新冠疫情下产前保健新模式的患者与提供者视角
本研究在某郊区学术机构评估了2020年3月20日实施的减少产检频率和虚拟就诊的新冠产前保健模式。实施后周均产检量下降16.1%,虚拟就诊比例从10.8%升至43.3%,取消预约率稳定。调查显示多数患者和提供者认为虚拟就诊改善可及性且安全,总体满意度较高。
要点
- 减少产检频率和虚拟就诊被快速整合,周均产检量降16.1%,虚拟就诊比例升至43.3%。
- 68.8%患者和96.1%提供者认为虚拟就诊改善可及性,53.3%患者和62.1%提供者认为安全。
- 77.5%患者和83.1%提供者对新冠产前保健模式满意。
核心结论
- 减少产检频率和虚拟就诊被快速整合到实际诊疗中,许多患者和提供者体验积极。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心评估,纳入2020年3月20日实施新冠产前保健模式的郊区学术机构。
- 通过电子健康记录评估实施前后3个月的就诊频率和虚拟就诊比例。
- 2020年5月对全部孕周>20周孕妇和提供者进行在线调查,评估可及性、质量与安全、满意度三个维度。
主要发现
- 实施后周均产检量从898次降至761次,下降16.1%。
- 周均虚拟产检比例从10.8%(97/898)升至43.3%(330/761)。
- 取消预约率保持稳定(实施前4.3%,实施后4.2%)。
- 68.8%患者(174/253)和96.1%提供者(74/77)认为虚拟就诊改善可及性。
- 53.3%患者(124/253)和62.1%提供者(41/77)认为虚拟就诊安全。
关键数值与推荐
- 提供者参与率74.8%(77/103),患者参与率15.0%(253/1690)。
- 患者受访者中白人占71.1%(180/253),商业保险占78.7%(199/253)。
- 提供者受访者中白人占66.7%(44/66),女性占75.8%(50/66)。
- 92.2%患者(213/231)和95.5%提供者(63/66)认为家用血压计对虚拟就诊重要。
临床怎么用
- 在疫情等特殊情况下可快速采用减少产检频率和虚拟就诊的产前保健模式。
- 虚拟就诊时家用血压计等设备对保障质量与安全很重要。
- 需关注虚拟就诊可及性不平等可能加深产科保健差异。
局限性
- 单中心研究,患者受访者以白人和商业保险为主,反映研究机构人群。
- 慢性病和妊娠并发症发生率与国家患病率不同。
- 患者调查参与率较低(15.0%)。
- 需在更多样化人群和疫情外环境研究健康结局与保健体验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Randomized controlled trials document the safety and efficacy of reduced frequency prenatal visit schedules and virtual visits, but real-world data are lacking. Our institution created a prenatal care delivery model incorporating these alternative approaches to continue safely providing prenatal care during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate institutional-level adoption and patient and provider experiences with the coronavirus disease 2019 prenatal care model. STUDY DESIGN: We conducted a single-site evaluation of a coronavirus disease 2019 prenatal care model incorporating a reduced frequency visit schedule and virtual visits deployed at a suburban academic institution on March 20, 2020. We used electronic health record data to evaluate institution-level model adoption, defined as changes in overall visit frequency and proportion of virtual visits in the 3 months before and after implementation. To evaluate the patient and provider experience with the coronavirus disease 2019 model, we conducted an online survey of all pregnant patients (>20 weeks' gestation) and providers in May 2020. Of note, 3 domains of care experience were evaluated: (1) access, (2) quality and safety, and (3) satisfaction. Quantitative data were analyzed with basic descriptive statistics. Free-text responses coded by the 3 survey domains elucidated drivers of positive and negative care experiences. RESULTS: After the coronavirus disease 2019 model adoption, average weekly prenatal visit volume fell by 16.1%, from 898 to 761 weekly visits; the average weekly proportion of prenatal visits conducted virtually increased from 10.8% (97 of 898) to 43.3% (330 of 761); and the average visit no-show rate remained stable (preimplementation, 4.3%; postimplementation, 4.2%). Of those eligible, 74.8% of providers (77 of 103) and 15.0% of patients (253 of 1690) participated in the surveys. Patient respondents were largely white (180 of 253; 71.1%) and privately insured (199 of 253; 78.7%), reflecting the study site population. The rates of chronic conditions and pregnancy complications also differed from national prevalence. Provider respondents were predominantly white (44 of 66; 66.7%) and female (50 of 66; 75.8%). Most patients and almost all providers reported that virtual visits improved access to care (patients, 174 of 253 [68.8%]; providers, 74 of 77 [96.1%]). More than half of respondents (patients, 124 of 253 [53.3%]; providers, 41 of 77 [62.1%]) believed that virtual visits were safe. Nearly all believed that home blood pressure cuffs were important for virtual visits (patients, 213 of 231 [92.2%]; providers, 63 of 66 [95.5%]). Most reported satisfaction with the coronavirus disease 2019 model (patients, 196 of 253 [77.5%]; providers, 64 of 77 [83.1%]). In free-text responses, drivers of positive care experiences were similar for patients and providers and included perceived improved access to care through decreased barriers (eg, transportation, childcare), perceived high quality of virtual visits for low-risk patients and increased safety during the pandemic, and improved satisfaction through better patient counseling. Perceived drivers of negative care experience were also similar for patients and providers, but less common. These included concerns that unequal access to virtual visits could deepen existing maternity care inequities, concerns that the lack of home devices (eg, blood pressure cuffs) would affect care quality and safety, and dissatisfaction with poor patient-provider continuity and inadequate expectation setting for the virtual visit experience. CONCLUSION: Reduced visit schedules and virtual visits were rapidly integrated into real-world care, with positive experiences for many patients and providers. Future research is needed to understand the health outcomes and care experience associated with alternative approaches to prenatal care delivery across more diverse patient populations outside of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic to inform broader health policy decisions.
引用
- Peahl AF, Powell A, Berlin H, et al. Patient and provider perspectives of a new prenatal care model introduced in response to the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 33039393. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2020.10.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。