单基因病植入前遗传学检测夫妇的动机、决策因素、态度与体验综述
本综述系统检索三大数据库,纳入正在或已完成植入前遗传学检测(PGT)患者的动机、态度、决策因素与体验研究。患者主要动机为生育健康子代及避免终止妊娠,决策受IVF需求、技术可接受性、费用及伦理立场影响,过程被认为极不便利且心理负担重。
要点
- 患者主要动机是生育健康子代和避免终止妊娠。
- 决策因素包括IVF需求、技术可接受性、费用和伦理立场。
- PGT过程被患者认为极不便利且心理负担重。
核心结论
- 患者使用PGT主要受生育健康子代和避免终止妊娠驱动,决策受IVF需求、技术可接受性、费用和伦理立场影响。
- 患者认为PGT过程极不便利且心理负担重,需多学科团队在检测前后提供全面咨询与支持。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA指南系统检索三个计算机数据库的英文同行评议期刊,不限研究设计与发表时间。
- 纳入考察正在或已完成PGT患者的动机、态度、决策因素与体验的研究,排除假设情境或仅用于非整倍体检测的研究。
- 采用主题分析法提取定性数据。
主要发现
- 有患病子女或既往终止妊娠经历者更可能使用PGT。
- 患者因道德责任或避免内疚而感到有义务利用现有技术。
- 对PGT用于致死或严重儿童期疾病有普遍共识,对成人发病或表现度可变疾病共识较少。
- 一致认为PGT不应被用于选择审美特征,并对社会对PGT的看法感到沮丧。
- 夫妇难以权衡PGT的全部获益与代价,导致矛盾心理和长期犹豫不决。
临床怎么用
- 在PGT使用前及过程中,由遗传学家、IVF临床医生、心理学家和患者支持团体组成的多学科团队对患者进行整体评估和全面咨询。
局限性
- 需要采用经过验证的心理测量工具在PGT过程不同阶段开展大型前瞻性研究,以建立数据库更好帮助患者决策和改善体验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In pre-implantation genetic testing (PGT), fertile couples undergo IVF with genetic testing of embryos to avoid conceptions with a genetic condition. There is an exponentially increasing uptake with over 600 applications listed by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority in the UK. The psychological aspects of the decision-making process and the experience of PGT, however, are relatively underevaluated, with the potential to leave patients unsupported in their journeys. OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE: In this review, we aim to comprehensively report on every aspect of couples' experiences of PGT. We consider what motivates users, the practical and ethical decisions involved and how couples navigate the decision-making process. Additionally, we report on the social and psychological impact on couples who are actively undergoing or have completed the PGT process. SEARCH METHODS: A systematic search of English peer-reviewed journals of three computerized databases was undertaken following PRISMA guidelines. Studies that examined the motivations, attitudes, decision-making factors and experiences of patients who have been actively engaged in the PGT process were included. No restrictions were placed on study design or date of publication. Studies examining patients using PGT in a hypothetical context or solely using PGT for aneuploidy were excluded. Qualitative data were extracted using thematic analysis. OUTCOMES: The main outcomes were patient motivations, deciding factors and attitudes, as well as the patient experience of coming to a decision and going through PGT.Patients were primarily motivated by the desire to have a healthy child and to avoid termination of pregnancy. Those with a sick child or previous experience of termination were more likely to use PGT. Patients also felt compelled to make use of the technology available, either from a moral responsibility to do so or to avoid feelings of guilt if not. The main factors considered when deciding to use PGT were the need for IVF and the acceptability of the technology, the financial cost of the procedure and one's ethical standpoint on the creation and manipulation of embryos. There was a general consensus that PGT should be applied to lethal or severe childhood disease but less agreement on use for adult onset or variable expression conditions. There was an agreement that it should not be used to select for aesthetic traits and a frustration with the views of PGT in society. We report that couples find it difficult to consider all of the benefits and costs of PGT, resulting in ambivalence and prolonged indecision. After deciding on PGT use, we found that patients find the process extremely impractical and psychologically demanding. WIDER IMPLICATIONS: This review aimed to summarize the current knowledge on how patients decide to use and experience PGT and to make suggestions to incorporate the findings into clinical practice. We cannot stress enough the importance of holistic evaluation of patients and thorough counselling prior to and during PGT use from a multidisciplinary team that includes geneticists, IVF clinicians, psychologists and also patient support groups. Large prospective studies using a validated psychological tool at various stages of the PGT process would provide an invaluable database for professionals to better aid patients in their decision-making and to improve the patient experience.
引用
- Hughes T, Bracewell-Milnes T, Saso S, et al. A review on the motivations, decision-making factors, attitudes and experiences of couples using pre-implantation genetic testing for inherited conditions. Hum Reprod Update. 2021. PMID: 33969393. doi:10.1093/humupd/dmab013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。