文献速递慢阻肺哮喘呼吸道感染

家庭燃气烹饪与取暖健康影响的系统综述与荟萃分析

Estimated health effects from domestic use of gaseous fuels for cooking and heating in high-income, middle-income, and low-income countries: a systematic review and meta-analyses.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet Respir Med · 2024-02-01

该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入116项研究,比较家庭燃气与污染燃料或清洁能源使用对健康结局的影响。与污染燃料相比,燃气显著降低肺炎、喘息、咳嗽、呼吸困难、慢阻肺、支气管炎、肺功能缺陷、严重呼吸疾病或死亡、早产和低出生体重的风险;与电力相比,燃气略增肺炎和慢阻肺风险。

要点

  • 与污染燃料相比,燃气使用显著降低肺炎、喘息、咳嗽、呼吸困难、慢阻肺等呼吸系统疾病风险。
  • 与电力相比,燃气使用与肺炎和慢阻肺风险轻度增加相关,但高质量研究中效应较小且不显著。
  • 在无法近期获得可靠电力的资源匮乏地区,燃气是可考虑的健康过渡燃料选项。

核心结论

  • 从污染燃料转向燃气可降低资源匮乏地区的健康风险和相关发病率与死亡率。
  • 与电力相比燃气对部分健康结局风险略高,但在电力不可及地区仍是重要过渡选项。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与荟萃分析,纳入116项研究(2项RCT、13项病例对照、23项队列、78项横断面),提供215个效应估计。
  • 检索PubMed、Scopus等数据库2020年12月16日至2021年2月6日发表文献,比较燃气与污染燃料或清洁能源的健康结局。

临床怎么用

  • 在依赖污染燃料的资源匮乏地区,推广燃气作为过渡燃料可降低呼吸系统疾病和不良出生结局风险。
  • 政策制定需权衡燃气与电力的健康效应差异,优先在电力不可及地区推广燃气。

局限性

  • 纳入研究多为横断面设计(78项,67%),RCT仅2项(2%),因果推断受限。
  • 与电力比较的高质量研究较少,部分效应估计不精确。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Exposure to household air pollution from polluting domestic fuel (solid fuel and kerosene) represents a substantial global public health burden and there is an urgent need for rapid transition to clean domestic fuels. Gas for cooking and heating might possibly affect child asthma, wheezing, and respiratory health. The aim of this review was to synthesise the evidence on the health effects of gaseous fuels to inform policies for scalable clean household energy. METHODS: In this systematic review and meta-analysis, we summarised the health effects from cooking or heating with gas compared with polluting fuels (eg, wood or charcoal) and clean energy (eg, electricity and solar energy). We searched PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, MEDLINE, Cochrane Library (CENTRAL), Environment Complete, GreenFile, Google Scholar, Wanfang DATA, and CNKI for articles published between Dec 16, 2020, and Feb 6, 2021. Studies eligible for inclusion had to compare gas for cooking or heating with polluting fuels (eg, wood or charcoal) or clean energy (eg, electricity or solar energy) and present data for health outcomes in general populations. Studies that reported health outcomes that were exacerbations of existing underlying conditions were excluded. Several of our reviewers were involved in screening studies, data extraction, and quality assessment (including risk of bias) of included studies; 20% of studies were independently screened, extracted and quality assessed by another reviewer. Disagreements were reconciled through discussion with the wider review team. Included studies were appraised for quality using the Liverpool Quality Assessment Tools. Key health outcomes were grouped for meta-analysis and analysed using Cochrane's RevMan software. Primary outcomes were health effects (eg, acute lower respiratory infections) and secondary outcomes were health symptoms (eg, respiratory symptoms such as wheeze, cough, or breathlessness). This study is registered with PROSPERO, CRD42021227092. FINDINGS: 116 studies were included in the meta-analysis (two [2%] randomised controlled trials, 13 [11%] case-control studies, 23 [20%] cohort studies, and 78 [67%] cross-sectional studies), contributing 215 effect estimates for five grouped health outcomes. Compared with polluting fuels, use of gas significantly lowered the risk of pneumonia (OR 0·54, 95% CI 0·38-0·77; p=0·00080), wheeze (OR 0·42, 0·30-0·59; p<0·0001), cough (OR 0·44, 0·32-0·62; p<0·0001), breathlessness (OR 0·40, 0·21-0·76; p=0·0052), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (OR 0·37, 0·23-0·60; p<0·0001), bronchitis (OR 0·60, 0·43-0·82; p=0·0015), pulmonary function deficit (OR 0·27, 0·17-0·44; p<0·0001), severe respiratory illness or death (OR 0·27, 0·11-0·63; p=0·0024), preterm birth (OR 0·66, 0·45-0·97; p=0·033), and low birth weight (OR 0·70, 0·53-0·93; p=0·015). Non-statistically significant effects were observed for asthma in children (OR 1·04, 0·70-1·55; p=0·84), asthma in adults (OR 0·65, 0·43-1·00; p=0·052), and small for gestational age (OR 1·04, 0·89-1·21; p=0·62). Compared with electricity, use of gas significantly increased risk of pneumonia (OR 1·26, 1·03-1·53; p=0·025) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (OR 1·15, 1·06-1·25; p=0·0011), although smaller non-significant effects were observed for higher-quality studies. In addition, a small increased risk of asthma in children was not significant (OR 1·09, 0·99-1·19; p=0·071) and no significant associations were found for adult asthma, wheeze, cough, and breathlessness (p>0·05). A significant decreased risk of bronchitis was observed (OR 0·87, 0·81-0·93; p<0·0001). INTERPRETATION: Switching from polluting fuels to gaseous household fuels could lower health risk and associated morbidity and mortality in resource-poor countries where reliance on polluting fuels is greatest. Although gas fuel use was associated with a slightly higher risk for some health outcomes compared with electricity, gas is an important transitional option for health in countries where access to reliable electricity supply for cooking or heating is not feasible in the near term. FUNDING: WHO.

来源:Lancet Respir Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Puzzolo E, Fleeman N, Lorenzetti F, et al. Estimated health effects from domestic use of gaseous fuels for cooking and heating in high-income, middle-income, and low-income countries: a systematic review and meta-analyses. Lancet Respir Med. 2024. PMID: 38310914. doi:10.1016/S2213-2600(23)00427-7

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。