两种多重PCR平台快速检测英国ICU医院获得性肺炎病原体的多中心评估:INHALE WP1研究
该研究在英国15家医院ICU中,对652份拟更换抗生素的医院获得性下呼吸道感染患者的下呼吸道标本,使用BioFire FilmArray和Unyvero两种多重PCR肺炎检测板与常规培养进行比较。PCR在更多标本中检出病原体(Unyvero 60.4%、FilmArray 74.2% vs 常规44.2%),且对常见HAP/VAP病原体敏感性高,贝叶斯潜类别分析显示常规培养敏感性仅27.0%–69.4%。
要点
- PCR在更多标本中检出病原体,且每份标本检出病原体数多于常规培养。
- FilmArray对常见HAP/VAP病原体敏感性91.7%–100.0%,特异性87.5%–99.5%。
- Unyvero敏感性50.0%–100.0%,特异性89.4%–99.0%;常规培养敏感性低(27.0%–69.4%)。
核心结论
- 两种PCR平台性能相似,且均显著优于常规微生物学检测的敏感性。
- PCR能在培养阴性的标本中检出潜在病原体,有望改善抗菌药物处方。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心研究,纳入英国15家医院ICU中因医院获得性下呼吸道感染拟接受新用或更换抗生素的患者。
- 收集652份合格的下呼吸道标本,同时使用BioFire FilmArray和Unyvero两种多重PCR肺炎检测板检测。
- 采用一致性分析和贝叶斯潜类别分析比较PCR与常规微生物学结果。
主要发现
- PCR检出病原体的标本比例显著高于常规微生物学:Unyvero 60.4%,FilmArray 74.2%,常规44.2%。
- PCR每份样本检出病原体数多于常规微生物学。
- FilmArray对常见HAP/VAP病原体敏感性91.7%–100.0%,特异性87.5%–99.5%。
- Unyvero对常见HAP/VAP病原体敏感性50.0%–100.0%,特异性89.4%–99.0%。
- 贝叶斯潜类别分析显示常规微生物学敏感性低,范围为27.0%–69.4%。
关键数值与推荐
- 共纳入652份合格下呼吸道标本。
- 常见HAP/VAP病原体:FilmArray敏感性91.7%–100.0%,特异性87.5%–99.5%。
- 常见HAP/VAP病原体:Unyvero敏感性50.0%–100.0%,特异性89.4%–99.0%。
- 常规微生物学敏感性27.0%–69.4%(贝叶斯潜类别分析)。
临床怎么用
- PCR可直接从下呼吸道标本检测病原体及耐药基因,提高病原检出率。
- 对培养阴性的医院获得性肺炎或呼吸机相关性肺炎患者,PCR可提供病原学依据。
- PCR的高敏感性可能有助于优化抗菌药物使用和抗菌药物管理。
局限性
- 仅检测英国ICU患者,外推需谨慎。
- 常规微生物学敏感性低,可能影响一致性比较的解读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Culture-based microbiological investigation of hospital-acquired or ventilator-associated pneumonia (HAP or VAP) is insensitive, with aetiological agents often unidentified. This can lead to excess antimicrobial treatment of patients with susceptible pathogens, while those with resistant bacteria are treated inadequately for prolonged periods. Using PCR to seek pathogens and their resistance genes directly from clinical samples may improve therapy and stewardship. METHODS: Surplus routine lower respiratory tract samples were collected from intensive care unit patients about to receive new or changed antibiotics for hospital-onset lower respiratory tract infections at 15 UK hospitals. Testing was performed using the BioFire FilmArray Pneumonia Panel (bioMérieux) and Unyvero Pneumonia Panel (Curetis). Concordance analysis compared machine and routine microbiology results, while Bayesian latent class (BLC) analysis estimated the sensitivity and specificity of each test, incorporating information from both PCR panels and routine microbiology. FINDINGS: In 652 eligible samples; PCR identified pathogens in considerably more samples compared with routine microbiology: 60.4% and 74.2% for Unyvero and FilmArray respectively vs 44.2% by routine microbiology. PCR tests also detected more pathogens per sample than routine microbiology. For common HAP/VAP pathogens, FilmArray had sensitivity of 91.7%-100.0% and specificity of 87.5%-99.5%; Unyvero had sensitivity of 50.0%-100.0%%, and specificity of 89.4%-99.0%. BLC analysis indicated that, compared with PCR, routine microbiology had low sensitivity, ranging from 27.0% to 69.4%. INTERPRETATION: Conventional and BLC analysis demonstrated that both platforms performed similarly and were considerably more sensitive than routine microbiology, detecting potential pathogens in patient samples reported as culture negative. The increased sensitivity of detection realised by PCR offers potential for improved antimicrobial prescribing.
引用
- Enne VI, Aydin A, Baldan R, et al. Multicentre evaluation of two multiplex PCR platforms for the rapid microbiological investigation of nosocomial pneumonia in UK ICUs: the INHALE WP1 study. Thorax. 2022. PMID: 35027473. doi:10.1136/thoraxjnl-2021-216990
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。