剖宫产子宫张力0至10评分的评分者间信度与一致性
结果显示单人评分信度良好、双人平均信度优秀,Bland-Altman分析提示两个时间点一致性良好,且量表对宫内张力变化有反应性,并初步获得最小临床重要差异估计。
要点
- 0至10子宫张力评分在剖宫产中单人信度良好、双人平均信度优秀。
- 3分钟与10分钟评分者间一致性均良好,可作为标准化报告工具。
- 量表对产后3至10分钟张力变化有反应性,并获初步最小临床重要差异估计。
核心结论
- 0至10数字评分用于剖宫产子宫张力评估,单人及双人评分信度分别为良好与优秀,评分者间一致性良好。
- 该量表能反映同一产妇宫内张力变化,并初步获得最小临床重要差异估计。
- 该量表可能成为未来研究报告剖宫产中宫缩程度的可靠标准化工具。
研究设计与样本
- 共收集62名不同产科医生提供的3分钟82对、10分钟84对评分,0代表无张力、10代表张力极佳。
- 采用组内相关系数与Bland-Altman分析评估信度与一致性,标准化反应均数与测量标准误评估反应性和最小临床重要差异。
主要发现
- 评分者1与评分者2的评分差值均值±标准差在3分钟为0.4±1.4,10分钟为0.1±1.1。
- 单人评分ICC(1,1)在3分钟为0.67(95%CI 0.53-0.77)、10分钟为0.61(95%CI 0.46-0.73)。
- 双人平均ICC(1,2)在3分钟为0.80(95%CI 0.71-0.87)、10分钟为0.76(95%CI 0.63-0.84)。
- Bland-Altman 95%一致性界限在3分钟为-2.4(95%CI -3.0至-1.9)至3.1(95%CI 2.6-3.7),10分钟为-2.1(95%CI -2.5至-1.7)至2.4(95%CI 2.0-2.8)。
- 3至10分钟标准化反应均数为1.1(n=81),测量标准误3分钟为1.0(95%CI 0.9-1.1)、10分钟为0.8(95%CI 0.7-0.9)。
关键数值与推荐
- 0至10数字评分中0代表无张力、10代表张力极佳,由产科医生触诊子宫后独立盲法评分。
- 单人评分ICC(1,1)3分钟0.67、10分钟0.61;双人平均ICC(1,2)3分钟0.80、10分钟0.76。
- 3分钟与10分钟Bland-Altman一致性界限分别约为-2.4至3.1与-2.1至2.4,提示一致性良好。
临床怎么用
- 剖宫产术中可用0至10数字评分标准化记录子宫张力,便于团队沟通与后续研究比较。
- 单人评分信度良好但非完美,双人平均可提高信度,重要临床决策可参考重复或双人评估。
- 量表对产后短时间内张力变化有反应性,可用于监测宫缩剂效果。
局限性
- 最小临床重要差异仅为初步估计,尚需进一步验证。
- 评分依赖触诊,未报告对临床结局(如产后出血)的预测价值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Postpartum hemorrhage is a leading source of maternal morbidity and mortality worldwide with uterine atony identified as the underlying cause in up to 80% of cases. Several measures have been utilized to report uterine tone. The most commonly reported measure is a 0 to 10 numeric rating scale, but this scale has not been tested for reliability or agreement between different raters. OBJECTIVE: The primary purpose of this study was to evaluate the interrater reliability and agreement of the 0 to 10 visual numeric rating scale of uterine tone during cesarean delivery. A secondary purpose was to obtain estimates of scale responsiveness and minimal clinically important difference. STUDY DESIGN: Between August and November of 2018, obstetricians used a 0 to 10 numeric rating score to independently rate uterine tone at 3 and 10 minutes after cesarean delivery by palpation of the uterus. Of note, "0" represented "no tone" and "10" represented excellent tone. Each obstetrician independently and blinded to the other's score pointed to a numeric rating scale held by the anesthesiologist through a clear sterile drape. Intraclass correlation coefficients and Bland-Altman analysis were used to assess interrater reliability and agreement, respectively. Standardized response mean and standard error of measurement were used to obtain estimates of responsiveness and minimal clinically important difference, respectively. RESULTS: A total of 82 and 84 pairs of scores were collected at 3 and 10 minutes, respectively, from pairs of 62 unique obstetricians. The mean±standard deviation difference in scores between rater 1 and rater 2 was 0.4±1.4 at 3 minutes and 0.1±1.1 at 10 minutes. Intraclass correlation coefficients for a future single rater (intraclass correlation coefficient [1, 1]) at 3 and 10 minutes were 0.67 (95% confidence interval, 0.53-0.77) and 0.61 (95% confidence interval, 0.46-0.73), and for the average between 2 future raters (intraclass correlation coefficient [1, 2]), they were 0.80 (95% confidence interval, 0.71-0.87) and 0.76 (95% confidence interval, 0.63-0.84), indicating good and excellent reliability, respectively. Bland-Altman analysis estimated 95% limit of agreement between raters of -2.4 (95% confidence interval, -3.0 to -1.9) to 3.1 (95% confidence interval, 2.6-3.7) at 3 minutes and -2.1 (95% confidence interval, -2.5 to -1.7) to 2.4 (95% confidence interval, 2.0-2.8) at 10 minutes, consistent with good interrater agreement at both time points. The standardized response mean from 3 to 10 minutes after delivery was 1.1 (n=81). Standard error of measurement was 1.0 (95% confidence interval, 0.9-1.1) at 3 minutes and 0.8 (95% confidence interval, 0.7-0.9) at 10 minutes. CONCLUSION: The 0 to 10 numeric rating scale for uterine tone demonstrated good to excellent interrater reliability with 1 and 2 raters, respectively, and good interrater agreement. The scale was responsive to within-parturient change in tone, and preliminary estimates of the minimal clinically important difference were obtained. The 0 to 10 numeric rating scale for uterine tone may be a reliable, standardized tool for future research in reporting degree of uterotonic contraction during cesarean delivery.
引用
- Cole NM, Abushoshah I, Fields KG, et al. The interrater reliability and agreement of a 0 to 10 uterine tone score in cesarean delivery. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2021. PMID: 33652161. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2021.100342
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。