产科文献中的撤稿文章:从过去吸取教训以改变未来
该回顾性研究通过检索PubMed和Retraction Watch数据库,识别截至2019年12月31日产科与母胎医学文献中的撤稿文章,共确认122篇,中位撤稿时间1年,主要原因包括文章重复、剽窃和结果或方法错误等学术不端行为。
要点
- 产科与母胎医学文献中共识别122篇撤稿文章,占妇产科撤稿文章的23.5%。
- 撤稿首要原因为内容相关问题(71.3%),包括文章重复、剽窃和结果或方法错误。
- 撤稿文章中位被引3次,中位期刊影响因子2.2,部分发表于高影响因子期刊。
核心结论
- 产科与母胎医学文献中撤稿文章数量在增加,且多与科学不端行为相关,包括文章重复和剽窃。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性综述,检索PubMed和Retraction Watch数据库,纳入索引至2019年12月31日的产科与母胎医学撤稿文章。
- 从Retraction Watch的519篇妇产科文章中筛选出122篇(23.5%)产科与母胎医学专篇,其中39篇(32.0%)也见于PubMed。
主要发现
- 中位撤稿时间为1年(范围0-17年),每篇文章中位被引3次(范围0-145)。
- 中位期刊影响因子为2.2(范围0.1-27.6),第一作者和资深作者中位H指数分别为6.0和13.5。
- 多数为原创研究(n=80;65.6%),包括回顾性研究(n=11;9.0%)、病例报告(n=19;15.6%)、前瞻性研究(n=18;14.8%)、随机对照试验(n=11;9%)、基础科学(n=18;14.8%)和系统综述或meta分析(n=3;2.5%)。
- 32篇(26.2%)发表于影响因子≥4的期刊,21篇(17.2%)发表于影响因子排名前10的妇产科期刊。
- 撤稿原因:内容相关问题87篇(71.3%),其中文章重复26篇(21.3%)、剽窃23篇(18.9%)、结果或方法错误20篇(16.4%);作者不端行为12篇(9.8%)、结果不可重复11篇(9.0%)、伪造8篇(6.6%)。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生在引用产科与母胎医学文献时,应关注撤稿状态及期刊的撤稿声明。
- 期刊和医疗机构需加强预防和检测,避免无效研究结果在医学文献中持续传播。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The publication of invalid scientific findings may have profound implications on medical practice. As the incidence of article retractions has increased over the last 2 decades, organizations have formed, including Retraction Watch, to improve the transparency of scientific publishing. At present, the incidence of article retraction in the obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine literature is unclear. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to determine the number of retracted articles within the obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine literature from the PubMed and Retraction Watch databases and examine reasons for retraction. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review of the PubMed and Retraction Watch databases was performed to identify retracted articles in the obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine literature from indexation through December 31, 2019. The primary outcome was defined as the number of identified articles and reason for retraction. Within PubMed, articles were identified using a medical subheading search for articles categorized as withdrawn or retracted. In addition, the Retraction Watch database was queried and nonobstetrical articles were excluded. The reason for retraction was classified according to the categories listed in Retraction Watch. The subject matter was classified on the basis of the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine criteria. Data were collected from retracted articles for author name, country, journal name and impact factor, year of publication and retraction, study type, and response of the publishing journal. Descriptive statistics were performed. RESULTS: Of the 519 obstetrics and gynecology articles in Retraction Watch, 122 (23.5%) were specific to the obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine specialties. In addition, 39 (32.0%) were identified from PubMed, all of which were included in Retraction Watch. There was a median time to retraction of 1 (range, 0-17) year, with a median of 3 citations per article (range, 0-145). In addition, the median journal impact factor was 2.2 (range, 0.1-27.6), with median first and senior author Hirsch index values of 6.0 and 13.5, respectively. Most articles were original research (n=80; 65.6%), specifically retrospective studies (n=11; 9.0%), case reports (n=19; 15.6%), prospective studies (n=18; 14.8%), randomized controlled trials (n=11; 9%), basic science (n=18; 14.8%), and systematic review or meta-analysis (n=3; 2.5%). Of eligible articles, 32 (26.2%) were published in journals with an impact factor ≥4, and 21 articles (17.2%) were published in the top 10 leading impact factor obstetrics and gynecology journals. Most retractions were for content-related issues (n=87; 71.3%), including 21.3% (n=26) for article duplication, 18.9% (n=23) for plagiarism, and 16.4% (n=20) for errors in results or methods. Additional reasons included author misconduct (n=12; 9.8%), nonreproducible results (n=11; 9.0%), and falsification (n=8; 6.6%). The most common journal response was an issued statement of retraction (n=82; 67.2%). Lack of retraction notice and limited to no information provided by the publishing journal occurred in 19 retracted articles (15.6%). CONCLUSION: In the obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine literature, retraction of scientific articles is increasing and is most often related to scientific misconduct, including article duplication and plagiarism. Improved prevention and detection are warranted by journals and healthcare institutions to ensure that invalid findings are not perpetuated in the medical literature, thereby avoiding adverse consequences for maternal and perinatal care.
引用
- Bennett C, Chambers LM, Al-Hafez L, et al. Retracted articles in the obstetrics literature: lessons from the past to change the future. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020. PMID: 33345918. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100201
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。