文献速递母胎医学产科

虚拟面试对母胎医学专科 Fellowship 匹配申请者方式与观点的影响

Effect of virtual interviewing on applicant approach to and perspective of the Maternal-Fetal Medicine Subspecialty Fellowship Match.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM · 2021-02-03

本研究通过问卷调查比较2020年虚拟面试周期与2017-2019年现场面试周期的母胎医学Fellowship申请者。共140份完整问卷,虚拟申请者46人,现场申请者94人。虚拟申请者申请更多项目、更少取消面试、花费更低,且多数认为体验优于或符合预期。

要点

  • 虚拟申请者中近75%申请至少25个Fellowship项目,现场申请者不足50%。
  • 虚拟申请者取消已安排面试的比例显著更低(39.1% vs 72.3%,P<.001)。
  • 近三分之二虚拟申请者花费低于1000美元,现场申请者近三分之二花费超过5000美元。

核心结论

  • 虚拟面试受到申请者好评,但显著改变了其申请策略。
  • 研究识别的虚拟与现场申请者倾向差异应指导下一周期申请。

研究设计与样本

  • 由母胎医学学会Fellowship事务委员会设计问卷调查。
  • 通过学会Listserv招募,2020年虚拟面试结束后、匹配日前完成。
  • 共140份完整问卷:虚拟申请者46人,现场申请者94人(2017年n=28,2018年n=33,2019年n=33)。

主要发现

  • 两组申请项目数量的总体分布不同(P=.02)。
  • 虚拟申请者取消面试比例显著低于现场申请者(39.1% vs 72.3%,P<.001)。
  • 两组在Fellowship申请过程总花费和面试离岗总天数上差异均有统计学意义(均P<.001)。
  • 近三分之二虚拟申请者花费低于1000美元,近三分之二现场申请者花费超过5000美元。
  • 近80%虚拟申请者认为体验优于或略优于预期,无人认为略差或更差。

关键数值与推荐

  • 虚拟申请者中近75%申请至少25个项目,现场申请者不足50%。
  • 虚拟申请者取消面试:18/46(39.1%);现场申请者:68/94(72.3%);P<.001。
  • 虚拟申请者花费低于1000美元者近三分之二;现场申请者花费超过5000美元者近三分之二。
  • 60.9%虚拟申请者认为项目代表性可比,63.0%认为能有效评估匹配度。
  • 仅20%虚拟申请者建议未来恢复完全现场面试。

临床怎么用

  • 虚拟面试可降低申请者经济负担和离岗时间,但可能增加申请项目数量。
  • 虚拟面试中申请者较少取消面试,项目方需调整面试安排策略。
  • 多数申请者认为虚拟面试可有效评估匹配度,可继续采用或优化虚拟形式。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The 2020 application cycle for the Maternal-Fetal Medicine Specialty Fellowship Match was the first to be exclusively virtual. OBJECTIVE: Our study was designed to compare approaches and perspectives of the MFM fellowship candidates who applied with virtual interviews with those of the current Maternal-Fetal Medicine fellows, who applied with in-person interviews in 2017, 2018, or 2019. STUDY DESIGN: A survey was developed by the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine Fellowship Affairs Committee to ascertain applicant approaches to and perspectives of the Maternal-Fetal Medicine Fellowship Match and was disseminated after 2020 Maternal-Fetal Medicine interviews ended and completed before Fellowship Match Day. Participants were contacted by means of active Listservs maintained by the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine. Current fellows were instructed to complete the survey using their experiences on the application cycle in which they successfully matched. Those who elected to participate entered their survey responses through the electronic link; answers were recorded in a secure Research Electronic Data Capture database. Outcomes were compared between those who applied during the virtual 2020 Maternal-Fetal Medicine interview cycle and those that applied during the in-person interview cycles in 2017, 2018, or 2019. RESULTS: Of the 140 completed surveys, 46 people participated in the 2020 Maternal-Fetal Medicine Match and were categorized as "virtual applicants," whereas the remaining 94 people participated in the 2017 (n=28), 2018 (n=33), or 2019 (n=33) Maternal-Fetal Medicine Match and were categorized as "in-person applicants." The overall distribution of number of programs to which each applicant applied differed between groups (P=.02); for example, nearly 75% of virtual applicants applied to at least 25 fellowship programs, compared with less than 50% of in-person applicants. Although the number of interviews received was similar between virtual and in-person applicants, virtual applicants were significantly less likely to cancel scheduled interviews (n=18 [39.1%] vs n=68 [72.3%]; P<.001). There were also differences between virtual and in-person applicants in terms of overall cost of the fellowship intervention process and total days away from work for interviewing (P<.001 for both). In particular, nearly two-thirds of virtual applicants reported spending less than $1000 in the Maternal-Fetal Medicine fellowship application process, compared with the nearly two-thirds of in-person applicants who reported spending more than $5000. Among the 46 virtual applicants, nearly 80% reported the experience was better or slightly better than expected, and none reported the experience was slightly worse or worse than expected. Nearly two-thirds of the virtual applicants reported that, compared with their in-person residency interviews, they received a comparable representation of Maternal-Fetal Medicine fellowship programs and could effectively assess their "fit" during interviews (60.9% and 63.0%, respectively). Only 20% of virtual Maternal-Fetal Medicine applicants would recommend returning to exclusive in-person interviews should that be possible in future Maternal-Fetal Medicine matches. CONCLUSION: Virtual Maternal-Fetal Medicine fellowship interviewing was viewed favorably by applicants but corresponded with significant changes to their application approaches. The differences between virtual and in-person fellowship applicant tendencies identified in this study should inform next year's application cycle for Maternal-Fetal Medicine and possibly other obstetrics and gynecology subspecialty fellowships.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lewkowitz AK, Ramsey PS, Burrell D, et al. Effect of virtual interviewing on applicant approach to and perspective of the Maternal-Fetal Medicine Subspecialty Fellowship Match. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2021. PMID: 33548511. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2021.100326

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。