胎儿超声脑部变异分类:国际德尔菲共识
该国际德尔菲共识通过两轮调查48名专家,对48种胎儿脑部变异按临床意义分为绿色(良性,无需随访)、橙色(需神经超声随访)和红色(需专门神经超声、胎儿脑磁共振和/或基因检查)三类,35种(72.9%)达成共识;该分类尚未经出生后影像或神经发育结局验证,需前瞻性评估后方可用于常规实践。
要点
- 35/48种胎儿脑部变异达成共识:绿色12种、橙色7种、红色16种。
- 绿色变异包括孤立性脉络丛囊肿<10 mm(全孕期)、透明隔腔分隔等。
- 橙色变异包括孤立性颅内透明层增大(解剖保留)、大或双侧脉络丛囊肿等。
核心结论
- 该国际德尔菲共识提出了常见胎儿超声脑部变异的初步专家分类,但尚未经出生后影像或神经发育结局验证,且未评估可重复性,需前瞻性评估后方可用于常规实践。
研究设计与样本
- 两轮国际德尔菲调查,调查数据收集于2025年9月至2026年3月。
- 通过PubMed/MEDLINE范围综述(建库至2025年8月,执行于2025年6月至8月)识别48种胎儿脑部变异,并以代表性超声图像说明。
- 第一轮48名来自14个国家的专家参与,39名(81.3%)完成两轮;共识预定义为≥70%一致。
主要发现
- 48种评估变异中35种(72.9%)经两轮达成共识:12种为绿色、7种为橙色、16种为红色。
- 绿色变异包括全孕期孤立性脉络丛囊肿<10 mm、脉络丛规则不对称、孤立性透明隔腔分隔、韦尔加腔、中间帆腔、胼胝体完整的小透明隔腔及头围和脑形态正常的舟状头。
- 橙色变异包括解剖保留的孤立性颅内透明层增大、大或双侧脉络丛囊肿、无压迫的孤立性蛛网膜下腔增大及孤立性透明隔腔囊肿。
- 红色变异包括后颅窝标志异常(正常三腔解剖消失、脑干-小脑蚓部角增大、脑干-枕骨距离减小)、伴邻近白质异常的室周囊肿、胼胝体增厚及半球间裂变形等。
- 13种(27.1%)变异未达成共识,凸显对细微孤立性不对称及部分囊性变异解读的持续不确定性。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识预定义为≥70%一致。
- 绿色:良性变异,无需额外检查或随访。
- 橙色:需神经超声随访。
- 红色:需专门神经超声、胎儿脑磁共振和/或基因检查。
- 孤立性脉络丛囊肿<10 mm归为绿色(全孕期适用)。
临床怎么用
- 该分类尚未经出生后影像或神经发育结局验证且未评估可重复性,需前瞻性评估后方可用于常规实践。
局限性
- 该分类尚未经出生后影像或神经发育结局验证。
- 该分类的可重复性尚未评估。
- 需前瞻性评估后方可用于常规实践。
- 13种(27.1%)变异未达成共识,凸显对细微孤立性不对称及部分囊性变异解读的持续不确定性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
ABSTRACT Objective To develop an expert consensus classification and management framework for fetal-brain variants identified on prenatal ultrasound across all trimesters of pregnancy that cannot be categorized confidently as either benign or pathological. Methods A two-round international Delphi survey was conducted among experts in fetal medicine and neurosonography, with survey data collected between September 2025 and March 2026. Forty-eight fetal-brain variants, identified through a scoping literature review of PubMed/MEDLINE from database inception to August 2025, performed between June and August 2025, and illustrated with representative ultrasound images, were evaluated. Brain variants were classified according to clinical significance and recommended management into three predefined categories: ‘green’ (benign variants requiring no additional investigation or follow-up), ‘orange’ (requiring neurosonographic follow-up) and ‘red’ (requiring dedicated neurosonography, fetal-brain magnetic resonance imaging and/or genetic investigations). Consensus was predefined as ≥ 70% agreement. In Round 2, experts confirmed their agreement regarding categorization of variants that had reached consensus in Round 1 and reassessed variants that did not reach initial consensus. Results Forty-eight experts from 14 countries participated in Round 1 and 39 (81.3%) completed both rounds. Of the 48 evaluated variants, 35 (72.9%) reached consensus after two rounds: 12 were classified as ‘green’, seven as ‘orange’ and 16 as ‘red’. Green variants included isolated choroid plexus cysts < 10 mm across all trimesters, regular asymmetry of the choroid plexuses, isolated cavum septations, cavum vergae, cavum velum interpositum, isolated small cavum septi pellucidi with intact corpus callosum and dolichocephaly with normal head circumference and normal brain morphology. Orange variants included isolated enlargement of intracranial translucency with preserved anatomy, large or bilateral choroid plexus cysts, isolated enlargement of subarachnoid spaces without compression and isolated cyst of the cavum septi pellucidi. Red variants included abnormal posterior fossa markers (loss of normal three-space anatomy, increased brainstem–vermis angle, reduced brainstem–occipital bone distance), periventricular cysts associated with adjacent white-matter abnormalities, thickened corpus callosum and distortion of the interhemispheric fissure, among other findings. Thirteen (27.1%) variants failed to reach consensus, highlighting persistent uncertainty in interpreting subtle isolated asymmetries and selected cystic variants. Conclusions This international Delphi consensus proposes an initial expert-derived classification of commonly encountered feta-brain variants on ultrasound. Because the classification has not been validated against postnatal imaging or neurodevelopmental outcomes and reproducibility has not been assessed, prospective evaluation is required before it can be applied in routine practice. © 2026 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology:Classification of brain variants on fetal ultrasound: international Delphi consensus
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。