新产科安全质量指数:整合剖宫产率与母儿结局
本研究在单中心12名产科医生接诊的535例足月初产单胎头位产妇中,构建整合高危因素调整后剖宫产率与母儿并发症的单一指标——产科安全质量指数。粗剖宫产率排名与该指数排名不相关(rho=0.05),12名医生中8名排名四分位发生变化,提示新指标可更全面评价产科质量。
要点
- 粗剖宫产率排名与整合母儿结局的新指数排名不相关(rho=0.05)
- 调整高危因素和母儿结局后,12名医生中8名排名四分位改变
- 新指数可用于个体医生及医院间产科质量比较
核心结论
- 考虑高危母体因素及母儿结局后,基于粗剖宫产率的排名发生显著变化。
- 产科安全质量指数作为单一指标,可识别机构内改善临床实践标准的途径。
- 该指标可比较个体产科医生及开展产科医院的医疗质量。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,纳入单中心12名随机选择的产科医生接诊的535例足月初产单胎头位产妇。
- 回顾1070份母儿病历(535份母体、535份新生儿),量化粗剖宫产率、调整剖宫产率及母儿并发症。
- 通过logistic回归模型估计医生特异性粗剖宫产率及调整母儿并发症后的剖宫产率,并推导产科安全质量指数。
主要发现
- 粗剖宫产率排名与基于产科安全质量指数的最终排名不相关(rho=0.05;95%CI -0.54至0.60)。
- 12名产科医生中8名在调整高危母体状况及母儿结局后排名四分位发生变化。
- 基于≥1个母体和/或新生儿并发症的排名与基于≥2个并发症的排名强相关(rho=0.63;95%CI 0.08-0.88)。
关键数值与推荐
- 研究人群为足月初产单胎头位胎儿,由12名产科医生接诊,共535例产妇。
- 母儿并发症分别按≥1个和≥2个母体和/或新生儿并发症进行分析。
临床怎么用
- 临床质量评价不应仅依赖粗剖宫产率,应整合高危母体因素及母儿结局。
- 产科安全质量指数可作为机构内临床实践标准改进的单一指标。
- 该指数可用于个体产科医生及医院间的产科质量比较。
局限性
- 单中心横断面研究,样本来自12名随机选择的产科医生。
- 仅纳入足月初产单胎头位产妇,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cesarean delivery rates have been used as obstetrical quality indicators. However, these approaches do not consider the accompanying maternal and neonatal morbidities. A challenge in the field of obstetrics has been to establish a valid outcomes quality measure that encompasses preexisting high-risk maternal factors and associated maternal and neonatal morbidities and is universally acceptable to all stakeholders, including patients, healthcare providers, payers, and governmental agencies. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to (1) establish a new single metric for obstetrical quality improvement among nulliparous patients with term singleton vertex-presenting fetus, integrating cesarean delivery rates adjusted for preexisting high-risk maternal factors with associated maternal and neonatal morbidities, and (2) determine whether obstetrician quality ranking by this new metric is different compared with the rating based on individual crude and/or risk-adjusted cesarean delivery rates. The single metric has been termed obstetrical safety and quality index. STUDY DESIGN: This was a cross-sectional study of all nulliparous patients with term singleton vertex-presenting fetuses delivered by 12 randomly chosen obstetricians in a single institution. A review of all records was performed, including a review of maternal high-risk factors and maternal and neonatal outcomes. Maternal and neonatal medical records were reviewed to determine crude and adjusted cesarean delivery rates by obstetricians and quantify maternal and neonatal complications. We estimated the obstetrician-specific crude cesarean delivery rates and rates adjusted for obstetrician-specific maternal and neonatal complications from logistic regression models. From this model, we derived the obstetrical safety and quality index for each obstetrician. The final ranking based on the obstetrical safety and quality index was compared with the initial ranking by crude cesarean delivery rates. Maternal and neonatal morbidities were analyzed as ≥1 and ≥2 maternal and/or neonatal complications. RESULTS: These 12 obstetricians delivered a total of 535 women; thus, 1070 (535 maternal and 535 neonatal) medical records were reviewed to determine crude and adjusted cesarean delivery rates by obstetricians and quantify maternal and neonatal complications. The ranking of crude cesarean delivery rates was not correlated (rho=0.05; 95% confidence interval, -0.54 to 0.60) to the final ranking based on the obstetrical safety and quality index. Of note, 8 of 12 obstetricians shifted their rank quartiles after adjustments for high-risk maternal conditions and maternal and neonatal outcomes. There was a strong correlation between the ranking based on ≥1 maternal and/or neonatal complication and ranking based on ≥2 maternal and/or neonatal complications (rho=0.63; 95% confidence interval, 0.08-0.88). CONCLUSION: Ranking based on crude cesarean delivery rates varied significantly after considering high-risk maternal conditions and associated maternal and neonatal outcomes. Therefore, the obstetrical safety and quality index, a single metric, was developed to identify ways to improve clinician practice standards within an institution. Use of this novel quality measure may help to change initiatives geared toward patient safety, balancing cesarean delivery rates with optimal maternal and neonatal outcomes. This metric could be used to compare obstetrical quality not only among individual obstetricians but also among hospitals that practice obstetrics.
引用
- Ramani S, Halpern TA, Akerman M, et al. A new index for obstetrics safety and quality of care: integrating cesarean delivery rates with maternal and neonatal outcomes. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 34634261. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2021.10.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。