: Reliance upon S pO2 during invasive exercise testing results in the misclassification of pre- and post-capillary ePH, and unmeasurable S pO2 for black, scleroderma and Raynaud's patients can preclude accurate exercise calculations, thus limiting the diagnostic and prognostic value of invasive exercise testing without an arterial line.
引用
- Campedelli L, Nouraie SM, Risbano MG, et al. Non-arterial line cardiac output calculation misclassifies exercise pulmonary hypertension and increases risk of data loss particularly in black, scleroderma and Raynaud's patients during invasive exercise testing. Eur Respir J. 2024. PMID: 38782468. doi:10.1183/13993003.02232-2023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。