盆腔器官脱垂术后成功与失败呈动态反复事件状态
该研究基于4项随机临床试验的1250例女性队列,分析盆腔器官脱垂术后解剖、主观和再治疗定义下成功与失败的重叠及随时间转换。结果显示仅13%失败者同时满足主客观失败标准,约四分之一失败为间歇性,多数最终随访时为成功状态。现行复合定义可能高估真实失败率。
要点
- 仅12.9%的失败者同时满足解剖和主观失败标准,多数仅满足单一组分。
- 24.2%的失败者在随访中在成功与失败间转换,其中83.8%末次随访为成功。
- 现行复合成功/失败定义可能高估手术失败率。
核心结论
- 盆腔器官脱垂术后真实失败率可能被现有文献高估,因仅少数患者同时满足主客观失败标准。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,纳入4项由Eunice Kennedy Shriver国家儿童健康与人类发展研究所盆底疾病网络开展的随机临床试验中1250例因≥II期盆腔器官脱垂手术的女性。
主要发现
- 1250例中433例(34.6%)在至少一个时间点出现手术失败结局。
- 首次失败评估时,85.5%(370/433)仅满足复合结局的一个组分:解剖失败46.7%(202/433)、主观失败36.7%(159/433)、再治疗2.1%(9/433)。
- 仅12.9%(56/433)同时满足解剖和主观失败标准。
- 24.2%(105/433)在随访中在成功与失败间转换,其中83.8%(88/105)末次随访为成功。
- 成功或失败分类与1年和2年质量调整生命年相关,且对盆腔器官脱垂困扰量表简表6维度健康指数评分存在时变组效应。
关键数值与推荐
- 手术失败复合定义需满足以下至少一项:解剖失败(POP-Q点Ba、Bp或C>0)、主观失败(存在困扰性阴道膨出症状)、或使用子宫托或再次手术治疗脱垂。
- 成功与失败评估时间点为术后3或6、12、24、36、48和60个月。
临床怎么用
- 临床解读脱垂手术结局时应认识到成功与失败可随时间动态转换,避免仅凭单一时点复合定义判定失败。
- 与患者沟通预后时,可说明多数间歇性失败最终仍处于成功状态。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The ideal measure of success after surgery for pelvic organ prolapse has long been debated. Historically, strict definitions based on anatomic perfection have dominated the literature. However, the importance of patient-centered perception of outcomes is equally or more important when comparing the success of various prolapse surgeries. Understanding the limitations of existing outcome definitions will guide surgical outcome reporting and comparisons of pelvic organ prolapse surgeries. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to describe the relationships and overlap among the participants who met the anatomic, subjective, and retreatment definitions of success or failure after pelvic organ prolapse surgery; demonstrate rates of transition between success and failure over time; and compare scores from the Pelvic Organ Prolapse Distress Inventory, Short-Form Six-Dimension health index, and quality-adjusted life years among these definitions. STUDY DESIGN: Definitions of surgical success were evaluated at 3 or 6, 12, 24, 36, 48, and 60 months after surgery for ≥stage II pelvic organ prolapse in a cohort of women (N=1250) from 4 randomized clinical trials conducted by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Pelvic Floor Disorders Network. Surgical failure was defined by a composite measure requiring 1 or more of (1) anatomic failure (Pelvic Organ Prolapse Quantification point Ba, Bp, or C of >0), (2) subjective failure (presence of bothersome vaginal bulge symptoms), or (3) pessary or surgical retreatment for pelvic organ prolapse. Pelvic Organ Prolapse Distress Inventory, Short-Form Six-Dimension health index, and quality-adjusted life years were compared among participants who met a variety of definitions of success and failure including novel "intermittent" success and failure over time. RESULTS: Among the 433 of 1250 women (34.6%) who had surgical failure outcomes at ≥1 time point, 85.5% (370 of 433) met only 1 component of the composite outcome at the assessment of initial failure (anatomic failure, 46.7% [202 of 433]; subjective failure, 36.7% [159 of 433]; retreatment, 2.1% [9 of 433]). Only 12.9% (56 of 433) met the criteria for both for anatomic and subjective failure. Despite meeting the criteria for failure in primary study reporting, 24.2% of these (105 of 433) transitioned between success and failure during follow-up, of whom 83.8% (88 of 105) met the criteria for success at their last follow-up. There were associations between success or failure classification and the 1- and 2-year quality-adjusted life years and a time-varying group effect on Pelvic Organ Prolapse Distress Inventory and Short-Form Six-Dimension health index scores. CONCLUSION: True failure rates after prolapse surgery may be overestimated in the current literature. Only 13% of clinical trial subjects initially met both subjective and objective criteria for failure. Approximately one-quarter of failures were intermittent and transitioned between success and failure over time, with most intermittent failures being in a state of "surgical success" at their last follow-up. Current composite definitions of success or failure may result in the overestimation of surgical failure rates, potentially explaining, in part, the discordance with low retreatment rates after pelvic organ prolapse surgery.
引用
- Jelovsek JE, Gantz MG, Lukacz E, et al. Success and failure are dynamic, recurrent event states after surgical treatment for pelvic organ prolapse. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 33039390. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2020.10.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。