经支气管冷冻肺活检标本间质性肺疾病病理诊断中国专家共识
本共识由中国医师协会呼吸医师分会呼吸病理工作组与中华医学会病理学分会胸部疾病学组共同制定,基于文献复习、临床实践和Delphi法形成14条推荐意见,规范经支气管冷冻肺活检(TBLC)标本的送检、质量评价、人为假象识别及间质性肺疾病(ILD)病理诊断原则与流程,供临床诊断及多学科讨论参考。
要点
- TBLC标本直径应大于5 mm,推荐取3至5块。
- 病理医师应记录标本块数、体积、颜色、质地及肺泡实质/气道成分比例。
- TBLC诊断ILD需结合临床变化和HRCT病变分布综合判断。
核心结论
- 共识形成14条推荐意见,规范TBLC标本用于ILD病理诊断的送检、评价和诊断流程。
研究设计与样本
- 中国医师协会呼吸医师分会呼吸病理工作组与中华医学会病理学分会胸部疾病学组共同组织专家,基于文献复习、临床实践、临床问题收集及多次会议讨论,采用Delphi法投票(专家赞成票超过70%)制定本共识。
主要发现
- 共识总结了TBLC标本送检要求、质量评价和常见人为假象,提出了诊断原则、诊断流程、各主要病理改变对应的ILD类型及主要鉴别诊断。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐1:TBLC临床操作者应及时观察测量标本大小,标本直径应大于5 mm,推荐取3至5块。
- 推荐2:病理医师应记录送检组织块数及每块标本的体积、颜色和质地,评估肺泡实质/气道成分比例及病变类型和分布。
- 推荐4:TBLC常见镜下人为假象为大量红细胞、蛋白性液体和纤维素渗出;无含铁血黄素细胞或咯血临床征象时慎诊断肺出血性疾病。
- 推荐5:病变主要位于胸膜或胸膜下肺组织(如胸膜肺实质弹力纤维增生症)时不建议用TBLC诊断。
- 推荐14:LIP在TBLC标本中应显示肺间质弥漫淋巴细胞浸润和淋巴滤泡形成,建议结合胸部CT判断病变是否弥漫以鉴别其他淋巴增殖性疾病。
临床怎么用
- 临床操作者需确保标本直径大于5 mm并取3至5块,病理医师应记录标本大体特征并评估镜下成分比例。
- 病理诊断需结合临床变化和HRCT病变分布综合判断,TBLC标本较小可能不足以显示ILD充分特征。
- 根据主要病理改变对应ILD类型(如UIP、NSIP、OP、AFOP、RB-ILD/DIP、DAD、LIP)并参考推荐意见进行诊断和鉴别诊断。
局限性
- TBLC标本显著小于外科肺活检,可能无法显示ILD的充分特征或继发改变。
- TBLC可能无法充分显示UIP胸膜下和外周肺病变分布及继发病变。
- TBLC标本难以准确评估机化区域比例,且组织结构和病变分布有时难以评价。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Transbronchial lung cryobiopsy (TBLC) is an applicable technique that can provide a histologic diagnosis of interstitial lung disease(ILD). The general sample size of TBLC is much smaller than that of surgical lung biopsy (SLB), which raises more concerns about the procedure's diagnostic accuracy. A guiding consensus and guidelines on the pathological procedure of ILD with TBLC are required to better guide pathologists in diagnostic practice. The Respiratory Pathology Working Group of the Respiratory Physicians Branch of the Chinese Medical Doctor Association and the Thoracic Diseases Group of the Pathological Branch of the Chinese Medical Association, jointly organized by experts, have worked together to discuss and formulated the consensus. The consensus is based on literature review, clinical practice, collection of clinical issues, and discussion during a series of meetings. Experts approved the final proposed consensus with more than 70% of votes in favor (Delphi). The consensus summarized the delivery requirements, quality evaluation and artificial phenomena of TBLC specimens. It also proposed the diagnostic principles and procedures, types of ILD corresponding to major pathological changes, and major corresponding differential diagnoses of TBLC specimens. Finally, the consensus formed 14 recommendations for clinical diagnosis and multidisciplinary discussion.The recommendations are addressed as follows.Recommendation 1: We suggest that the TBLC clinical manipulators should observe and measure the size of the specimen in time. The specimen size should be greater than 5 mm in diameter, and multiple pieces(3 to 5 pieces)are recommended.Recommendation 2: Pathologists should record the number of blocks of tissue submitted for examination and the volume, color, and texture of each specimen. Evaluation of the proportion of alveolar parenchyma/airway components under the microscope, analysis of the type and distribution of lesions will facilitate making diagnostic suggestions.Recommendation 3: The size of TBLC specimens is significantly smaller than SLB and may not show sufficient features of ILD or secondary changes. It is more necessary to combine the evaluation of clinical changes and lesion distribution assessed by HRCT for a comprehensive diagnosis.Recommendation 4: Common microscopic artefacts of TBLC specimen are mass of red blood cells, proteinaceous fluid and fibrin exudation. In the absence of hemosiderin cells or clinical signs of hemoptysis symptoms, the diagnosis of pulmonary hemorrhagic disease should be considered with