产科医生班次完成比例与分娩干预及结局的差异
这项多中心产科队列的二次分析纳入47,262例尝试阴道分娩的单胎头位患者,评估分娩距主治医生换班的时间比例与产科干预及不良结局的关系。结果显示剖宫产、会阴切开、三/四度裂伤及5分钟Apgar<4在各班次时段无显著差异,仅NICU入住率随班次完成比例小幅增加(校正P=.009),但敏感性分析未持续。
要点
- 分娩距主治换班的时间比例与剖宫产、会阴切开、严重裂伤及低Apgar无显著差异。
- NICU入住率随班次完成比例小幅增加(校正P=.009),但12小时班次敏感性分析未持续。
- 未来需直接研究病区文化与医生疲劳,以进一步改善产科质量。
核心结论
- 基于主治医生换班的时间 proximity,产科干预和结局未见临床显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心产科队列的二次分析,纳入所有尝试阴道分娩的头位单胎妊娠患者。
- 可分析样本47,262例(占 eligible 82,851 例的57%),暴露为主治最近一次换班至阴道分娩或决定剖宫产的时间占班次总长度的比例。
- 采用卡方检验及拟合立方样条(必要时)的校正与非校正逻辑回归模型评估结局。
- 敏感性分析限于由完成12小时班次的医生分娩的患者(占22.2%)。
主要发现
- 分娩在班次内均匀分布,50.6%发生在班次前半段。
- 剖宫产、会阴切开、三/四度会阴裂伤及5分钟Apgar<4的频率基于班次完成比例无统计学显著差异。
- 立方样条在校正与非校正逻辑模型中结果不变。
- NICU入住频率随班次完成比例增加而小幅升高(校正P=.009),但12小时班次敏感性分析中未持续。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局包括剖宫产、会阴切开、三/四度会阴裂伤、5分钟Apgar<4及NICU入住。
- NICU入住随班次完成比例增加的小幅升高仅见于主分析(校正P=.009),敏感性分析未重复。
临床怎么用
- 临床无需因主治医生临近换班而担忧剖宫产、会阴切开、严重裂伤或低Apgar风险显著变化。
- NICU入住的小幅增加信号需结合单位文化及医生疲劳进一步研究,暂不作为常规换班策略调整依据。
局限性
- 仅为二次分析,仅57%的 eligible 患者有可分析的班次比例数据。
- NICU入住的小幅增加在12小时班次敏感性分析中未持续,需谨慎解读。
- 未来需在社区医疗环境中进一步验证,并直接研究病区文化与医生疲劳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Understanding and improving obstetrical quality and safety is an important goal of professional societies, and many interventions such as checklists, safety bundles, educational interventions, or other culture changes have been implemented to improve the quality of care provided to obstetrical patients. Although many factors contribute to delivery decisions, a reduced workload has addressed how provider issues such as fatigue or behaviors surrounding impending shift changes may influence the delivery mode and outcomes. OBJECTIVE: The objective was to assess whether intrapartum obstetrical interventions and adverse outcomes differ based on the temporal proximity of the delivery to the attending's shift change. STUDY DESIGN: This was a secondary analysis from a multicenter obstetrical cohort in which all patients with cephalic, singleton gestations who attempted vaginal birth were eligible for inclusion. The primary exposure used to quantify the relationship between the proximity of the provider to their shift change and a delivery intervention was the ratio of time from the most recent attending shift change to vaginal delivery or decision for cesarean delivery to the total length of the shift. Ratios were used to represent the proportion of time completed in the shift by normalizing for varying shift lengths. A sensitivity analysis restricted to patients who were delivered by physicians working 12-hour shifts was performed. Outcomes chosen included cesarean delivery, episiotomy, third- or fourth-degree perineal laceration, 5-minute Apgar score of <4, and neonatal intensive care unit admission. Chi-squared tests were used to evaluate outcomes based on the proportion of the attending's shift completed. Adjusted and unadjusted logistic models fitting a cubic spline (when indicated) were used to determine whether the frequency of outcomes throughout the shift occurred in a statistically significant, nonlinear pattern RESULTS: Of the 82,851 patients eligible for inclusion, 47,262 (57%) had ratio data available and constituted the analyzable sample. Deliveries were evenly distributed throughout shifts, with 50.6% taking place in the first half of shifts. There were no statistically significant differences in the frequency of cesarean delivery, episiotomy, third- or fourth-degree perineal lacerations, or 5-minute Apgar scores of <4 based on the proportion of the shift completed. The findings were unchanged when evaluated with a cubic spline in unadjusted and adjusted logistic models. Sensitivity analyses performed on the 22.2% of patients who were delivered by a physician completing a 12-hour shift showed similar findings. There was a small increase in the frequency of neonatal intensive care unit admissions with a greater proportion of the shift completed (adjusted P=.009), but the findings did not persist in the sensitivity analysis. CONCLUSION: Clinically significant differences in obstetrical interventions and outcomes do not seem to exist based on the temporal proximity to the attending physician's shift change. Future work should attempt to directly study unit culture and provider fatigue to further investigate opportunities to improve obstetrical quality of care, and additional studies are needed to corroborate these findings in community settings.
引用
- Yee LM, McGee P, Bailit JL, et al. Differences in obstetrical care and outcomes associated with the proportion of the obstetrician's shift completed. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 33812810. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2021.03.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。