新型装置与手工检查测量产程中宫颈扩张的随机对照试验
该随机对照试验将42名临产妇女随机分至新型装置DilaCheck组或标准手工检查组,比较不同检查者测量宫颈扩张的一致性。结果显示装置组检查者间≤1 cm一致率61.9%,低于手工组的95.2%(P=.008),未改善一致性。
要点
- 新型装置DilaCheck未提高检查者间宫颈扩张测量一致性,反而降低。
- 手工检查检查者间≤1 cm一致率为95.2%,装置组为61.9%。
- 临床管理应基于>1 cm的临床差异,因约90%检查在1 cm内一致。
核心结论
- 新型装置DilaCheck未改善临产妇女宫颈扩张的检查者间一致性,反而降低了一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,纳入42名临产妇女,随机分至DilaCheck装置组(21例)或标准手工检查组(21例),每组由两名培训过的检查者分别测量宫颈扩张。
主要发现
- 装置组两次检查完全一致率为19%,手工组为42.9%(P=.10)。
- 检查者间≤1 cm一致率装置组为61.9%,手工组为95.2%(P=.008)。
- 检查者间≤2 cm一致率装置组为90.5%,手工组为100%(P=.15)。
- 多数检查者间不一致出现在宫颈扩张5至7 cm时。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为检查者间宫颈扩张测量≤1 cm的一致率。
- 手工检查检查者间完全一致率通常最好不超过50%。
临床怎么用
- 临床管理应基于宫颈扩张的临床差异>1 cm,因为一般90%的检查在1 cm内一致。
- 标准手工检查的检查者间完全一致率较差,需关注测量差异。
局限性
- 样本量较小,共42名临产妇女。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cervical dilation and changes in cervical dilation inform the management of labor, including decisions to admit a patient to the hospital, augment labor, or perform a cesarean delivery. Practitioners routinely measure cervical dilation subjectively using 2 fingers on manual examination; however, agreement of ≤1 cm between 2 observers has been reported as 60% to 91% previously in laboring women. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the agreement among different providers' examinations using DilaCheck (interexaminer agreement) compared with interexaminer agreement between 2 manual examinations for cervical dilation of women in labor. STUDY DESIGN: Women admitted in labor to a labor and delivery service were randomized to receive 2 cervical examinations from trained providers, using either a novel device (DilaCheck) or the standard manual examination. This randomized controlled trial compares a novel device with the standard method of manual examination for the measurement of cervical dilation. The novel device consisted of a string measuring tape suspended between 2 soft plastic rings worn on the index and middle fingertips. Interobserver agreement, defined as the agreement (exact, ≤1 cm [primary outcome], or ≤2 cm) in the numeric cervical dilation measurement obtained by 2 different examiners, was compared between the 2 groups. RESULTS: A total of 42 women in labor were randomized, 21 to the novel device and 21 to the standard manual examination groups. The 2 device examinations agreed in 19% of cases, whereas manual examinations agreed exactly in 42.9% of cases (P=.10). Interobserver agreement of ≤1 cm was 61.9% vs 95.2%, respectively (P=.008). Interobserver agreement of ≤2 cm was 90.5% vs 100%, respectively (P=.15). Most interobserver disagreement was seen at 5 to 7 cm of cervical dilation. CONCLUSION: A novel device, DilaCheck, intended for a more objective cervical assessment of women in labor did not improve interobserver agreement; in fact, it decreased it. Standard cervical dilation examinations result in poor interexaminer exact agreement, usually at best 50% or less. Clinical management should be based on clinical differences of >1 cm because, in general, 90% of cervical examinations will agree within 1 cm of each other. Given the importance of dilation measurements in the management of labor, continued innovation in this field would benefit women in labor and the providers caring for them; however, the puzzle remains unsolved.
引用
- Martin EL, Firman B, Berghella V, et al. Novel device vs manual examinations for the measurement of cervical dilation in labor: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2021. PMID: 33582306. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2021.100328
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。