机器学习模型在危重症成人生物医学与信息系统信号中的应用
本研究在危重症成人中训练机器学习算法预测插管和升压药启动事件,并与生物医学监视器警报和远程医疗系统警报比较。机器学习通知的准确性和精确性显著更高,警报负担比远程医疗系统警报低50倍,总体F分数是后者的五倍以上。
要点
- 机器学习通知预测插管和升压药启动的准确性为0.87-0.94,优于远程医疗系统(0.28-0.53)和生物医学监视器(0.019-0.028)。
- 机器学习通知的警报负担比远程医疗系统警报低50倍,远程医疗系统警报负担比生物医学监视器警报低10倍。
- 机器学习通知的F分数是远程医疗系统警报的五倍以上,远程医疗系统警报又高于生物医学监视器警报。
核心结论
- 机器学习衍生的通知在预测临床可干预的血流动力学不稳定和呼吸衰竭事件方面优于远程医疗系统警报和生物医学监视器警报。
研究设计与样本
- 训练机器学习算法预测危重症成人的插管和升压药启动事件,并与生物医学监视器警报和远程医疗系统警报比较性能。
主要发现
- 机器学习通知预测升压药启动和插管事件的准确性和精确性显著更高,警报负担比远程医疗系统警报低50倍。
- 机器学习通知在独立学术医学中心外部验证和COVID-19队列中表现相似。
- 机器学习警报的准确性(0.87-0.94)处于其他临床可操作检测范围内,而远程医疗系统(0.28-0.53)和生物医学监视器(0.019-0.028)警报的准确性不在该范围。
- 机器学习通知的总体F分数是远程医疗系统警报的五倍以上,远程医疗系统警报高于生物医学监视器警报。
- 远程医疗系统检测特性显著优于生物医学监视器警报,警报负担低10倍。
关键数值与推荐
- 机器学习警报准确性0.87-0.94,远程医疗系统警报准确性0.28-0.53,生物医学监视器警报准确性0.019-0.028。
- 机器学习通知警报负担比远程医疗系统警报低50倍。
- 远程医疗系统警报负担比生物医学监视器警报低10倍。
- 机器学习通知F分数是远程医疗系统警报的五倍以上。
临床怎么用
- 机器学习通知可提前预警插管和升压药启动事件,支持更主动的临床干预。
- 机器学习通知警报频率显著更低,对床边医生工作流程的干扰更少。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Machine learning (ML)-derived notifications for impending episodes of hemodynamic instability and respiratory failure events are interesting because they can alert physicians in time to intervene before these complications occur. RESEARCH QUESTION: Do ML alerts, telemedicine system (TS)-generated alerts, or biomedical monitors (BMs) have superior performance for predicting episodes of intubation or administration of vasopressors? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: An ML algorithm was trained to predict intubation and vasopressor initiation events among critically ill adults. Its performance was compared with BM alarms and TS alerts. RESULTS: ML notifications were substantially more accurate and precise, with 50-fold lower alarm burden than TS alerts for predicting vasopressor initiation and intubation events. ML notifications of internal validation cohorts demonstrated similar performance for independent academic medical center external validation and COVID-19 cohorts. Characteristics were also measured for a control group of recent patients that validated event detection methods and compared TS alert and BM alarm performance. The TS test characteristics were substantially better, with 10-fold less alarm burden than BM alarms. The accuracy of ML alerts (0.87-0.94) was in the range of other clinically actionable tests; the accuracy of TS (0.28-0.53) and BM (0.019-0.028) alerts were not. Overall test performance (F scores) for ML notifications were more than fivefold higher than for TS alerts, which were higher than those of BM alarms. INTERPRETATION: ML-derived notifications for clinically actioned hemodynamic instability and respiratory failure events represent an advance because the magnitude of the differences of accuracy, precision, misclassification rate, and pre-event lead time is large enough to allow more proactive care and has markedly lower frequency and interruption of bedside physician work flows.
引用
- Lilly CM, Kirk D, Pessach IM, et al. Application of Machine Learning Models to Biomedical and Information System Signals From Critically Ill Adults. Chest. 2023. PMID: 37923292. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2023.10.036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。