非产科手术中的胎儿心率监测:证据的系统综述
本系统综述检索1966年至2019年5月的文献,仅纳入病例报告和病例系列,共74例孕妇在非产科手术中接受术中胎儿心率监测。异常胎心曲线见于29例,其中胎心过缓17例,几乎均发生于涉及主动脉阻断和体外循环的母亲心脏手术;仅3例因胎心异常同期早产分娩。结论认为术中胎心监测证据级别低,麻醉和手术相关的胎心变化不应成为医源性早产剖宫产的指征。
要点
- 非产科手术术中胎心监测证据仅来自病例报告和病例系列,共74例。
- 母亲心脏手术涉及体外循环时胎心过缓常见,判读具有挑战性。
- 胎心异常不构成医源性早产剖宫产的充分理由,需结合临床综合判断。
核心结论
- 术中胎儿监测的证据基于病例报告和病例系列,母亲心脏手术涉及体外循环常导致胎心过缓且判读困难。
- 产科医生应认识到麻醉和手术相关的胎心模式变化,不应据此进行医源性早产剖宫产。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、Cochrane和CENTRAL等数据库,手工检索指南、会议论文集和文献综述,在线检索涵盖1966年至2019年5月发表的文献。
- 仅纳入病例报告和病例系列,共74例孕妇在非产科手术中接受术中胎心监测,手术类型包括母亲普通外科41例、心血管外科13例、神经外科/骨科20例。
- 母亲手术时中位孕周为30周(范围22-36周)。
主要发现
- 41例未报告胎心监测结果,29例观察到异常胎心曲线,包括变异减少13例和胎心过缓17例。
- 除3例胎心过缓外,其余胎心过缓均发生于涉及主动脉阻断和体外循环的母亲心脏手术。
- 1例因手术气腹无法进行胎心监测,1例胎心过速与母亲发热相关,3例胎心监测被认为稳定或正常。
- 3例早产儿在普通外科手术同期分娩,孕周分别为30、33和34周,其中2例因胎心过缓、1例因持续性变异减少。
临床怎么用
- 产科医生应了解麻醉和手术可导致胎心模式变化,避免仅凭术中胎心异常行医源性早产剖宫产。
- 对涉及体外循环的母亲心脏手术,胎心过缓常见,判读需结合手术和麻醉背景。
局限性
- 证据仅基于病例报告和病例系列,存在发表偏倚和选择偏倚,无法推断因果关系。
- 41例未报告胎心监测结果,数据不完整,影响结果解释。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Concern for fetal well-being during maternal nonobstetric surgery may result in obstetricians and other maternity care providers being asked to perform intraoperative fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring. We systematically reviewed the evidence regarding the use of FHR monitoring during nonobstetric surgery after potential fetal viability (>22 weeks gestational age), and examined the FHR patterns and outcomes reported. DATA SOURCES: A systematic review of the evidence was performed. Sources included databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, and CENTRAL), hand searching, guidelines, conference proceedings, and literature reviews. Online searching was performed to include literature published from 1966 to May 2019. STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: All studies reviewing care of pregnant women undergoing nonobstetric surgery where FHR monitoring was performed intraoperatively. Data were extracted from appropriate full-text articles using a data abstraction form. STUDY APPRAISAL AND SYNTHESIS: Case reports and case series only were identified. A total of 74 cases were reviewed, encompassing maternal general surgery (n = 41, cardiovascular surgery (n = 13) and neurosurgery/orthopedics (n = 20). Median gestational age at time of maternal surgery was 30 weeks (range, 22-36 weeks). In 41 cases, findings of FHR monitoring were not reported. Abnormal tracings were observed in 29 cases, as either reduced variability (n = 13) or fetal bradycardia (n = 17). All but 3 bradycardias reported occurred during maternal cardiac surgery involving aortic clamping and cardiopulmonary bypass. In 1 case, FHR monitoring was not possible because of a surgical pneumoperitoneum; there was 1 fetal tachycardia associated with maternal pyrexia, and three cases in which FHR monitoring was deemed stable or normal. Three preterm infants were delivered simultaneously at the time of general surgery as a result of FHR abnormalities (at 30, 33, and 34 weeks respectively), 2 as a result of fetal bradycardia and 1 because of protracted reduced variablity. CONCLUSION: The evidence for intraoperative fetal monitoring is based on case reports and cases series. Maternal cardiac surgery involving cardiopulmonary bypass commonly results in fetal bradycardia, which may be challenging to interpret. Obstetricians should be aware of FHR pattern changes in response to anesthesia and surgery that do not justify iatrogenic preterm cesarean delivery.
引用
- Higgins MF, Pollard L, McGuinness SK, et al. Fetal heart rate monitoring in nonobstetric surgery: a systematic review of the evidence. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019. PMID: 33345838. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。