医院间引产产妇剖宫产率的差异
本研究基于加州2016-2017年出生证明与住院记录关联数据,评估行政数据识别引产的准确性,并分析低危初产妇引产后剖宫产率的医院间差异。结果显示,联合诊断编码与出生证明识别引产准确率最高(92.9%,95%CI 92.7-93.2),238家医院99,441例足月单胎头位引产初产妇的中位剖宫产率为32.2%(范围18.5-84.6%),风险调整及排除引产指征后差异未缩小。
要点
- 联合出院诊断编码与出生证明数据识别引产准确率最高,达92.9%。
- 足月单胎头位引产初产妇中位剖宫产率32.2%,医院间范围18.5-84.6%。
- 风险调整及排除引产指征后,医院间剖宫产率差异未缩小。
核心结论
- 引产后剖宫产率在医院间存在大幅差异,提示临床管理对引产成功有重要影响。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,分析加州2016-2017年活产数据,出生证明与产妇出院记录关联。
- 8家医院对46,916例分娩进行病历审查,评估引产识别准确性。
- 分析238家分娩医院中99,441例足月单胎头位引产初产妇的剖宫产率。
主要发现
- 联合出院诊断编码与出生证明数据识别引产准确率最高(92.9%,95%CI 92.7-93.2)。
- 足月单胎头位引产初产妇中位剖宫产率为32.2%,范围18.5-84.6%。
- 风险调整及排除所有引产指征后,医院间差异未缩小。
- 地理区域、新生儿重症监护级别及同一机构内医生间亦存在类似大幅差异。
- 引产后剖宫产率与非引产剖宫产率(R<0.08)及引产率(R<0.12)仅呈极弱关联。
临床怎么用
- 临床管理可能是提高引产成功率、降低剖宫产率的关键可干预因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the use of administrative data for identification of labor induction and to estimate the variation in cesarean delivery rates among low-risk women who underwent labor induction. METHODS: A cross-sectional study was performed examining live births in California hospitals during 2016 and 2017 using birth certificate data linked with maternal patient discharge records. Initially, eight hospitals performed medical record reviews by using reVITALize definitions on 46,916 deliveries to assess the validity of induction identification by birth certificate or discharge diagnosis records or both. Hospital-level variation in cesarean delivery rates was then assessed among all California hospitals for women with low-obstetric-risk first births before and after further risk adjustment and after the exclusion of potential medical and obstetric indications for induction. Variation in physician-level cesarean delivery rates after induction at four large hospitals also was examined. The relationships between cesarean delivery rates among women with induced labors compared with noninduced labors and with the hospital rate of induction also were explored. RESULTS: Identifying induction by a combination of discharge diagnosis codes and birth certificate data had the highest accuracy (92.9%, 95% CI 92.7-93.2). Among 917,225 births at 238 birthing hospitals, there were 99,441 nulliparous women with term, singleton, vertex pregnancies who were induced. The median cesarean delivery rate after labor induction for nulliparous women with term, singleton, vertex pregnancies was 32.2%, with a range of 18.5-84.6%. This wide variation was not reduced after risk adjustment or after exclusion of all women with induction indications. A similar wide variation was noted within geographic regions, neonatal intensive care levels, and among individual physicians in the same facility. Only very weak associations were found for the cesarean delivery rate after labor induction and either the rate after noninduced labor (R<0.08) or the rate of nulliparous labor induction (R<0.12). CONCLUSION: The large variation of cesarean delivery rates after induction of labor suggests that clinical management plays an important role in achieving induction success.
引用
- Main EK, Chang SC, Cheng YW, et al. Hospital-Level Variation in the Frequency of Cesarean Delivery Among Nulliparous Women Who Undergo Labor Induction. Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 33156193. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000004139
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。