文献速递生殖医学

不孕夫妇对新鲜胚胎移植与全胚冷冻后冻融胚胎移植的偏好:离散选择实验

Assessing couples' preferences for fresh or frozen embryo transfer: a discrete choice experiment.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2021-01-01

该离散选择实验于2018年8月至2019年1月在一家三级转诊中心调查未接触过IVF的不孕夫妇,让他们在9个假设任务中,在新鲜胚胎移植与全胚冷冻后冻融胚胎移植间选择。结果显示,夫妇的偏好由活产率、流产率、新生儿并发症率和费用驱动,而非治疗流程差异。

要点

  • 活产率、流产率、新生儿并发症和费用是驱动夫妇偏好的关键因素。
  • 夫妇对新鲜与冻融胚胎移植无强烈偏好,但更看重结局而非流程差异。
  • 夫妇愿意为活产率提高支付额外费用,并要求补偿以接受新生儿并发症风险增加。

核心结论

  • 夫妇对新鲜胚胎移植与冻融胚胎移植的偏好主要受活产率、流产率、新生儿并发症率和费用驱动。
  • 夫妇对治疗流程差异(如胚胎移植延迟和OHSS风险)不敏感。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用离散选择实验(DCE)技术,于2018年8月至2019年1月在一家三级转诊中心调查未接触过IVF的不孕夫妇。
  • 向180对符合纳入标准的夫妇发放360份个人问卷,回收212份,回应率58.8%。
  • 使用误差成分混合logit模型估计偏好权重,并计算支付意愿和边际替代率。

主要发现

  • 与不接受IVF治疗相比,夫妇偏好新鲜胚胎移植(OR 27.93)和冻融胚胎移植(OR 28.06),两者间无强烈偏好。
  • 夫妇强烈偏好活产率提高5%(P=0.006)和15%(P<0.0001)、流产率降低18%(P<0.0001)及新生儿并发症降低10%(P<0.0001)的IVF技术。
  • 受访者愿意为活产率提高5%和15%分别额外支付£2451(95%CI 604-4299)和£761(95%CI 5056-9265)。
  • 夫妇愿意接受活产率降低1.26%(95%CI 1.001-1.706)以换取每活产新生儿并发症风险降低1%。

临床怎么用

  • 若实施全胚冷冻策略,在成功率提高或新生儿并发症降低的前提下,患者可能接受。
  • 个体化诊疗应考虑患者对预期临床结局和风险的偏好。

局限性

  • DCE可能引发意图而非实际行为。
  • 研究在单一中心进行且IVF公共资助慷慨,外部有效性受限。
  • 不能排除选择偏倚或应答者偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: What are couples' preferences for fresh embryo transfer versus freezing of all embryos followed by frozen embryo transfer and the associated clinical outcomes that may differentiate them? SUMMARY ANSWER: Couples' preferences are driven by anticipated chances of live birth, miscarriage, neonatal complications, and costs but not by the differences in the treatment process (including delay of embryo transfer linked to frozen embryo transfer and risk of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS) associated with fresh embryo transfer). WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: A policy of freezing all embryos followed by transfer of frozen embryos results in livebirth rates which are similar to or higher than those following the transfer of fresh embryos while reducing the risk of OHSS and small for gestational age babies: it can, however, increase the risk of pre-eclampsia and large for gestational age offspring. Hence, the controversy continues over whether to do fresh embryo transfer or freeze all embryos followed by frozen embryo transfer. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: We used a discrete choice experiment (DCE) technique to survey infertile couples between August 2018 and January 2019. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: We asked IVF naïve couples attending a tertiary referral centre to independently complete a questionnaire with nine hypothetical choice tasks between fresh and frozen embryo transfer. The alternatives varied across the choice occurrences on several attributes including efficacy (live birth rate), safety (miscarriage rate, neonatal complication rate), and cost of treatment. We assumed that a freeze-all strategy prolonged treatment but reduced the risk of OHSS. An error components mixed logit model was used to estimate the relative value (utility) that couples placed on the alternative treatment approaches and the attributes used to describe them. Willingness to pay and marginal rates of substitution between the non-cost attributes were calculated. A total of 360 individual questionnaires were given to 180 couples who fulfilled the inclusion criteria, of which 212 were completed and returned Our study population included 3 same sex couples (2 females and 1 male) and 101 heterosexual couples. Four questionnaires were filled by one partner only. The response rate was 58.8%. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Couples preferred both fresh and frozen embryo transfer (odds ratio 27.93 and 28.06, respectively) compared with no IVF treatment, with no strong preference for fresh over frozen. Couples strongly preferred any IVF technique that offered an increase in live birth rates by 5% (P = 0.006) and 15% (P < 0.0001), reduced miscarriage by 18% (P < 0.0001) and diminished neonatal complications by 10% (P < 0.0001). Respondents were willing to pay an additional £2451 (95% CI 604 - 4299) and £761 (95% CI 5056-9265) for a 5 and 15% increase in the chance of live birth, respectively, regardless of whether this involved fresh or frozen embryos. They required compensation of £5230 (95% CI 3320 - 7141) and £13 245 (95% CI 10 110-16 380) to accept a 10 and 25% increase in the risk of neonatal complications, respectively (P < 0.001). Results indicated that couples would be willing to accept a 1.26% (95% CI 1.001 - 1.706) reduction in the live birth rate for a 1% reduction in the risk of neonatal complications per live birth. Older couples appeared to place less emphasis on the risk of neonatal complications than younger couples. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: DCEs can elicit intentions which may not reflect actual behaviour. The external validity of this study is limited by the fact that it was conducted in a single centre with generous public funding for IVF. We cannot rule out the potential for selection or responder bias. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: If a strategy of freeze all was to be implemented it would appear to be acceptable to patients, if either success rates can be improved or neonatal complications reduced. Live birth rates, neonatal complication rates, miscarriage rates, and cost are more likely to drive their preferences than a slight delay in the treatment process. The results of this study have important implications for future economic evaluations of IVF, as they suggest that the appropriate balance needs to be struck between success and safety. A holistic approach incorporating patient preferences for expected clinical outcomes and risks should be taken into consideration for individualized care. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): No external funding was sought for this study. A.M. is the chief investigator of the randomized controlled trial 'Freeze all'. S.B. is an Editor in Chief of Human Reproduction Open. The other co-authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. Graham Scotland reports non-financial support from Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany, outside the submitted work. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Abdulrahim B, Scotland G, Bhattacharya S, et al. Assessing couples' preferences for fresh or frozen embryo transfer: a discrete choice experiment. Hum Reprod. 2021. PMID: 34550368. doi:10.1093/humrep/deab207

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。