宫颈癌筛查退出资格:全国与安全网队列比较
研究评估64岁女性是否符合宫颈癌筛查退出标准,比较全国保险数据库(590,901人)与安全网健康中心(1,544人)两个队列。结果显示仅22.2%和34.2%符合退出条件,多数女性数据不足以满足退出标准。
要点
- 全国队列中22.2%符合退出资格,安全网队列为34.2%。
- 多数女性缺乏足够数据满足退出标准,全国64.7%、安全网56.7%。
- 即使有10年索赔数据,仅41.5%符合停止筛查条件。
核心结论
- 两个队列约三分之二女性不符合宫颈癌筛查退出资格。
- 退出筛查前需额外步骤确认资格,以减少65岁以上可预防宫颈癌。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,全国保险索赔数据库纳入2016-2018年64岁有雇主保险女性590,901人。
- 安全网健康中心纳入2019年64-66岁接受初级保健女性1,544人。
主要发现
- 全国队列131,059人(22.2%)符合退出,其中1.6%因子宫切除、20.6%因筛查阴性。
- 安全网队列528人(34.2%)符合退出,其中9.3%因子宫切除、24.9%因筛查阴性。
- 全国382,509人(64.7%)和安全网875人(56.7%)数据不足以满足退出标准。
- 有10年保险索赔数据的女性中仅41.5%符合停止筛查条件。
关键数值与推荐
- 退出标准:无宫颈癌或HIV阳性证据,过去25年无宫颈癌前病变证据,且有子宫切除(含宫颈切除)证据或满足退出标准(过去10年两次HPV筛查或HPV联合Pap共检测或三次Pap检测且无异常结果)。
临床怎么用
- 对64岁女性评估筛查退出资格时,需核实既往筛查和子宫切除记录。
- 数据不足者不应直接退出筛查,需补充信息确认资格。
局限性
- 全国队列依赖保险索赔数据,安全网队列依赖电子病历,可能存在数据不完整。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine eligibility for discontinuation of cervical cancer screening. METHODS: Women aged 64 with employer-sponsored insurance enrolled in a national database between 2016 and 2018, and those aged 64-66 receiving primary care at a safety net health center in 2019 were included. Patients were evaluated for screening exit eligibility by current guidelines: no evidence of cervical cancer or HIV-positive status and no evidence of cervical precancer in the past 25 years, and had evidence of either hysterectomy with removal of the cervix or evidence of fulfilling screening exit criteria, defined as two HPV screening tests or HPV plus Pap co-tests or three Pap tests within the past 10 years without evidence of an abnormal result. RESULTS: Of the 590,901 women in the national claims database, 131,059 (22.2%) were eligible to exit due to hysterectomy (1.6%) or negative screening (20.6%). Of the 1544 women from the safety net health center, 528 (34.2%) were eligible to exit due to hysterectomy (9.3%) or negative screening (24.9%). Most women did not have sufficient data available to fulfill exit criteria: 382,509 (64.7%) in the national database and 875 (56.7%) in the safety net hospital system. Even among women with 10 years of insurance claims data, only 41.5% qualified to discontinue screening. CONCLUSIONS: Examining insurance claims in a national database and electronic medical records at a safety net institution led to remarkably similar findings: two thirds of women fail to qualify for screening exit. Additional steps to ensure eligibility prior to screening exit may be necessary to decrease preventable cervical cancers among women aged >65. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: N/A.
引用
- Mills JM, Morgan JR, Dhaliwal A, et al. Eligibility for cervical cancer screening exit: Comparison of a national and safety net cohort. Gynecol Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34090706. doi:10.1016/j.ygyno.2021.05.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。