经阴道自然腔道内镜手术与腹腔镜附件切除术随机对照试验
这项单中心、单盲、平行组随机对照试验纳入67例良性附件肿块患者,比较经阴道自然腔道内镜手术(vNOTES)与腹腔镜附件切除术。主要终点为按分配技术完成附件切除术,两组均无中转,vNOTES非劣效于腹腔镜(单侧95%上限13%低于预设15%界值)。vNOTES手术时间更短、疼痛评分更低、镇痛药总量更少,但不良事件有增多趋势。
要点
- vNOTES附件切除术中转率非劣效于腹腔镜,单侧95%上限13%低于15%界值。
- vNOTES组手术时间更短、疼痛评分更低、镇痛药总量更少。
- vNOTES组不良事件有增多趋势,需关注安全性。
核心结论
- vNOTES附件切除术无中转成功完成方面非劣效于腹腔镜。
- vNOTES手术时间更短且术后疼痛更轻,但不良事件有增多趋势。
研究设计与样本
- 平行组、1:1、单中心、单盲随机对照试验,设计为非劣效性研究,界值15%。
- 比利时教学医院开展,纳入67例非妊娠非处女、子宫完整、道格拉斯窝未闭塞、超声按IOTA标准评估为良性附件肿块的患者。
- 随机分配至腹腔镜组(33例)或vNOTES组(34例),按附件大小分层,通过假切口对参与者和结局评估者设盲。
主要发现
- 主要终点在两组均始终达到,无中转。
- 敏感性分析假设vNOTES组1例中转、腹腔镜组0例中转,中转比例差异的单侧95%上限估计为13%,低于预设非劣效界值15%。
- vNOTES组手术时间更短、疼痛评分更低、镇痛药总剂量更少,不良事件有增多趋势。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效界值为15%。
- 敏感性分析中vNOTES组假设1例中转、腹腔镜组0例中转,单侧95%上限为13%。
临床怎么用
- 对于符合条件的良性附件肿块患者,vNOTES可作为腹腔镜附件切除术的非劣效替代方案。
- vNOTES可能缩短手术时间并减轻术后疼痛,但需警惕不良事件增多的趋势。
局限性
- 单中心、样本量较小(共67例),结果需更大样本验证。
- 不良事件增多趋势需进一步研究确认。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare adnexectomy by vaginal Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery (vNOTES) versus laparoscopy. DESIGN: Parallel group, 1:1 single-centre single-blinded randomised trial, designed as non-inferiority study with a margin of 15%. SETTING: Belgian teaching hospital. POPULATION: Non-pregnant non-virgin women with an intact uterus and without obliteration of the pouch of Douglas scheduled to undergo removal of an adnexal mass assessed to be benign on ultrasound by IOTA criteria. METHODS: Randomisation to laparoscopy (control group) or vNOTES (experimental group). Stratification according to adnexal size. Blinding of participants and outcome assessors by sham incisions. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome measure was adnexectomy by the allocated technique. Secondary outcomes included duration of surgery, pain scores and analgesics used, quality of life and adverse events. RESULTS: We randomly assigned 67 participants (34 to the vNOTES group and 33 to the laparoscopy group). The primary end point was always reached in both groups: there were no conversions. We performed a sensitivity analysis for the primary outcome, assuming one conversion in the vNOTES group and no conversions in the laparoscopy group: the one-sided 95% upper limit for the differences in proportions of conversion was estimated as 13%, which is below the predefined non-inferiority margin of 15%. The secondary outcomes demonstrated a shorter duration of surgery, lower pain scores, lower total dose of analgesics and a trend for more adverse events in the vNOTES group. CONCLUSIONS: vNOTES is non-inferior to laparoscopy for a successful adnexectomy without conversion. vNOTES allowed shorter operating times and less postoperative pain but there was a trend for more adverse events.
引用
- Baekelandt J, De Mulder PA, Le Roy I, et al. Adnexectomy by vaginal Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery versus laparoscopy: results of a first randomised controlled trial (NOTABLE trial). BJOG. 2021. PMID: 34246198. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.16838
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。