输精管复通术与取精联合体外受精的当代比较分析
本文为文献综述,比较输精管结扎术后男性恢复生育的两大选择:输精管复通术(VR)与手术取精联合体外受精(IVF)。综述围绕梗阻间期、女性伴侣年龄、抗精子抗体、男性伴侣年龄、女性不孕因素及费用等考量进行比较,指出两种方式总体妊娠率相似,具体选择应基于个体情况并通过共享决策确定。
要点
- VR与取精联合IVF均为输精管结扎术后恢复生育的合理选择,总体妊娠率相似。
- 无保险覆盖时,VR常比IVF更具成本效益;若合并女性不孕因素,IVF常更优。
- 选择需综合梗阻间期、双方年龄、女性不孕因素及费用,并与生殖泌尿外科及生殖内分泌专家充分讨论。
核心结论
- 输精管复通术或手术取精联合IVF均为输精管结扎术后寻求生育的夫妇的合理选择。
- 两种选择的妊娠率总体相似,最终决策应通过共享决策并综合考虑相关因素后做出。
研究设计与样本
- 文献综述,设置于迈阿密大学米勒医学院,对象为既往输精管结扎术后现寻求生育的男性。
- 比较两种主要方式:输精管复通术(VR)与手术取精联合体外受精(IVF)。
主要发现
- VR与IVF均为合理选择,具体情形可能因梗阻间期、女性不孕因素、女性伴侣年龄、男性伴侣年龄及费用而倾向某一方式。
- 无保险覆盖时,VR常比IVF更具成本效益;当除输精管结扎外还可能存在女性因素不孕时,IVF常为更好选择。
- 成功VR后抗精子抗体不太可能导致不孕。
关键数值与推荐
- 比较考量因素包括:梗阻间期、女性伴侣年龄、抗精子抗体、男性伴侣年龄、女性不孕因素及费用。
- 两种选择的妊娠率总体相似。
临床怎么用
- 在决定采用任一方式前,必须与具备显微外科VR技能的生殖泌尿外科医生及精通IVF的生殖内分泌医生进行充分讨论。
- 最终选择应通过共享决策,综合考虑梗阻间期、双方年龄、女性不孕因素及费用等因素后确定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To explore the primary options available to men who desire fertility after a vasectomy. DESIGN: Literature review. SETTING: University of Miami Miller School of Medicine. PATIENT(S): Men with a previous vasectomy now seeking fertility. INTERVENTION(S): The two main options to achieve paternity for men following vasectomy include vasectomy reversal (VR) and surgical sperm retrieval with subsequent in vitro fertilization (IVF). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): We reviewed and compared the important considerations for men deciding between these 2 options, including: obstructive interval, female partner age, antisperm antibodies, male partner age, female infertility factors, and cost. RESULT(S): Both VR and IVF represent reasonable options for the couple seeking fertility after vasectomy. Specific circumstances may favor one modality over another, depending on obstructive interval, possible female fertility factors, female partner age, male partner age, and cost. In the absence of insurance coverage, VR is often more cost-effective than IVF. Alternatively, when a female factor may contribute to infertility in addition to vasectomy, IVF is often the better choice. Antisperm antibodies are unlikely to contribute to infertility following a successful VR. CONCLUSION(S): VR or surgical sperm retrieval with IVF are reasonable options for couples seeking children after vasectomy. Pregnancy rates for both options are overall similar, so prior to pursuing either option, a thorough discussion with a reproductive urologist who possesses microsurgical skills in VR and a reproductive endocrinologist with expertise in IVF is imperative. Making a final choice through shared decision-making while considering these points is ideal.
引用
- Dubin JM, White J, Ory J, et al. Vasectomy reversal vs. sperm retrieval with in vitro fertilization: a contemporary, comparative analysis. Fertil Steril. 2021. PMID: 34053510. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2021.03.050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。