文献速递母胎医学产科

胎儿膈疝超声胃位置分类的评估者间一致性研究

Interrater agreement for sonographic stomach position classification in fetal diaphragmatic hernia across the North American Fetal Therapy Network.
PubMed 文献 · Prenat Diagn · 2021-04-24

该研究评估北美胎儿治疗网络(NAFTNet)中心胎儿医学专家对左侧先天性膈疝(LCDH)超声胃位置分类的评估者间一致性,并与外部专家(ER1)及两位专家(ER1和ER2)间比较。结果显示与ER1的一致性在FETO组为69%,非FETO组为54%;两位专家间仅5/13例(38.5%)一致,总体一致性差。

要点

  • 与外部专家相比,FETO组胃位置评估一致率为69%,非FETO组为54%。
  • 两位专家间胃位置评估一致率仅38.5%(5/13例)。
  • 不一致多表现为相邻一个位置的差异,前位胃一致性最高。

核心结论

  • 在NAFTNet中心及专家评审者中,胎儿膈疝胃位置评估的评估者间一致性差。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用Basta等发表的分类标准,将胃位置分为腹腔内、左胸前、左胸中后、心后四类。
  • 通过计算与ER1的一致比例及专家间kappa统计评估一致性。

主要发现

  • 与ER1相比,FETO组一致率为69%(范围39%-85%,n=19),非FETO组为54%(范围23%-92%,n=29)。
  • 两位专家间胃位置一致率为5/13例(38.5%)。
  • 不一致多与相差一个位置有关,前位胃位置的一致性最高。

临床怎么用

  • 临床中应用胃位置分类评估胎儿膈疝时需注意观察者间差异,建议结合多观察者或专家复核。

局限性

  • 仅评估了左侧先天性膈疝,结论外推需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate inter-rater agreement for sonographic classification of stomach position (as a surrogate for liver herniation) in fetal left congenital diaphragmatic hernia (LCDH) among: (i) fetal medicine specialists from the North American Fetal Therapy Network (NAFTNet) centers within and without the fetal endoscopic tracheal occlusion (FETO) consortium and in comparison to an expert external reviewer (ER1); and (iii) among two expert ERs (ER1 and ER2). METHODS: Forty-eight physicians from 26 NAFTNet centers and 2 ERs were asked to assess 13 sonographic clips of isolated LCDH and classify stomach position as "intra-abdominal," "anterior left chest," "mid to posterior left chest," or "retro-cardiac" based on the classification published by Basta et al.8 Interrater agreement was assessed by determining proportion of stomach position ratings concordant amongst NAFTNet participants and ER1. Agreement for stomach position between ERs was calculated using kappa statistics. RESULTS: Agreement for stomach position was 69% (39%-85%; n = 19) and 54% (23%-92%; n = 29) among FETO and non-FETO NAFTNet participants, respectively, when compared to ER1. Most disagreement in stomach position was related to a discrepancy of one position. ERs were in agreement for stomach position in 5 of 13 cases (38.5%) and inter-rater agreement was highest for "anterior" stomach position. CONCLUSION: Interrater agreement for stomach position assessment in CDH was poor across NAFTNet and indeed amongst expert reviewers.

来源:Prenat Diagn,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Abbasi N, Ryan G, Ruano R, et al. Interrater agreement for sonographic stomach position classification in fetal diaphragmatic hernia across the North American Fetal Therapy Network. Prenat Diagn. 2021. PMID: 33817814. doi:10.1002/pd.5949

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。