文献速递母胎医学

正常与病理条件下自动化彩色组织多普勒 cine loop 分析与手动频谱脉冲波组织多普勒波形描记测量羊胎心脏周期时间间期和心肌速度的一致性:一项实验研究

Agreement between cardiac cycle time intervals and myocardial velocities measured by automated analysis of color tissue Doppler cine loops and by manual tracing of spectral pulsed‐wave tissue Doppler waveforms of sheep fetal heart under normal and pathological conditions: An experimental study
RSS 订阅 · Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica · 2026-10-26

在10只羊胎中行升主动脉缩窄、9只行母体子宫动脉闭塞、4只为对照,于基线及母体低氧诱导的胎儿低氧血症期间序贯获取 cTDI cine loop 与 pwTDI 波形。自动化 cTDI 与手动 pwTDI 的胎心率一致性极好(ICC=0.94),心肌速度与心脏时间间期绝对一致性差至中等(ICC 0.20–0.63),自动化方法测得速度较低、等容间期较长,偏移在各生理状态稳定。自动化 cTDI 与手动 pwTDI 不可直接互换,但适合用方法特异性基线或校准进行纵向评估。

要点

  • 自动化 cTDI 与手动 pwTDI 的胎心率一致性极好(ICC=0.94)。
  • 心肌速度与心脏时间间期绝对一致性差至中等(ICC 0.20–0.63),不可互换。
  • 自动化方法测得速度较低、等容间期较长,偏移在各生理状态稳定。

核心结论

  • 自动化 cTDI 因持续存在方法特异性偏移,不能与手动 pwTDI 直接互换用于羊胎心肌速度或时间间期的绝对测量。
  • 自动化方法提供可重复的相对追踪且在不同生理条件下性能稳定,适合用方法特异性基线或校准进行纵向评估。
  • 胎心率是唯一表现接近可互换的参数。

研究设计与样本

  • 实验研究:10只羊胎行25%–50%升主动脉缩窄,9只行母体子宫动脉闭塞以减少子宫胎盘血流,4只作为对照。
  • 恢复4至5天后,于基线及母体低氧诱导的胎儿低氧血症期间序贯获取 cTDI cine loop 与 pwTDI 波形。
  • cTDI cine loop 用不依赖心电图的自动化算法处理,pwTDI 波形手动描记以测量心脏周期时间间期和心肌速度。

主要发现

  • 胎心率两种方法一致性极好(ICC=0.94)。
  • 心肌速度与心脏时间间期绝对一致性差至中等(ICC范围0.20–0.63)。
  • Bland–Altman 分析显示系统性方法特异性偏移:自动化方法测得速度持续较低、等容间期较长。
  • 这些偏移在各生理状态稳定,经 Benjamini–Hochberg 错误发现率校正后无指标显示偏倚随相位变化(所有 q>0.05)。
  • 一致性及相关性(ICC(C,1) 与 Pearson r)明显高于绝对一致性,Lin 一致性相关系数显示胎心率高一致性(CCC=0.936),多数其他指标一致性较低。

临床怎么用

  • 自动化 cTDI 与手动 pwTDI 不可直接互换用于羊胎心肌速度或时间间期的绝对测量。
  • 自动化 cTDI 适合用方法特异性基线或校准进行纵向评估。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Automated cTDI in sheep fetuses provided reproducible measurements of myocardial velocities and heart rate that align well with manual pulsed-wave TDI. For cardiac cycle duration metrics, the two modalities are not interchangeable. These findings support that automated cTDI is well suited for longitudinal assessment under both physiological and pathological situations when interpreted using method-specific baselines or calibration. Abstract Introduction This study evaluated agreement between automated analysis of color tissue Doppler (cTDI) cine loops and manual spectral pulsed-wave tissue Doppler (pwTDI) measurements of fetal cardiac cycle time intervals and myocardial velocities under normal and pathological conditions in an experimental model using fetal sheep. Material and Methods In 10 sheep fetuses, 25%–50% partial ascending aorta constriction was performed, and in nine, utero-placental blood flow was reduced by maternal uterine artery occlusion. Four fetuses served as controls. Experiments were performed after 4 to 5 days recovery, and cTDI cine loops and pwTDI waveforms were sequentially obtained during baseline and during fetal hypoxemia induced by maternal hypo-oxygenation. cTDI cine loops were processed using an automated, ECG-independent algorithm, whereas pwTDI waveforms were manually traced to measure cardiac cycle time intervals and myocardial velocities. Results Fetal heart rate (FHR) showed excellent agreement between methods (intraclass correlation coefficient, ICC = 0.94). In contrast, myocardial velocities and cardiac time intervals demonstrated poor-to-moderate absolute agreement (ICC range 0.20–0.63). Bland–Altman analysis revealed systematic modality-specific offsets: the automated method yielded consistently lower velocities and longer isovolumic intervals. These offsets were stable across physiological states, with no metric showing phase-dependent changes in bias after Benjamini–Hochberg false discovery rate (FDR) correction (all q > 0.05). Despite limited absolute agreement, consistency and correlation (ICC(C,1) and Pearson r) were markedly higher than absolute agreement, indicating strong preservation of relative ranking across methods. Lin's concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) showed a similar pattern, with high concordance for FHR (CCC = 0.936) and lower concordance for most other metrics. Conclusions Automated cTDI is not directly interchangeable with manual pwTDI for absolute measurements of sheep fetal myocardial velocities or time intervals due to persistent modality-specific offsets. However, the automated method provides reproducible relative tracking and stable performance across different physiological conditions. Automated cTDI is therefore well suited for longitudinal assessments when interpreted using method-specific baselines or calibration. FHR was the only parameter demonstrating near-interchangeable performance.

来源:Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica:Agreement between cardiac cycle time intervals and myocardial velocities measured by automated analysis of color tissue Doppler cine loops and by manual tracing of spectral pulsed‐wave tissue Doppler waveforms of sheep fetal heart under normal and pathological conditions: An experimental study

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。