低负荷血流限制力量训练在COPD患者中的随机单盲预试验
本研究比较下肢低负荷血流限制训练(LL-BFRT)与高负荷力量训练(HL-ST)在门诊肺康复中对COPD患者腿部力量的效果。30例稳定期COPD患者随机接受24次训练,LL-BFRT以30% 1-RM结合70%动脉闭塞压进行,HL-ST以70% 1-RM进行。两组等长膝伸肌力量均获临床相关改善,组间无显著差异;LL-BFRT组在1分钟坐立试验和体力活动方面有临床相关改善,且初始训练阶段呼吸困难感知较低。
要点
- LL-BFRT与HL-ST在改善COPD患者腿部力量方面效果相当。
- LL-BFRT初始训练阶段降低运动性呼吸困难感知,但增加腿部疲劳。
- LL-BFRT组1分钟坐立试验和体力活动有临床相关改善。
核心结论
- 在稳定期COPD门诊肺康复患者中,LL-BFRT在改善腿部力量方面不优于HL-ST。
- LL-BFRT达到与HL-ST相似的 strength gains,并在初始训练阶段降低呼吸困难感知。
研究设计与样本
- 随机单盲预试验,纳入30例COPD患者(13女,17男,64(9)岁,FEV1 47(18)% pred.),24例完成研究。
- 参与者随机接受LL-BFRT或HL-ST,共24次训练;LL-BFRT以30% 1-RM结合70%动脉闭塞压进行,HL-ST以70% 1-RM进行。
- 主要结局为膝伸肌和屈肌等长力量;次要结局包括1-RM、功能运动能力、体力活动、症状负担和健康相关生活质量。
主要发现
- 两组双腿等长膝伸肌力量均改善至临床相关程度(LL-BFRT:右腿9(20)Nm,左腿10(18)Nm;HL-ST:右腿15(26)Nm,左腿16(30)Nm,数据为均值(SD))。
- 组间差异无统计学或临床意义(右腿平均差=-6.4,95%CI=-13.20至25.92 Nm;左腿平均差=-5.6,95%CI=-15.44至26.55 Nm)。
- 1分钟坐立试验仅LL-BFRT组改善至临床相关程度(4(4) vs 1(5)次)。
- 体力活动仅LL-BFRT组改善至临床相关程度(1506(2441) vs -182(1971)步/天)。
- 与HL-ST相比,LL-BFRT在初始12次训练中降低运动性呼吸困难感知并增加腿部疲劳。
临床怎么用
- LL-BFRT可作为COPD肺康复中力量训练的替代方案,尤其适用于不能耐受高负荷训练的患者。
- LL-BFRT初始训练阶段可能降低呼吸困难感知,但需注意腿部疲劳增加。
局限性
- 预试验样本量小(30例纳入,24例完成),结果需更大规模研究验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study is to compare the effectiveness of lower limb low-load blood flow restriction training (LL-BFRT) with high-load strength training (HL-ST) as part of an outpatient pulmonary rehabilitation programme on leg strength in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). METHODS: Participants were randomised to LL-BFRT or HL-ST (24 sessions). LL-BFRT was done at 30% 1-repetition maximum (1-RM) with 70% arterial occlusion pressure. HL-ST was done at 70% 1-RM. Primary outcome was isometric strength of knee extensors and flexors. Secondary outcomes were 1-RM, functional exercise capacity, physical activity, symptom burden and health-related quality of life. Perceptions of dyspnoea and leg fatigue were recorded after every exercise. We compared groups with t-tests. RESULTS: We included 30 participants (13 women, 17 men, 64 (9) years, forced expiratory volume in 1 s 47 (18)% pred.), 24 completed the study. Isometric knee extensor strength improved to a clinically relevant degree in both legs in both groups (LL-BFRT: right leg 9 (20) Nm, left leg 10 (18) Nm; HL-ST: right leg 15 (26) Nm, left leg 16 (30) Nm, data are mean (SD)), without statistically significant or clinically relevant between-group differences (right leg mean difference= -6.4, 95% CI= -13.20 to 25.92 Nm, left leg mean difference= -5.6, 95% CI= -15.44 to 26.55 Nm). 1 min sit-to-stand test performance improved to a clinically relevant degree only in the LL-BFRT group (4 (4) vs 1 (5) repetitions). Interestingly, physical activity improved to a clinically relevant degree only in the LL-BFRT group (1506 (2441) vs -182 (1971) steps/day). LL-BFRT lowered perceived in-exercise dyspnoea and increased leg fatigue compared with HL-ST in the initial 12 trainings. CONCLUSION: In patients with stable COPD undergoing outpatient pulmonary rehabilitation, LL-BFRT was not superior to HL-ST in improving leg strength. LL-BFRT led to similar strength gains as HL-ST while reducing perceptions of dyspnoea in the initial training phase. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT04151771.
引用
- Kohlbrenner D, Kuhn M, Manettas A, et al. Low-load blood flow restriction strength training in patients with COPD: a randomised single-blind pilot study. Thorax. 2024. PMID: 38129116. doi:10.1136/thorax-2023-220546
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。