低剂量CT肺癌筛查决策支持工具:信息内容、格式与呈现方法范围综述
本范围综述系统检索2000年1月至2021年4月PubMed等数据库文献,共纳入26篇文章中的22个决策支持工具(DST),涵盖纸质、视频或电子格式。多数DST聚焦知识传递,少数采用交互技术辅助价值观澄清或 deliberation;各工具涉及主题相似,但细节、概率量化及呈现方法差异显著,且无工具描述全部潜在筛查危害与结果。DST设计的异质性可能影响决策质量,尤其对低健康素养和低计算能力人群。
要点
- 多数LDCT筛查决策支持工具侧重知识传递,较少支持价值观澄清与 deliberation。
- 各工具在细节、概率量化及呈现方法上差异显著,且无工具涵盖全部筛查危害与结果。
- 设计异质性可能影响决策质量,尤其对低健康素养和低计算能力者。
核心结论
- LDCT肺癌筛查决策支持工具在内容、格式、模式和呈现方法上存在显著异质性,无工具描述所有潜在筛查危害和结果,可能影响决策质量。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,系统检索PubMed、PsycInfo、EMBASE和CINAHL Plus(2000年1月至2021年4月),纳入26篇文章中的22个决策支持工具,数据提取框架基于国际患者决策辅助标准工具和干预描述与报告模板。
主要发现
- 共识别22个决策支持工具,格式包括纸质、视频或电子,分布于26篇文章。
- 13个工具侧重于知识交换,7个采用交互技术(如Likert量表)支持价值观澄清,9个工具引导 deliberation(如建议讨论话题)。
- 各工具涉及相似主题,但细节、概率量化及呈现方法差异很大,且无工具描述所有潜在筛查危害和结果。
临床怎么用
- 临床选用或开发LDCT筛查决策支持工具时,需注意其内容与呈现方法的异质性,并关注对低健康素养和低计算能力人群的影响。
局限性
- 证据基础有限,需与筛查合格成人协作制定基于证据的共识指南以规范决策支持工具的内容和呈现方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Several countries mandate informed or shared decision-making for low-dose CT (LDCT) lung cancer screening, but knowledge is limited about the type of information and presentation techniques used to support decision-making in practice. This review aimed to characterize the content, format, mode, and presentation methods of decision support tools (DSTs) for LDCT lung cancer screening. DSTs reported within peer-reviewed articles (January 2000-April 2021) were identified systematically from PubMed, PsycInfo, EMBASE, and CINAHL Plus. Inclusion criteria revolved around the development or evaluation of a resource or tool intended to support individual or shared decision-making for LDCT lung cancer screening. The data-charting and extraction framework was based on the International Patient Decision Aids Standards instrument and Template for Intervention Description and Reporting. Extracted data were organized within two categories: (1) study characteristics and context, format, and mode of DST use and (2) DST content and presentation methods. This review identified 22 DSTs in paper, video, or electronic formats across 26 articles. Most DSTs (n = 13) focused on knowledge exchange, whereas seven used interactive techniques to support values clarification (eg, Likert scales) and nine DSTs guided deliberation (eg, suggested discussion topics). The DSTs addressed similar topics, but the detail, quantification of probability, and presentation methods varied considerably. None described all the potential screening harms and results. The heterogeneity in DST design may affect the quality of decision-making, particularly for participants with lower literacy and numeracy. Evidence-based consensus guidelines for DST content and presentation methods should be developed collaboratively with screening-eligible adults.
引用
- Jallow M, Bonfield S, Kurtidu C, et al. Decision Support Tools for Low-Dose CT Lung Cancer Screening: A Scoping Review of Information Content, Format, and Presentation Methods. Chest. 2021. PMID: 34922933. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2021.12.638
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。