文献速递母胎医学

新冠疫情期间母胎医学专科主任对纯虚拟面试的体验调查

Maternal-fetal medicine program director experience of exclusive virtual interviewing during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM · 2021-02-27

该研究通过在线调查评估母胎医学专科主任对2020年纯虚拟面试的看法,89名主任中71人(80%)回复。所有回复者均完成100%虚拟面试,近半数面试了更多候选人,所有主任认为虚拟体验符合或超出预期,但多数认为展示项目和评估候选人匹配度不如面对面。

要点

  • 80%的专科主任回复,均完成100%虚拟面试。
  • 49%的主任面试了更多候选人,平均每职位增加5.8人。
  • 所有主任认为虚拟体验符合或超出预期,但多数认为展示项目和评估匹配度不如面对面。

核心结论

  • 多数专科主任认为虚拟面试体验超出预期,但多数认为在虚拟平台上展示项目和评估候选人匹配度不如面对面。
  • 多数专科主任对未来至少部分采用虚拟面试感兴趣。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面在线调查,通过母胎医学学会分发,在面试季结束后、2020年10月14日匹配结果前进行。
  • 89名专科主任中71人(80%)回复,数据匿名收集。

主要发现

  • 所有回复者完成2020年面试100%虚拟。
  • 68名主任中33人(49%)面试了更多候选人,平均每职位增加5.8人(标准差±3.8)。
  • 71名主任中35人(49%)报告技术困难无负面影响,34人(48%)报告影响极小。
  • 71名主任中46人(65%)认为虚拟平台展示项目全面准确性不如面对面。
  • 71名主任中44人(62%)认为评估候选人匹配度不如面对面。

关键数值与推荐

  • 多数项目面试结构为半天(4小时)或更短。
  • 71个项目中31个(44%)举办了虚拟社交活动,通常由现任研究员主持。
  • 假设未来无公共卫生担忧,23/71(32%)偏好纯面对面,24/71(34%)偏好纯虚拟,24/71(34%)偏好混合。

临床怎么用

  • 虚拟面试可作为未来面试的组成部分,但需改进以优化展示项目和评估候选人的效果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic necessitated an abrupt transition to exclusive virtual interviewing for maternal-fetal medicine fellowship programs. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess the maternal-fetal medicine fellowship program directors' approaches to exclusive virtual interviews and to obtain program director feedback on the virtual interview experience to guide future interview cycles. STUDY DESIGN: A novel cross-sectional online survey was distributed through the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine to program directors after the completion of the interview season, but before the results of the National Resident Matching Program on October 14, 2020. Survey data were collected anonymously and managed using secure Research Electronic Data Capture electronic data capture tools. RESULTS: Overall 71 of 89 program directors (80%) responded. All respondents completed their 2020 interviews 100% virtually. Nearly half of program directors (33 of 68, 49%) interviewed more candidates in 2020 than in 2019. Of those who interviewed more candidates in 2020, the mean number of additional candidates per fellowship position was 5.8 (standard deviation, ±3.8). Almost all program directors reported no (35 of 71, 49%) or minimal (34 of 71, 48%) negative impact of technical difficulties on their virtual interview processes. Most programs structured their interview to a half day (4 hours) or less for the candidates. Many programs were able to adapt their supplemental interview materials and events for the candidates into a virtual format, including a virtual social event hosted by 31 of 71 programs (44%). The virtual social event was most commonly casual and led by current fellows. Ultimately, all program directors reported that the virtual interview experience was as expected or better than expected. However, most program directors felt less able to provide candidates with a comprehensive and accurate representation of their program on a virtual platform compared with their previous in-person experiences (46 of 71 [65%] reported minimally, moderately, or significantly less than in-person). In addition, most program directors felt their ability to get to know candidates and assess their "fit" with the program was less than previous in-person years (44 of 71 [62%] reported minimally, moderately, or significantly less than in-person). In a hypothetical future year without any public health concerns, there were 23 of 71 respondents (32%) who prefer exclusive in-person interviews, 24 of 71 (34%) who prefer exclusive virtual interviews, and 24 of 71 (34%) who prefer a hybrid of virtual and in-person interviews. CONCLUSION: The virtual interview experience was better than expected for most program directors. However, most program directors felt less able to present their programs and assess the candidates on a virtual platform compared with previous in-person experiences. Despite this, most program directors are interested in at least a component of virtual interviewing in future years. Future efforts are needed to refine the virtual interview process to optimize the experience for program directors and candidates.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rhoades JS, Ramsey PS, Metz TD, et al. Maternal-fetal medicine program director experience of exclusive virtual interviewing during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2021. PMID: 33652158. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2021.100344

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。