引产剖宫产风险计算器实施:临床医生视角的定性评估
本研究对20名临床医生进行半结构化访谈,评估引产剖宫产风险计算器的实施体验。医生总体持积极态度,认为计算器提供客观数据和标准化轨迹,但担忧过度依赖、咨询时间不足及互动尴尬。高年资医生多认为计算器未影响管理,而受训者认为在高风险极端影响决策并建立信任。
要点
- 临床医生对引产剖宫产风险计算器总体持积极态度
- 主要障碍包括咨询时间不足和互动尴尬
- 受训者更认为计算器在高风险极端影响决策
核心结论
- 临床医生对引产剖宫产风险计算器总体持积极态度,并识别了实施促进因素与障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 在完成前瞻性研究后,对研究site的20名受训者和主治临床医生(包括助产士、产科医生和家庭医学医生)进行单次简要半结构化访谈,时间2020年3月1日至6月30日。
主要发现
- 临床医生将计算器描述为提供「客观数据」和「分娩轨迹的标准化快照」。
- concerns raised regarding 「overreliance」 on calculator output.
- 使用障碍包括患者咨询时间和互动中的「尴尬」及感知的患者误解。
- 大多数高年资临床医生(n=8)报告计算器未影响患者管理,而受训临床医生(n=12)更常认为计算器在高剖宫产风险极端影响护理。
- 更多高年资医生对咨询剖宫产风险的影响持「中立」态度,而受训者认为咨询「建立了信任」。
临床怎么用
- 在引产剖宫产风险计算器广泛实施时,应关注促进因素与障碍,优化临床整合。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We previously conducted a prospective cohort study (n=1610) demonstrating that the implementation of a validated calculator to predict likelihood of cesarean delivery during labor induction was associated with reduced maternal morbidity, reduced cesarean delivery rate, and improved birth satisfaction. OBJECTIVE: To optimize future implementation, we used qualitative interviews to understand the clinician perspective on: (1) the cesarean delivery risk calculator implementation and (2) the mechanisms by which the use of the calculator resulted in the observed improved outcomes. STUDY DESIGN: After completion of the prospective study (June 30, 2019), 20 trainees and attending clinicians (including nurse-midwives, obstetrical physicians, and family medicine physicians) at the study site participated in a single, brief semistructured interview from March 1, 2020, to June 30, 2020. Transcriptions were coded using a systematic approach. RESULTS: Overall, clinicians had favorable perspectives regarding the cesarean delivery risk calculator. Clinicians described the calculator as offering "objective data" and a "standardized snapshot of the labor trajectory." Concerns were raised regarding "overreliance" on calculator output. Barriers to use included time for patient counseling and "awkwardness" around the interactions and perceived patient misunderstanding of the calculator result. Although most senior clinicians (n=8) reported that the calculator did not impact patient management, trainee clinicians (n=12) more often felt that the calculator influenced care at the extremes of cesarean delivery risk. Furthermore, more senior clinicians felt "neutral" regarding any impact of counseling patients on cesarean delivery risk compared with trainee clinicians, who felt that the counseling "built [patient-clinician] trust." CONCLUSION: This qualitative evaluation characterized the generally positive clinician perspective around the cesarean delivery risk calculator, while identifying specific facilitators and barriers to implementation. In addition, we elucidated potential mechanisms by which the calculator may have been related to clinician decision making and patient-clinician interactions, leading to reduced maternal morbidity and improved patient birth satisfaction. This information is important as widespread implementation of the cesarean delivery risk calculator begins.
引用
- Hamm RF, Levine LD, Nelson MN, et al. Implementation of a calculator to predict cesarean delivery during labor induction: a qualitative evaluation of the clinician perspective. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2021. PMID: 33493705. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2021.100321
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。