caution.Recommendation 5: TBLC is not a suggested diagnosis when the pathological changes are mainly located in the pleural or subpleural lung tissues, e.g., pleuroparenchymal fibroelastosis.Recommendation 6: The principle of pathological diagnosis of ILD in TBLC is consistent with SLB, with a description of the main pathological morphological change and a tendentious pathological diagnosis; if the lesion is not fully shown, only a pathological description is given.Recommendation 7: A well-sampled TBLC specimen may show patchy fibrosis and fibroblast foci in UIP, supporting a pathological diagnosis of a probable UIP pattern. TBLC may not display sufficient features of the distribution of subpleural and peripheral lung lesions in UIP, as well as secondary lesions.Recommendation 8: TBLC specimens show diffuse inflammation and fibrosis with well-preserved lung tissue structure, which may support a pathological diagnosis of NSIP; if the distribution of lesions and lung tissue structure are difficult to evaluate, it is recommended that a pathological diagnosis of fibrotic ILD or cellular ILD be made.Recommendation 9: TBLC specimens may show pathological features of NSIP accompanied by organization, but it is difficult to accurately evaluate the proportion of organization area. In this scenario, a descriptive diagnosis of NSIP accompanied by organization is suggested.Recommendation 10: It is recommended to diagnose organizing pneumonia if only distal airway organization is present in TBLC; in addition to organization, if pathological histology is accompanied by obvious interstitial fibrosis and lung tissue remodelling, granuloma formation, obvious neutrophil infiltration or accompanied with abscess formation, obvious eosinophil infiltration, tissue necrosis, hyaline membrane formation or vasculitis, secondary OP should be considered.Recommendation 11: It is recommended to diagnose acute fibrinous and organizing pneumonia (AFOP) if lesions on TBLC show features of organizing pneumonia and fibrin balls.Recommendation 12: A diagnosis of smoking-related ILD (RB-ILD or DIP) is suggested when a good sampling of TBLC shows a significant accumulation of histocytes or smoker's macrophages in the alveolar spaces, and without specific changes sufficient for other diagnoses. If the lesions are confined to the lumen of respiratory bronchioles and the immediate peribronchiolar airspaces, RB-ILD is supported; if the distribution is diffuse, DIP should be considered. If it is difficult to determine the distribution of the lesions, it is necessary to integrate clinical and chest CT imaging findings to differentiate RB-ILD from DIP.Recommendation 13: A well-sampled TBLC specimen can display the pathological features of DAD and then also support such a pathological diagnosis.Recommendation 14: Lymphoid interstitial pneumonia (LIP) should show diffuse lymphocyte infiltration and lymphoid follicle formation in the lung interstitium in TBLC specimens. It is recommended that chest CT imaging be combined to determine whether the lesion is diffuse to differentiate from other lymphoproliferative diseases. 经支气管冷冻肺活检(TBLC)已用于间质性肺疾病(ILD)的病理诊断,TBLC较外科肺活检标本小,病理诊断难度增大,业内缺乏关于TBLC病理诊断ILD的指导性共识/指南,为更好指导病理医师做好TBLC标本ILD的病理诊断,中国医师协会呼吸医师分会呼吸病理工作组、中华医学会病理学分会胸部疾病学组共同组织专家讨论及制定本共识。共识制定小组在文献复习的基础上结合临床实践,收集临床问题,经多次会议讨论及专家投票(Delphi法)形成本共识。共识总结了TBLC标本送检、评价、常见人为假象,提出TBLC标本的诊断原则、诊断流程、各主要病理改变对应的ILD类型以及主要鉴别诊断,并形成14条专家推荐意见,供临床诊断及多学科讨论参考。.
引用
- [Chinese expert consensus on the pathological diagnosis of interstitial lung disease with transbronchial lung cryobiopsy specimens]. Zhonghua Jie He He Hu Xi Za Zhi. 2024. PMID: 39069847. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112147-20231127-00343
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。