患者与临床医生对改善肺癌筛查结果沟通与理解的建议
该混合方法研究从多中心肺癌筛查项目招募参与者,调查患者对低剂量CT筛查结果的理解缺口,并开发常见问题信息表。调查显示88%患者自认理解结果,但仅55%理解肺结节含义,多数患者认为异常结果信件不能替代与医生讨论,而常见问题表被认为有助于理解与提问。
要点
- 患者对肺癌筛查结果的自评理解与实际理解存在差距,仅55%理解肺结节含义。
- 异常低剂量CT结果信件可能引起担忧,不能替代与临床医生的讨论。
- 常见问题信息表可帮助患者理解结节、结果报告和偶然发现,并促进医患沟通。
核心结论
- 研究识别了患者对肺癌筛查结果的信息需求,并开发了经患者和临床医生完善的常见问题信息表。
- 常见问题信息表可能是一种简单可行的方法,改善筛查结果报告并加强医患讨论。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,参与者从多中心肺癌筛查项目招募。
- 初始患者调查评估对筛查结果的理解和反应(n=190)。
- 随后进行患者访谈和焦点小组讨论(n=31),并访谈临床医生(n=6)以获取反馈。
主要发现
- 190名调查受访者中(应答率43%),88%同意自己「理解」筛查结果,但仅55%报告理解肺结节是什么。
- 约三分之二认为获得关于肺结节及偶然发现的肺和心脏疾病的更多信息「非常重要」。
- 访谈和焦点小组中,患者认为正常低剂量CT结果的简短结果信件通常可接受,但多数认为解释异常结果和偶然发现的信件令人担忧且不能替代与临床医生的讨论。
- 几乎所有患者表示常见问题信息表提供了关于结节、结果报告和偶然发现的有用信息,并帮助形成向医生提问的问题。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生可借助常见问题信息表补充筛查结果信件,帮助患者理解肺结节及偶然发现。
- 对异常低剂量CT结果,应安排与患者讨论,不宜仅靠信件传达。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patient understanding of chest low-dose CT (LDCT) scan results for lung cancer screening (LCS) may impact outcomes. RESEARCH QUESTION: What are patient- and clinician-identified gaps in understanding and communication of LCS results and how might communication be improved through a patient-oriented tool? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: We performed a mixed-methods study of participants recruited from a multisite LCS program to understand knowledge gaps after receiving LCS results and to guide development of a commonly asked questions (CAQ) after LCS information sheet. Initial patient surveys assessed understanding and reactions to LCS results (n = 190). We then conducted patient interviews and focus group discussions (n = 31) to understand experiences receiving LDCT scan results and reactions to results letters and the proposed CAQ; we also interviewed clinicians (n = 6) for feedback on these resources. We summarized survey responses and used thematic analysis to identify major themes in focus groups and interviews. RESULTS: Of 190 survey respondents (43% response rate), although 88% agreed that they "understood" their LCS results, only 55% reported understanding what a lung nodule is. Approximately two-thirds thought it was "very important" to receive more information regarding lung nodules and incidental lung and heart disease. In interviews and focus groups, although patients believed that brief results letters for normal LDCT scan results generally were acceptable, most found letters explaining abnormal LDCT scan and incidental findings to be concerning and not a substitute for discussion with their clinician. Nearly all patients expressed that the CAQ sheet provided helpful information on nodules, results reporting and incidental findings, and helped them form questions to ask their clinicians. INTERPRETATION: We identified patient-reported information needs regarding LCS results and developed a CAQ information sheet that was refined with patient and clinician input. The CAQ may represent a simple and feasible way to improve LCS results reporting and to augment clinician-patient discussions.
引用
- Crothers K, Shahrir S, Kross EK, et al. Patient and Clinician Recommendations to Improve Communication and Understanding of Lung Cancer Screening Results. Chest. 2022. PMID: 36209835. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2022.09.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。