文献速递肺结节与肺癌呼吸道感染

多学科综合管理模式在早期肺癌诊疗中的应用

[Application of multidisciplinary treatment comprehensive management model for early-stage lung cancer].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Jie He He Hu Xi Za Zhi · 2022-01-01

该回顾性研究纳入西京医院470例经MDT后手术的早期肺癌患者,分析MDT综合管理模式的临床价值。结果显示MDT推荐手术者术后恶性病理比例高,诊断符合率98.09%,一致性强,诊疗周期均值24.28~26.51天。结论认为该模式在诊断效能和诊疗周期方面有优势,结核与真菌感染应作为重要鉴别诊断。

要点

  • MDT推荐手术患者术后恶性病理比例高,腺癌为主,原位癌及Ⅰ期肺癌居多。
  • 总体诊断符合率98.09%,一致性强(Kappa>0.81),PPV 97.96%,NPV 100%。
  • 术后良性病理以肺结核和真菌感染为主,应作为重要鉴别诊断项目。

核心结论

  • MDT综合管理模式符合共识要求,在诊断效能和诊疗周期方面具有较大优势,对早期肺癌诊治有较高推广应用价值。
  • 早期肺癌诊疗中应将结核与真菌感染作为重要鉴别诊断项目。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究纳入西京医院2018年1月8日至2019年12月31日经MDT后手术的470例患者。
  • 其中男172例,女298例,年龄23~79(54.46±11.08)岁;MDT建议手术441例,主观要求手术29例。

主要发现

  • 男性以实性结节居多(69/172,40.1%),女性以磨玻璃结节居多(135/298,45.3%)。
  • 结节分布上叶(277/470)多于下叶(161/470),右肺(276/470)多于左肺(194/470)。
  • MDT推荐手术的441例中,98.11%男性(156/159)和97.87%女性(276/282)术后病理提示恶性,腺癌为主要类型(男146/156,93.59%;女269/276,97.46%)。
  • 恶性病理以原位癌(男66/156,42.31%;女130/276,47.10%)及Ⅰ期肺癌(男79/156,50.64%;女131/276,47.46%)居多。
  • 推荐手术者中1.89%男性(3/159)和2.13%女性(6/282)术后病理良性,以肺结核和真菌感染为主(各性别均为66.67%,男2/3,女4/6)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 总体诊断符合率98.09%,一致性强(Kappa>0.81)。
  • 阳性预测值(PPV)97.96%,阴性预测值(NPV)100%。
  • 患者诊疗周期均值为24.28~26.51天。

