30分钟自主呼吸试验会漏诊许多后续120分钟试验失败的儿童
该研究对儿童ARDS临床试验进行二次分析,纳入100名儿童和305次2小时自主呼吸试验(SBT)。42%的SBT成功,32%在30分钟内失败,25%在30至120分钟之间失败;30分钟时通过的SBT中40%在120分钟时失败。30分钟时常规参数无可靠阈值预测结局,30分钟SBT可能过短。
要点
- 30分钟通过的SBT中40%在120分钟时失败,30分钟SBT可能漏诊迟发失败。
- 失败SBT中超过80%存在高呼吸努力(食管测压)。
- 30分钟时RR、Vt、RSBI、Fio2、氧饱和度或二氧化碳图无可靠预测阈值。
核心结论
- 在儿童ARDS恢复期,30分钟SBT可能过短,因为许多失败发生在30至120分钟之间。
- 30分钟时Vt、RR和气体交换的可靠值不能可靠预测2小时SBT通过,可能因未捕捉呼吸努力。
研究设计与样本
- 对儿童ARDS临床试验进行二次分析,每日进行2小时SBT。
- 纳入100名儿童和305次SBT,SBT失败基于客观标准包括食管测压评估呼吸努力。
- SBT结局分为通过、早期失败(≤30分钟)或迟发失败(30-120分钟)。
- 使用肺量计计算RR、Vt和RSBI,并采用脉搏血氧饱和度和二氧化碳图。
- 预测模型评估30分钟参数对SBT结局的预测价值,使用ROC曲线和AUC。
主要发现
- 42%的SBT成功,32%在30分钟内失败,25%在30至120分钟之间失败。
- 30分钟时通过SBT的患者中,40%在120分钟时失败。
- 失败SBT中超过80%存在高呼吸努力(食管测压)。
- 30分钟时RR、Vt、RSBI、Fio2、氧饱和度或二氧化碳图无清晰阈值可靠预测SBT结局。
- 多变量模型识别30分钟RR(P < .001)、RSBI > 7(P = .034)、SBT前吸气压力水平(P = .009)和SBT前凹陷(P = .042)为SBT失败预测因素,但模型在独立验证集中表现不佳(AUC 0.67)。
关键数值与推荐
- SBT失败基于客观标准,包括食管测压评估呼吸努力。
- RSBI > 7(P = .034)与SBT失败相关。
- 30分钟RR(P < .001)、SBT前吸气压力水平(P = .009)和SBT前凹陷(P = .042)与SBT失败相关。
- 预测模型在独立验证集中AUC为0.67。
临床怎么用
- 儿童ARDS恢复期考虑延长SBT至120分钟以减少漏诊迟发失败。
- 30分钟时常规参数正常不应作为通过SBT的唯一依据。
- 关注呼吸努力(如食管测压)而非仅依赖Vt、RR和气体交换。
局限性
- 为二次分析,可能受原始试验设计限制。
- 预测模型在独立验证集中表现不佳(AUC 0.67)。
- 样本为儿童ARDS人群,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The optimal length of spontaneous breathing trials (SBTs) in children is unknown. RESEARCH QUESTIONS: What are the most common reasons for SBT failure in children, and when do they occur? Can clinical parameters at the 30-min mark of a 120-min SBT predict outcome? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: We performed a secondary analysis of a clinical trial in pediatric ARDS, in which 2-h SBTs are conducted daily. SBT failure is based on objective criteria, including esophageal manometry for effort of breathing, categorized as passage, early failure (≤ 30 min), or late failure (30-120 min). Spirometry was used to calculate respiratory rate (RR), tidal volume (Vt), and rapid shallow breathing index (RSBI), in addition to pulse oximetry and capnography. Predictive models evaluated parameters at 30 min against SBT outcome, using receiver operating characteristic plots and area under the curve. RESULTS: We included 100 children and 305 SBTs, with 42% of SBTs being successful, 32% failing within 30 min, and 25% failing between 30 and 120 min. Of the patients passing SBTs at 30 min, 40% went on to fail by 120 min. High respiratory effort (esophageal manometry) was present in > 80% of failed SBTs. At the 30-min mark, there were no clear thresholds for RR, Vt, RSBI, Fio2, oxygen saturation, or capnography that could reliably predict SBT outcome. Multivariable modeling identified RR (P < .001) and RSBI > 7 (P = .034) at 30 min, pre-SBT inspiratory pressure level (P = .009), and pre-SBT retractions (P = .042) as predictors for SBT failure, but this model performed poorly in an independent validation set with the receiver operating characteristic plot crossing the reference line (area under the curve, 0.67). INTERPRETATION: A 30-min SBT may be too short in children recovering from pediatric ARDS because many go on to fail between 30 and 120 min. Reassuring values of Vt, RR, and gas exchange at 30 min do not reliably predict SBT passage at 2 h, likely because they do not capture the effort of breathing. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov; No.: NCT03266016; URL: www. CLINICALTRIALS: gov.
引用
- Knox KE, Hotz JC, Newth CJL, et al. A 30-Minute Spontaneous Breathing Trial Misses Many Children Who Go On to Fail a 120-Minute Spontaneous Breathing Trial. Chest. 2022. PMID: 36037984. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2022.08.2212
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。