结缔组织病相关肺动脉高压照护质量标准与管理最佳实践:德尔菲专家组共识
该研究采用改良德尔菲法,由六個欧洲国家的20名医生和4名执业护士参与,旨在形成SSc及其他CTD相关PAH的照护质量标准和最佳实践共识。共识强调多模态筛查(超声心动图、生物标志物、症状评估)及风湿科与肺高压专科、护士和患者的多学科协作,但在DETECT算法和PH新血流动力学定义方面未达成共识。
要点
- 推荐联合超声心动图、生物标志物和症状评估进行PAH多模态筛查与早期识别
- 强调风湿科医生与肺高压专科医生、执业护士及患者的多学科协作管理
- DETECT筛查算法和PH新血流动力学定义的应用尚未在专家组内达成共识
核心结论
- 专家组就CTD-PAH的多模态筛查标准化及多学科紧密协作等关键建议达成共识。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲专家组研究,纳入来自六个欧洲国家的20名医生和4名执业护士,共识定义为医生间≥80%一致。
主要发现
- 强调通过联合超声心动图、生物标志物检测和症状评估的多模态方法进行PAH筛查和早期发现。
- 就优化筛查和早期发现中超声心动图的可及性提高及其有用性达成共识,并指出心脏病学专业知识对准确评估右心变量的重要性。
- 就风湿科医生与肺高压专科医生、执业护士和患者协作的多学科管理方法达成共识。
- 风湿科医生对DETECT筛查算法的有用性达成一致,但心脏科医生和呼吸科医生意见分歧,未达成共识。
- 关于PH新血流动力学定义对CTD-PAH管理的影响未达成共识,需要更多证据。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识阈值定义为医生间≥80%一致。
- 专家组由20名医生和4名执业护士组成,来自六个欧洲国家。
临床怎么用
- 临床应采用超声心动图、生物标志物和症状评估联合的多模态策略筛查CTD-PAH。
- 管理CTD-PAH时应推动风湿科、肺高压专科、执业护士和患者之间的多学科协作。
局限性
- DETECT筛查算法和PH新血流动力学定义的相关议题未达成专家组共识,需进一步证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Rheumatol Adv Pract. 2026 Jan 14;10(2):rkag003. doi: 10.1093/rap/rkag003. eCollection 2026. ABSTRACT OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to develop a consensus of expert opinion on the quality standards of care and outline management best practices for pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) in SSc and other CTDs. METHODS: Twenty physicians and four nurse practitioners (NPs) managing patients with CTD-PAH (including SSc-PAH) from six European countries participated in a modified Delphi panel. Consensus was defined as ≥80% agreement among the physicians. RESULTS: The importance of a multimodal approach to screening and early detection of PAH through combining echocardiography, biomarker tests and symptom evaluation was emphasised. Consensus agreement was also reached on the usefulness and increased access of echocardiography for optimising screening and early detection processes, noting the importance of cardiology expertise for accurate assessment of right-heart variables. Panellists reached consensus agreement on the importance of a multidisciplinary approach to managing SSc- and other CTD-PAHs through collaboration between rheumatologists and pulmonary hypertension (PH) specialists, NPs and patients. Rheumatologists aligned on the usefulness of the DETECT screening algorithm, whereas cardiologists and pulmonologists remained divided, with consensus not being reached, thus highlighting the lack of agreement regarding the relevance of a stepwise approach. Similarly, no consensus was reached on the impact of the new haemodynamic definition of PH in CTD-PAH management, where greater evidence is required. CONCLUSIONS: Consensus was reached on key recommendations for optimising CTD-PAH management, including the standardisation of multimodal screening and promotion of closer collaboration between healthcare specialties and patients. PMID: 41878556 | PMC: PMC13006206 | DOI: 10.1093/rap/rkag003
引用
- 指南共识 · 肺动脉高压:Defining quality standards of care in CTD-PAH and management best practices: a Delphi panel consensus
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。