临床怎么用

  • MDT综合管理模式联合多种辅助诊断技术及多学科经验,可弥补单科诊断局限性。
  • 对早期肺癌手术决策可参考MDT推荐,同时需将结核与真菌感染纳入鉴别诊断。

局限性

  • 本研究为单中心回顾性研究,样本来自西京医院,推广性需进一步验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To explore the application of multidisciplinary treatment (MDT) and comprehensive management model in the diagnosis and treatment of early-stage lung cancer, and analyze its clinical value and the feasibility and significance of promotion. Methods: A retrospective study of 470 patients in Xijing Hospital who underwent surgery after MDT from January 8, 2018 to December 31, 2019. There were 172 males and 298 females, aged from 23 to 79 (54.46±11.08) years. Basic diagnosis and treatment information as well as postoperative pathology were analyzed, of which 441 cases were recommended for surgery by MDT and 29 cases were subjectively requested for surgery. The patients' general condition, preoperative diagnosis and pathological results were compared, and the specific content of the MDT and comprehensive management model were summarized. We also explored the value of MDT integrated management model in early stage lung cancer treatment in the context of the current lung cancer incidence in China. Results: Among 470 surgical patients, the majority of males had solid nodules (69/172,40.1%), and the majority of females had ground glass nodules (135/298,45.3%). The distribution of nodules showed a trend of more upper lobe(277/470)than lower lobe(161/470) and more right lung(276/470) than left lung(194/470). Among the 441 patients recommended for surgery, 98.11% of males (156/159) and 97.87% of females (276/282) showed malignant pathology after surgery. Adenocarcinoma was the main pathological type (93.59% of males, 146/156; 97.46% of females, 269/276). Among the malignant pathological results, carcinoma in situ (42.31% of males, 66/156; 47.10% of females, 130/276) and stage I lung cancer (50.64% of males, 79/156; 47.46% of females, 131/276) were the most common. In all patients, 1.89% of the males (3/159) and 2.13% of the females (6/282) recommended for surgery showed benign postoperative pathology, of which tuberculosis and fungal infection were the main pathological types (66.67% for each gender, males 2/3, females, 4/6). The postoperative pathology of 29 patients who subjectively requested surgery was also tuberculosis and fungal infection as the main pathological types (69.23% of males, 9/13; 68.75% of females, 11/16). The MDT comprehensive management model made full use of a variety of auxiliary diagnostic technologies and combined the experience advantages of multidisciplinary participation to make up for the limitations of single-diagnosis. The overall diagnosis coincidence rate reached 98.09%, with strong consistency (Kappa>0.81). The positive predictive value (PPV) was 97.96%, the negative predictive value (NPV) was 100%, and the average patient diagnosis and treatment cycle was 24.28-26.51 days. Conclusions: The MDT comprehensive management model meets the consensus requirements. It has great advantages in diagnostic efficiency and diagnosis and treatment cycle, and has a high promotion and application value for the diagnosis and treatment of early-stage lung cancer. At the same time, tuberculosis and fungal infection should be regarded as an important differential diagnosis item. 目的: 探索多学科会诊(MDT)综合管理模式在早期肺癌诊疗中的应用,分析其临床价值以及推广的可行性和意义。 方法: 回顾性纳入西京医院2018年1月8日至2019年12月31日经MDT后进行手术的470例患者,其中男172例,女298例,年龄23~79(54.46±11.08)岁。分析基本诊疗信息以及术后病理,其中MDT建议手术441例,主观要求手术29例。比较患者一般情况、术前诊断以及病理结果,总结MDT综合管理模式的具体内容及相关技术运用。同时结合当下国内肺癌发病现状探究MDT综合管理模式在早期肺癌诊疗中的应用价值。 结果: 470例手术患者中,男性以实性结节居多(69/172,40.1%),女性以磨玻璃结节居多(135/298,45.3%),结节分布总体呈现上叶(277/470)多于下叶(161/470)、右肺(276/470)多于左肺(194/470)的趋势。MDT推荐手术的441例患者中98.11%的男性(156/159)和97.87%的女性(276/282)术后病理提示恶性,腺癌为主要病理类型(男146/156例,93.59%;女269/276例,97.46%)。恶性病理结果中以原位癌(男66/156例,42.31%;女130/276例,47.10%)及Ⅰ期肺癌(男79/156例,50.64%;女131/276例,47.46%)居多。推荐手术的患者中1.89%的男性(3/159)和2.13%的女性(6/282)术后病理提示良性,其中以肺结核和真菌感染为主(各性别均为66.67%,男2/3例;女4/6例)。主观手术的29患者术后病理也以结核与真菌感染为主要类型(男9/13例,69.23%;女11/16例,68.75%)。MDT综合管理模式中充分联合运用多种辅助诊断技术,同时结合多学科参与的经验优势,弥补了单科诊断的局限性,总体诊断符合率可达98.09%,一致性强(Kappa>0.81),其阳性预测值(PPV)为97.96%,阴性预测值(NPV)为100%,患者诊疗周期均值为24.28~26.51 d。 结论: MDT综合管理模式符合共识要求,其在诊断效能和诊疗周期方面都具有较大的优势,对于早期肺癌的诊治具有较高的推广应用价值,但在早期肺癌的诊疗中应将结核与真菌的感染应作为重要鉴别诊断项目。.

来源:Zhonghua Jie He He Hu Xi Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Yang WH, Xu TQ, Zhang Y, et al. [Application of multidisciplinary treatment comprehensive management model for early-stage lung cancer]. Zhonghua Jie He He Hu Xi Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35279989. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112147-20211026-00743

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。