新型Odon装置用于指征性阴道助产结局的可行性研究
该非随机单臂可行性研究在单中心纳入40名需阴道助产的孕妇,使用Odon装置协助分娩。装置成功助产19/40例(48%),52.5%需额外助产,无严重母婴不良事件,4例(10%)因制造缺陷无效。招募可行性良好,77.6%符合条件的女性同意参与。
要点
- Odon装置成功助产率为48%(19/40),低于已报道的产钳和吸引器成功率。
- 52.5%的病例需额外助产,其中45%用非旋转产钳,5%需紧急剖宫产。
- 无严重母婴不良事件或严重装置不良效应,但4例(10%)因制造缺陷无效。
核心结论
- Odon装置用于标准临床指征的阴道助产成功率为48%,无严重母婴安全担忧,但研究样本量小,需进一步可行性研究优化装置、技术和临床指征。
研究设计与样本
- 非随机单臂介入性可行性研究,在英国布里斯托尔Southmead医院单中心开展,共40名需助产的孕妇使用Odon装置。
主要发现
- 装置成功助产19/40例(48%),21例(52.5%)需额外助产:18例(45%)用非旋转产钳,1例(3%)用旋转产钳,2例(5%)行紧急剖宫产。
- 无与装置相关的严重母婴不良事件或严重装置不良效应,4例(10%)因制造缺陷无效。
- 39/40例(98%)女性报告高分娩感知评分,所有操作者均能按预期使用装置。
关键数值与推荐
- 首要临床结局为Odon装置成功助产比例,首要可行性结局为符合条件女性中同意参与的比例。
- 2018年10月至2019年1月间,384名符合条件女性中298名(77.6%)同意参与,其中40名接受干预。
临床怎么用
- Odon装置可作为阴道助产的潜在替代选择,但当前成功率低于产钳和吸引器,且存在制造缺陷风险,暂不宜常规推广。
局限性
- 研究为非随机单臂设计,样本量小(40例),成功率低于产钳和吸引器已报道的成功率,且4例装置因制造缺陷无效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: No new method of assisting vaginal birth has been introduced into clinical practice since the development of the vacuum extractor in the 1950s. The Odon Device is a new device that employs a circumferential air cuff over the fetal head to assist birth. In this study, the Odon Device has been used to assist vaginal birth for standard clinical indications. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to investigate the clinical impact, safety, and acceptability of the Odon Device to women, their babies, and clinicians and to assess the feasibility of recruiting women to an interventional intrapartum research study. STUDY DESIGN: This is a nonrandomized, single-arm interventional feasibility study of the Odon Device for operative vaginal birth undertaken in a single maternity unit: Southmead Hospital, Bristol, United Kingdom. The Odon Device was used to assist birth in 40 women who required the birth to be assisted for suspected fetal compromise and/or prolonged second stage of labor. The primary clinical outcome was the proportion of births successfully assisted with the Odon Device, and the primary feasibility outcome was the proportion of eligible women who were approached and who agreed to participate. Neonatal outcome data were reviewed at day 28, and maternal outcomes were investigated up to day 90. RESULTS: Between October 2018 and January 2019, 298 of 384 approached, eligible women (77.6%) consented to participate. Of these women, 40 received the intervention-the use of the Odon Device. Birth was assisted in all cephalic (occiput anterior, occiput transverse, and occiput posterior) fetal positions, at all stations at or below the ischial spine and with or without regional analgesia. The Odon Device was effective in 19 of 40 cases (48%). Of the 40 births, 21 (52.5%) required additional assistance: 18 of 40 births (45%) were completed using nonrotational forceps, 1 of 40 births (3%) required rotational forceps, and 2 of 40 births (5%) required an emergency cesarean delivery. There was no serious maternal or neonatal adverse event related to the use of the device, and there was no serious adverse device effect. There were 4 devices (10%) that were ineffective because of a manufacturing fault. Furthermore, 39 of 40 women (98%) reported a high birth perception score. All practitioners were able to use the device as intended, although some steps in using the device were reported to be easier to perform (setup and deflation of air chamber) than others (application of the device and withdrawal of the applicator). CONCLUSION: Recruitment to an interventional study of a new device for operative vaginal birth was feasible; 78% of eligible women were willing to participate, often expressing an aspiration for an alternative to forceps and vacuum. The success rate of the Odon Device was lower than reported success rates of vacuum and forceps; however, in this study, the device had been used to assist birth for standard clinical indications. There was no significant maternal or neonatal safety concern associated with the use of the device, although the number of births studied was small. Further feasibility study to establish iterative changes to the device, technique, and clinical indications is necessary.
引用
- Hotton EJ, Lenguerrand E, Alvarez M, et al. Outcomes of the novel Odon Device in indicated operative vaginal birth. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 33316274. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2020.12.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。