文献速递妇科产科

盆腔器官脱垂术后失败亚型与生活质量结局的纵向聚类分析

Subgroups of failure after surgery for pelvic organ prolapse and associations with quality of life outcomes: a longitudinal cluster analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2021-06-19

本研究对709例接受盆腔器官脱垂手术的患者进行最长5年随访,采用纵向聚类分析识别出4种手术失败亚型。无症状间歇性前壁失败患者的生活质量与手术成功者相似;有症状间歇性前壁失败患者解剖相似但持续报告膨出症状且生活质量最低。有症状全腔室失败患者术后早期即出现症状和解剖失败,再治疗率最高。

要点

  • 盆腔器官脱垂术后失败存在4种不同亚型,其症状、解剖和再治疗情况各异。
  • 有症状间歇性前壁失败患者生活质量最低,需重点关注。
  • 有症状全腔室失败患者再治疗率最高,需早期识别干预。

核心结论

  • 盆腔器官脱垂术后失败可聚类为4种亚型:无症状间歇性前壁失败、有症状间歇性前壁失败、无症状间歇性前壁和后壁失败、有症状全腔室失败。
  • 各亚型在膨出症状、解剖和再治疗方面与生活质量结局的关联不同。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为纵向队列分析,纳入709例接受盆腔器官脱垂手术且符合4项多中心手术试验之一的参与者,随访至5年。
  • 手术失败定义为复合标准:解剖成功(POP-Q Ba、Bp、C点均≤0)、主观成功(无困扰性阴道膨出症状)且无因脱垂再治疗。
  • 对经历手术失败且从基线至术后60个月至少完成4次访视的参与者进行纵向聚类,考虑Ba、Bp、C点和阴道膨出困扰程度的轨迹,并填补缺失数据。
  • 手术成功者归入单独聚类。

主要发现

  • 709例女性中276例(39%)报告手术失败。
  • 无症状间歇性前壁失败(n=150)的Ba值平均约-1厘米,在解剖成功(Ba≤0)和失败(Ba>0)之间波动,与手术成功者相似。
  • 有症状间歇性前壁失败(n=82)解剖上与无症状间歇性前壁失败相似,但持续报告困扰性膨出症状,且生活质量、SF-6D健康指数和感知成功率最低。
  • 无症状间歇性前壁和后壁失败(n=28)术前脱垂最严重,但症状性失败率和再治疗率最低。
  • 有症状全腔室失败(n=16)术后早期即出现症状和解剖失败,再治疗率在所有聚类中最高。

关键数值与推荐

  • 手术失败复合标准要求解剖成功(Ba、Bp、C点均≤0)、主观成功(无困扰性阴道膨出症状)且无再治疗。
  • 有症状间歇性前壁失败聚类的生活质量和SF-6D健康指数得分最低。
  • 有症状全腔室失败聚类的再治疗率最高。

临床怎么用

  • 临床评估盆腔器官脱垂手术结局时,应认识到失败存在异质性,不能仅用二分法判断。
  • 对有症状间歇性前壁失败患者,需关注其生活质量受损,可能需针对性干预。
  • 对有症状全腔室失败患者,应早期识别并考虑再治疗。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Treatment outcomes after pelvic organ prolapse surgery are often presented as dichotomous "success or failure" based on anatomic and symptom criteria. However, clinical experience suggests that some women with outcome "failures" are asymptomatic and perceive their surgery to be successful and that other women have anatomic resolution but continue to report symptoms. Characterizing failure types could be a useful step to clarify definitions of success, understand mechanisms of failure, and identify individuals who may benefit from specific therapies. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to identify clusters of women with similar failure patterns over time and assess associations among clusters and the Pelvic Organ Prolapse Distress Inventory, Short-Form Six-Dimension health index, Patient Global Impression of Improvement, patient satisfaction item questionnaire, and quality-adjusted life-year. STUDY DESIGN: Outcomes were evaluated for up to 5 years in a cohort of participants (N=709) with stage ≥2 pelvic organ prolapse who underwent surgical pelvic organ prolapse repair and had sufficient follow-up in 1 of 4 multicenter surgical trials conducted by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Pelvic Floor Disorders Network. Surgical success was defined as a composite measure requiring anatomic success (Pelvic Organ Prolapse Quantification system points Ba, Bp, and C of ≤0), subjective success (absence of bothersome vaginal bulge symptoms), and absence of retreatment for pelvic organ prolapse. Participants who experienced surgical failure and attended ≥4 visits from baseline to 60 months after surgery were longitudinally clustered, accounting for similar trajectories in Ba, Bp, and C and degree of vaginal bulge bother; moreover, missing data were imputed. Participants with surgical success were grouped into a separate cluster. RESULTS: Surgical failure was reported in 276 of 709 women (39%) included in the analysis. Failures clustered into the following 4 mutually exclusive subgroups: (1) asymptomatic intermittent anterior wall failures, (2) symptomatic intermittent anterior wall failures, (3) asymptomatic intermittent anterior and posterior wall failures, and (4) symptomatic all-compartment failures. Each cluster had different bulge symptoms, anatomy, and retreatment associations with quality of life outcomes. Asymptomatic intermittent anterior wall failures (n=150) were similar to surgical successes with Ba values that averaged around -1 cm but fluctuated between anatomic success (Ba≤0) and failure (Ba>0) over time. Symptomatic intermittent anterior wall failures (n=82) were anatomically similar to asymptomatic intermittent anterior failures, but women in this cluster persistently reported bothersome bulge symptoms and the lowest quality of life, Short-Form Six-Dimension health index scores, and perceived success. Women with asymptomatic intermittent anterior and posterior wall failures (n=28) had the most severe preoperative pelvic organ prolapse but the lowest symptomatic failure rate and retreatment rate. Participants with symptomatic all-compartment failures (n=16) had symptomatic and anatomic failure early after surgery and the highest retreatment of any cluster. CONCLUSION: In particular, the following 4 clusters of pelvic organ prolapse surgical failure were identified in participants up to 5 years after pelvic organ prolapse surgery: asymptomatic intermittent anterior wall failures, symptomatic intermittent anterior wall failures, asymptomatic intermittent anterior and posterior wall failures, and symptomatic all-compartment failures. These groups provide granularity about the nature of surgical failures after pelvic organ prolapse surgery. Future work is planned for predicting these distinct outcomes using patient characteristics that can be used for counseling women individually.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jelovsek JE, Gantz MG, Lukacz ES, et al. Subgroups of failure after surgery for pelvic organ prolapse and associations with quality of life outcomes: a longitudinal cluster analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 34157280. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2021.06.068

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。